John & Yoko: Above Us Only Sky (TV Movie 2018) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
27 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Imagine a genius at work
Lejink21 December 2018
Well (well well), Lennon is my favourite rock star and "Imagine" is one of my all-time favourite albums so this documentary centring on his recording of that very record was always going to be right down my strasse. Actually taking in his career and activities from a couple of years before, when he first hooked up with Yoko Ono and they formed the Plastic Ono Band, it's a fascinating insight into the man that "Time" magazine voted as one of the men of the decade just past when this was shot.

This was therefore the period when Lennon, soon to up sticks permanently to New York after just a couple of years at the sprawling country grounds of Tittenhurst Park where most of this film was made, was living a gadfly existence as outside of his recording duties we see him out on the road promoting Yoko's book "Grapefruit", following through on his political activism by attending protest marches as well as making himself generally available for interviews with both the music and the popular press, the latter keen to lampoon his peacenik happenings.

The film employs the usual technique of talking head commentaries, some from over-adulatory outsiders and the more interesting ones from those who were either in Lennon's band at the time, like drummer Alan White and bassist Klaus Voormann or were part of his staff. Whilst the film gives almost equal attention to Yoko, there's no question in my mind as to who the real deal is here. Whether expounding his utopian vision for peace on earth, discussing revolutionary politics with Tariq Ali, leading his band through his new songs or most candidly, taking in an obviously damaged Beatles fan who just turns up at his door (and look where that openness to his public led him), he comes across, at least to me, as a sharp, witty, playful guy, one you'd enjoy spending time with. Yes I'm aware of his self-confessed human flaws but even grown up son Julian speaks well of his old man here and that's good enough for me.

The music is absolutely terrific too with snippets of every track from the album heard in one incarnation or another although personally I wish there was more of it shown.

This in summary then is a fine fly-on-the-wall documentary showing a musical giant at his very considerable best.
27 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Repackaging "Imagine" footage for the fourth time
sendspamhere-688685 May 2021
Since 1972 roughly every 10-15 years the footage collected from the Imagine album recording sessions is repackaged into a new film/documentary. So you will watch the same scenes in either:

Imagine (1972) - the original film, mostly cheesy a music special Imagine: John Lennon (1988) - a more expansive look into John's life Gimme Some Truth (2000) - more focused on the recording sessions Above Us Only The Sky (2018) - the most recent repackaging

It seems redundant to watch them all but all of them have different goals. I found Gimme Some Truth the most enjoyable because the footage itself tells the history and the focus is the music.

Above Us Only The Sky in other hand feels MORE LIKE a PR piece with the function of maintaining the Lennon's image of a pacifist and raising Yoko's profile. Not a bad documentary but too thin. It features some forgettable present day interviews with people involved with Lennon at the time. The most noteworthy appearance is of Julian Lennon, often at odds with Yoko.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Genius and humanity
paul2001sw-13 December 2018
For eight years, the Beatles rewrote the rules of popular music. After they split up, they were never to reach the same heights as individuals. Except, perhaps, for John Lennon's 'Imagine' album, his first record after the break-up. The album was recorded at his home studio, a process that was mostly recorded on film. That film, coupled with the obligatory sequence of talking heads, has now been recycled into this documentary. Why is it good? Well, because Lennon was (at his peak) brilliant, which makes the insight into how he made his music innately more interesting than the average film of this type. But it also makes a strong case for the (positive) influence that his wife Yoko Ono had on him, and suggests persuasively that the album was very much a product of their shared life, although once it was completed, they abandoned their English country home forever. It's a very human picture of a genius; there's (almost invetably) a measure of sycophancy to it, but it's still well worth watching.
17 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Thank You Yoko
mossbaybotanicals5 May 2019
I've heard Yoko mention throughout the years that she had 'never before' seen footage of John. This is it and I'm grateful she has finally shared it with the world. This is Yoko's heart on a platter, her private life with John I'm certain was very very painful to let go of. These clips were obviously cherished memories that she held close to her heart and were difficult to share because these were her memories, not for the public. Thank you for opening your heart and sharing with us those memories of John. Very tastefully done.
17 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Loved it!
mckat-2534321 May 2019
Beautiful. Yoko, you got a bad rap. Peace and love, everyone should watch this just to see the crazy evolution of our culture, as well as the maddening stagnency.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Familiar Territory, But Worth A Watch
AlGranthamMusic7 May 2019
Stumbled upon this film and figured it would be a lame re-hash of the previous "Imagine" documentary. To my pleasant surprise, it felt like there was footage I hadn't seen before. I enjoyed pretty much the entirety of it.

This is a portrait of Lennon in transition, newly free from the shackled of then-fraught Beatles. He seems a lot more relaxed and chilled out then just a couple years prior, and it's nice to see.

I appreciated the documentary spending some time crediting Yoko's positive influence (for once) on songs like Imagine and others. Whatever your opinions of the woman is, it can't be denied that we got a huge amount of amazing music from her time as Lennon's muse.

There's a number of talking heads without much interesting things to say. Basically just heaping praise, which dragged the film down a bit I felt. More interesting were the stories from the engineers and other musicians in terms of Lennon's recording process.

All in all, a nice appetizer for the upcoming Peter Jackson helmed Beatles doc of their time recording Let It Be.

Worth a watch.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beautiful
ayahsheart16 May 2019
This is truly a must see film. It covers the conscience of a generation that wasn't ready to give up hope. It takes us into the life and relationship of John and Yoko with a perspective we haven't seen yet.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
John by Yoko
bastos24 July 2020
Your enjoyment on documentaries about artists often depend on how much you like the artists. If you're a huge fan of John Lennon you're gonna love the insight this doc brings into the making of Imagine, if you don't like either John or Yoko you'll find more reasons to hate them. I'm a bit indifferent and thought it was quite informative and enjoyed it for the insight into the mind of one of music's biggest influences.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Just wonderful....
lorranw23 May 2019
I was amazed at the unseen footage. It was well edited and thoughtfully done, with interviews of people telling nuggets of details about the album. He was an incredible human being - and his message is needed even more now with the problems we're facing across the globe.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
John & especially Yoko
dromasca11 October 2019
The documentary 'John & Yoko: Above Us Only Sky' can be considered as a post-trauma movie. The Beatles fans who are today at or near retirement age were experiencing a traumatic period 50 years ago. The internal conflicts between the members of the group had become more and more visible - in the absence of their public appearances, in the photographs and the filmed sequences in which they seemed more and more distant and extinguished from each other, in the independent creative initiatives of each one, and especially in the music of their latest albums. The inevitable news of the break-up would be made public only in April 1970. Then, and from then until now, fans have split into two camps: those who believe that the main blame belongs to Paul and those who throw the guilt on John and especially on the influence of Yoko Ono . The film made by Michael Epstein does not elucidate this dispute which I think will continue in eternity, but brings solid and documented arguments for Yoko's historical and artistic rehabilitation.

Separation was probably inevitable. Each of the four had his own strong and original personality. And yet, after their break-up, their individual careers failed to create, separately or put together, almost anything that came close to what they had created together in the seven years during which they had revolutionized music history. One of the few exceptions is the song 'Imagine' from the album of the same name, released by John in 1971, a manifest song for a whole generation, divinely inspired in its music, words and message, since then on the first places in all the tops of 20th century songs. The film is largely based on the material filmed (in huge quantities) during the making of the album and on the much publicized aspects of John and Yoko's life in the years before and immediately after the Beatles split. Added to these are interviews filmed with Yoko, Julian (John's son from the first marriage), musicians, technicians, assistants, friends during that period. Almost all the arsenal we can expect from such a documentary is present here.

What I liked: Some of John and Yoko's private video footage was interesting and new, at least to me. Some of the studio scenes introduced the viewers to the process of creating the album and especially the song 'Imagine'. The image of Yoko Ono, as an artist, as a militant, and as a supporter of John's life and creation, is much more nuanced and interesting than the schematic and caricature portrait that exists in much of her public image. Each scene in which John appears makes us realize even more painfully and more acutely what a huge loss his murder represented. What I liked less: The 'talking heads' selection was obviously polarized, none of those who had differing opinions about the reasons for the Beatles' separation or Yoko's influence had any say in this film. Equally biased is the reflection of John and Yoko's political activity. Those who want to approach history (or the present) objectively know that the protest movements like the ones the two were associated with had a justification in the context of that time and a positive influence up to a certain point. But the truth about the Vietnam War, atomic disarmament, and other commendable causes was far more complex. It's the same phenomenon that we can find in fact today in the movement that claim to be anti-globalization, pro-ecological, etc. The film idealizes the policies of John and Yoko and allows neither a different opinion nor a more balanced analysis. Finally, as with any music documentary, I expected more ... music. Here the talk / music ratio is far too unbalanced to the detriment of music. 'John & Yoko: Above Us Only Sky' offers a facet of John's life and activity, but manages to be just one piece of a much more complex puzzle.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Inspiring and Heartbreaking
jimbecker19566 August 2020
I'm not a film critic but I am a big documentary fan and lived through the Beatles and John Lennon's life. (I'm 63). I learned a lot I didn't know from this documentary, mostly about John and Yoko's relationship and how she was really his muse. To be honest I mostly thought of her as the strange woman who howled unintelligibly and broke up the Beatles. But there's so much more to the story. This is a film about music, love, social change, war, art and the media (and a lot more!). I would say there are a few too many talking head interviews but none of them are superfluous and they all add to the story and commentary. Just wish I could have seen more of John and Yoko (there's a lot but the film alludes to thousands of hours of film). Mostly I was left inspired by their creativity and willingness to take on the critics and the media and blaze their own path. Their idealism and vision was so beautiful and yet the world is an even darker place today. Yet we can always Imagine and that gives hope.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
seductive
Kirpianuscus2 March 2020
Not different by many other biographic films, it is the portrait of the genesis of an emblematic song. Seductive for confessions and pieces of real life and seductive for the grace to define a time, for generosity of Yoko Ono Lennon and for the wise footage, it represents a remember and inspired definition of the art and its seed - the relation between so special people.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good documentary about a legendary song
fischer_patrick28 March 2022
This is a good film. It had a ton of archival footage from home movies to interviews. All this past footage was expertly edited together with present day interviews with those who were around John and Yoko during the time Imagine was recorded. It told a compelling story that illuminates John and Yoko's relationship and their creative visions and processes. Well done film.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Nothing new
azeemnavarro13 July 2019
If you think that this documentary is only about the creation of "Imagine"; well, unfortunately you're wrong. In this hour and a half film, you only get like 25 minutes about the classical album, the rest of it it's about the relationship of John & Yoko: how they met, how they falled in love, how they complemented the art of each other... sounds familiar, right? And it is, you know all this, even if you're not a big Lennon fan. Something that bugged me it's that everyone that appears here put Yoko in a pedestal, like this amazing but missunderstood artist and person, that all the press and Beatles fans just hated for no reason. Maybe this people don't know nothing about art (i know that may sound disrespectful), or the not so good things she has done. I know the song Imagine is all about peace, but this film didn't needed to be about it, they spent so much runtime about how war is awful and blah, blah, blah. Yeah, I know. I just wanted to watch this for some extra insight on an album, but the director kinda forgot what the sinopsis for this was in the first place. This documentary is harmless, pretty, innocent. But is also unnecesary, more if you're well informed in this stage of the life of this two.
9 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Peace and love, tea and ciggies
babybuletgani8 November 2019
Peace and love, tea and ciggies... More than a mere 'story of the album', director Michael Epstein's doc mounts a vividly humanising study of Lennon/Ono circa 1971's Imagine. An absorbing picture of two deeply entwined idealists caught in fame's glare emerges between the raretreasure home vids and new interviews, deepened by insights into peoplepower, the Beatles and politics. And whenever the fan worship gets windy, Lennon's quick, warm wit is on-hand to keep things grounded.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Imagine
westsideschl22 November 2019
Watched this, not expecting a great deal, but after a slightly slow start the almost non-stop professional video that someone had the foresight (or was it just chance or some other reason) of John's life before & during his time with Yoko was captivating & informative. Sprinkled in were period photos & some current interviews w/people present at that time. Foremost were insights into the process of creating a song w/emphasis on the song of the century "Imagine". Artists capture inspiration (knowingly & unknowingly) throughout life that contribute/shape what they become & create.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
you may say i'm a dreamer...
shirlone9 December 2021
John Lennon was a very talented musician who left us all too soon. There's no question The Beatles owned the 60's but by the time the 70's rolled around you had Beach Boys and other groups. This is a very well put together documentary movie and you could see just how much Yoko's influence had on John. This movie is worth watching.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Everything beautiful...
RosanaBotafogo13 June 2022
"Only Heaven About Us" about the most famous couple in international rock, nice to see how they both lived away from the spotlight, with the presence of John's eldest son, the birth of Lennon's most beautiful, painful and sad song, and about the openly known Jhon vs Paul feud, in addition to the injustice Yoko, stoned for loving... Everything beautiful...
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"Yes" is the Answer: Guided Tour of Life at Tittenhurst circa 1971
Ian_Jules26 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
A lovely--and loving--portrait of John&Yoko during during the recording of Imagine and the transitional period that carried them from the English countryside to NYC, this documentary film has plenty to offer well-versed Lennon/Ono fans, and is certainly worth a look for newcomers in search of readily available material exploring Lennon's life and music.

Private footage of Lennon and Ono-- recording the Imagine album at their home studio, relaxing with Lennon's son Julian and various friends, and generally making the most of life on the sumptuous Tittenhurst estate-- is extensive, more than has been shown before, and this is likely the key asset for aficionados. Those who know the narrative and the people involved will recognize most of the talking heads, but the best insights come from the session guys: Jim Keltner, Klaus Voorman, and Alan White offer warm, solid perspectives on the music on the atmosphere of the studio. One only wishes George Harrison, who is seen in the archival footage working out his solo for How Do you Sleep? and, in a lovely moment, seeking Yoko's input on which acoustic guitar tone she preferred for another cut, were alive to contribute his recollections.

The documentary contextualizes the album, and John & Yoko's relationship, in the political and countercultural zeitgeist of the times, giving more or less equal attention to Yoko's concept art as to Lennon's music, showing how their bodies of work overlap and complement one another. Audiences will be divided over Yoko's work, as well as the political implications of John & Yoko's message. But the message, which carries from the music to the film, is a life-affirming and hopeful one, grounded in a vision of peace, communication, and human harmony.

Some of the comments on this site referring to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor are dramatically and depressingly missing the point. There are no innocent parties in war, and Pearl Harbor is not an excuse, morally speaking, for the suffering of many innocent Japanese people. Most of us cannot say that we have experienced the impacts of war first hand, as Yoko did in her childhood. The point is to learn from her experiences, not hand-wave them because "we didn't start it".

Human suffering is equally traumatic and atrocious, whether it's Pearl harbor, the London Blitz, or atomic bombs. Disregarding this truth in favor of preserving our comfortable historical narratives is not simply inhumane. Valuing geopolitical rivalry and national pride over human lives leads directly to the perpetuation of conflict and cycles of vengeance.

In the words of songwriter and activist Tommy Sands, "Peace is the prize for those who are daring". Dare to imagine.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perhaps flawed film ? but the subject matter overcomes all
awvknj16 April 2022
It's hard to find words to reflect the emotion this film brings forth ...its intimacy ...the heart of John's music. Loved the offhand nuggets in John's own voice and words after the segment recording of How Do You Sleep he commented "My lyrics are published his are not so you have to listen hard" to catch the snide comments (referring to Ram) and then said something about the siblings rivalry he had with Paul- "just had dinner with him last week so he can't be too mad about it." And later in his own recorded words from 1980 acknowledging that Imagine was co-written with Yoko but he was too "macho" at the time it was published to acknowledge her contribution. His own words !! What is there to argue with here?

John and Yoko were in a storm of celebrity frenzy during a time of huge personal chaos. They both saw a unique opportunity to spin the attention toward a global conversation -To open hearts and minds to the possibilities of what we can do as individuals and collectively. Born out of the events of the previous decade -in this context the song Imagine is a prayer, a vision for our survival and that of the planet really.

Together he and Yoko channeled a vision that lives on in hearts and minds; hopefully continues to inspire not only my generation but this generation and future generations toward what is possible. It starts with imagining that it is possible !!! How would it feel if this was truly happening? And feeling that hope rise within ... no matter how much it seems that oppression and pain will never end.

John really was just a man - a flawed and brilliant one who did his best to rise above his inner conflict. Thank you John and thank you Yoko; For showing us that even though we don't really know how to love we can choose to try and keep choosing moment by moment to be vulnerable and open to doing that.

Imagine Peace.... How can I be that today in a world filled with aggression and aggravation? How can I move forward when I don't know? Just as he shares in the music, In spite of messy mistakes and miscommunications. Keep Starting Over. Imagine Peace.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nice Sequel to 2021 Get Back Series
polsixe5 December 2021
A similar look at John Lennon and Yoko in life and work a year or so after the Jan 69 events of the latest film. The Beatles have broken up, John is cleaned up, happy and Yoko as the muse leads to the Imagine album. Once again the creative process is Lennon on a piano with an assortment of session musicians following along, including George. Some insight into the bitterness with Paul and the move to New York. Also a fair look at Yoko and her own history as an artist. A more traditional rockumentary with the people who were there adding context 47 years later.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Imagine a Co-dependent Ego-trip
tigerfish5011 May 2019
Reaction to this routine documentary probably depends on how much a viewer admires this famous couple. The film relates how an art gallery encounter between a tormented pop idol and an obscure conceptual artist subsequently resulted in a celebrity romance and music album. Various witnesses and participants are filmed delivering their recollections of this epic moment in popular culture, with most of their contributions expressing breathless admiration of John's song 'Imagine', as if this were the first time a songwriter had lamented mankind's divisions and the folly of war.

There's also plenty of archival footage depicting the pair's early relationship, with Yoko's creepy gazes at her paramour remaining the most vivid impression. To the detached eye it looks more like compulsive co-dependency than immortal love affair, but others might disagree. Yoko is described as an important artist, although cynics might raise an eyebrow over her haste to sideline this vocation in order to piggyback onto John's rock career. The interviewees speak of the couple's songs, sleep-ins, demos and press conference proclamations as world-changing events, but nobody took their antics very seriously - much as the art world has ignored Yoko's lightweight artistic conceits.
11 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Good start, then goes right off a cliff.
deanbean31710 May 2019
When this movie dealt with what John Lennon was, a musical genius, it was awesome! Watching the songs we all know and love starting out as nebulous demos, being crafted into finished gems was fascinating. But then the whole enterprise took an extreme left turn and became a geopolitical rant about America's involvement in every military skirmish from WWII to Vietnam. I realize that the happenings in the world had a great influence on John's music, but when they started rebuking the United States over the bombing of Japan in WWII, I had seen enough. I'll just rewatch Beatles Anthology, which was indeed, all about the music
8 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Complete nonsense about Yoko's "contribution" long debunked by scholars of Lennon
random-7077827 October 2019
I am not a Yoko hater. But I do believe in the facts. I suggest people take a read of any of the scholarly biographies to learn this film is complete nonsense.

Lennon had severe problems with women, specifically "performance " and inadequacy issues and also violent behavior toward women. he did not just strike women he sometimes beat them. That his relationship with Yoko Ono who was apparently willing to accept the former, and calm down the latter, made him a better man and really a better creator in some aspects of his music is attested to. That Ono herself contributed in any meaningful way with any of his better post Beatles work is not supported whatsoever.
4 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Great Documentary Format
Peridot_Ice4 June 2020
Absolutely loved John Lennon's "Imagine". I happened to be in Central Park when Yoko Ono dedicated a purchased corner of the park viewable from their apartment to John calling it Strawberry Fields complete with a stone labeled Imagine. The only part of this documentary that I found inaccurate was the references to the US bombing Japan as if we started that war. No dates were given, but extensively talking about Yoko's hardships due to the bombing was in a context of the US being a predator without reason. Japan bombed Pearl Harbor BEFORE the US retaliated.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed