Glossary of Broken Dreams (2018) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
25 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Wunderwelt of Politics
D_Ogusa20 April 2018
In a wild collage of puppets, pixels, stop motion and live action stock footage, Austrian auteur Johannes Grenzfurthner gives us an insight into his mind and ideology with this cinematic revue about politics.

At its core, "Glossary Of Broken Dreams" is a rant against society in form of a list of words and concepts. A glossary of today's issues. The why's and how's. The way it's all put together is amusing. So was I entertained? Yes. Yes I was. Even though it was a little fast for the information being presented... it was still entertaining.

Check it out. I will definitely rewatch it.
38 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Colorful documentary
internetfreieminuten30 April 2018
A colorful film about politics and the problems of political thinking in the age of internet culture. It is insightful and very funny. Only problem I have is that it is a bit too fast. It is almost impossible to follow all the threads, references and jokes. I'm not an English native speaker, so maybe that's part of the problem, but, very well deserved 7 stars from me. Hope that there will German subtitles in the future....
41 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
If you have any aspirations towards social responsibility, it's well worth a watch but don't expect any earth-shattering or life-changing insights.
iantrader20 May 2018
It's like Johannes Grenzfurthner just finished courses in politics and film-making and wanted to combine the two.

Ostensibly, he sets out to break down the big words and the buzzwords surrounding politics and society but virtually all of the definitions are so replete with buzzwords themselves that you may find yourself being only slightly wiser. Still, that's better than not be any wiser at all.

It's an interesting take on our modern situation. But who's to say if it's correct or not?

It IS a documentary and, unfortunately, it offers no solution; it simply presents the problems and, essentially, says we're all responsible Ah, shame. But unsurprising.

If you have any aspirations towards social responsibility, it's well worth a watch but don't expect any earth-shattering or life-changing insights.
9 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Rubbish
jonoau17 May 2018
Maybe it's because I'm not American but this is complete crap.
17 out of 69 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
It's like Tumblr took the form of a video.
danrtoner19 May 2018
It's so unbearable to watch that their "message" falls short. This might possibly be the worst thing that I've ever seen.

"Puppets. Pixels. Anime. Live action. Stock footage." is in the description. Let's just go ahead and change that to: "Stock footage. Cringe. Stock footage on a loop. Cringe. More Cringe."

The thing has a "trigger warning" in the opening credits! It's so bad. It's like Tumblr took the form of a video.

I'm a far left liberal saying that these people hurt more than they help. Nut up, this is why we lose elections. Know why the right wins? They don't look like a pack of pu--ys.

If you're thinking about watching this, just read the description, because if you can survive that then sure, waste your 2 hours and go make a tumblr account.

Zero stars. Never make anything ever again. Grow up and nut up.
15 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
glossary of broken modernity
romantic-gorn18 May 2018
I think this is a very important movie and should reach as many people as possible. self-reflective hyper-modernity at its best.
33 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Imagine you have no Imagination
BorisKarpov17 May 2018
Imagine you have no creativity or talents, but you have a huge ego. Then imagine that you try to explain a world, that you don't understand yourself, by putting together fragments and clusters of nonsense and selling that as art or a documentary. That is exactly what this "Glossary of Broken Dream" is. This "glossary" has no information to provide, only pseudo intellectual sketches, empty phrases, and bad attempt at explaining our world with the mind of a hamster on drugs. This is a piece of rubbish that everyone should avoid.
17 out of 72 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very enjoyable buffer overflow!
Velocerix17 April 2018
I saw GOBD at the Vermont International Film Festival. Loved every overbearing second of it. I'd call it a braindump on stages of disappointments with persistent political ideologies. Being embedded deeply in leftist, political nerd culture, the movie tries to address topics in depth, and as the filmmaker stated in the Q&A, he couldn't have dumbed it down further. It's also a marvelous trip through film styles and packed with popcultural inside jokes. Buffer overflow! (Can't believe I'm giving a doc with a political agenda 8 stars. I've never done that before! I usually like films about animals!)
39 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Garbage
kilic-118 May 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Anti-capitalalist hit piece that alleges that Ayn Rand died poor and on welfare. While she may have been on social security during her later years she died with a worth of over a million dollars. This is typical liberal strategy. Propaganda at best.
12 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Leftist Garbage
TheKekistani10 July 2018
Totally biased and completely one sided, nothing but a colorful piece of propaganda hinting us how nice and flowery a socialist alternative would be.
5 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Poor cinematography
info-241-30942819 January 2019
Although I mostly agree with the topics of the film but It's so hard to watch and I stoped the movie at the half and try to watch it later due to the very under talented voice over and the fast moving story I couldn't help to resist more to the horrible mind of the producer at my second attemp.

Great concept can just be spoiled like this. Good topic but very poor film. Those awards were just given because of the political views of the film not for the cinema talent...
2 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ultimately pointless nerdgasm of overused tropes
Radu_A19 May 2019
First of all, this is not a documentary but an essay. Some reviewers seem to be a bit confused about what genre this is, mainly because the heyday of essay film was in the 60s-80s. Google Chris Marker.

Then some people don't know who the director Johannes Grenzfurthner is. He is a very Austrian phenomenon of multimedia philosopher, a bit like Slavoj Zizek but more cynical. He's done a lot of social theory parodies before this film, so don't let the amateurish production misguide you.

Now for the problems. As rather typical for our current cerebral climate, there is a veritable smorgasbord of social issues addressed here, some in a rather cliché 1960s Marxist way (hard to figure out if that's parody), some in rather original, thought-provoking ways (like the segment on media culture in which Politics consults a shrink in early 1990s 8bit video game animation).

The best point: US-style particularized social movements foster inequality, because they demand more individual rights at the cost of the common good. But then one waits for a resolution, some sort of proposal for taking action, and there isn't any. The biggest weakness of the film therefore: starting a lot of conversations, and then let these peter out into nowhere. This becomes increasingly frustrating as one realizes that there will be no proposition at the end of the film, and indeed: it just ends (clumsily).

Grenzfurthner correctly criticizes at various points the currently hip dismissal of Constructivism, but in not really coming up with anything but concluding that society is effed up, he inadvertently confirms critics who view postmodernists as vacuous relativists. To which I would have said: You know, the murkiness of perpetual uncertainty feels pretty safe compared to the battleground of competing absolute truths.

And as much as I hate the term "mansplaining", that's exactly what much of this film amounts to: Men talking vividly about stuff without checking if anyone cares.

Feel frustrated because there are so many questions but no answers? How about reading some books? Google Ulrich Beck, Anthony Giddens, Silvio Gesell for instance (don't stop there, i.e. Montaigne never gets old).

Find the sections of the film talking about liberalism incomprehensible because you are not Austrian? Google Austrian School / Viennese School of Economics.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gleefully taking apart buzzwords
StanleyLamarche21 April 2018
"Glossary of Broken Dreams" definitely has an interesting concept: what kind of buzzwords do we use in our (social media thread) bubbles, but most people don't really understand what they mean? Through a series of short vignettes and using pop culture as the prime example, that concept succeeds in more ways than one. It's one of more entertaining documentaries I've seen and it's massively thought-provoking. Highly recommended!
35 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A set of tools
GOD1zilla19 April 2018
It was Mark Fisher who pointed out that capitalist reality always needs a certain level of anti-capitalism to become tolerable. This film definitely gets into your head, it tackles some of your inner beliefs, yet, of course, it cannot fundamentally change anything. Critique is its own category, its own precious thing. It simply shows us what's wrong, even gives a couple of suggestions what we could do better, but in the end, political critique is nothing more than a friendly invitation. You accept it, or you don't. Either way, after watching Glossary of Broken Dreams you will have learned a lot. What you do with your new mental tools is up to you.
38 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sesame Street for adults
hund-1974130 April 2018
Finally a good film from Austria. Why am I not surprised that it's a low budget production and that the filmmaker is an artist? Austrian cinema can be so boring and pretentious. Please excuse my bashing of Austrian films...maybe I'm biased but here is a film that does exactly what it promises: entertain and explain the world...almost like a Sesame Street for adults...a rich tapestry of styles & information. I think it will be one of those films that i will rewatch in a couple of years and say... yes, it was right about it all.
41 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Be warned
iamthefanbase16 May 2018
Not a classic documentary. Very unsual combination of political comedy and high-level academic theory. Sounds strange, is strange, but I couldn't stop watching. "Monty Python" plus "The Big Short" plus "Muppets."

I, for one, welcome our new socialist overlords.
40 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What genre is this?
brubaker-979-65909920 April 2018
Another feat by director-writer-actor Johannes Grenzfurthner. He pulls off an almost impossible task: being seriously funny while being dead serious.

I don't even think this film can be considered a documentary. Nothing is documented, not even re-enacted, and it's also not a mockumentary or docufiction. It uses whimsical narrative and musical elements to explain political theory and philosophy. I think Grenzfurthner created his own little genre. Docufarce? Documentravesty?
40 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Hilarious
anton-korngold19 May 2018
Shameless plug for the Glossary of Broken Dreams, which I saw last night. Deleuze, Latour, Marx, Foucault and loads more but my favorite was the scene where the American President explains the Global Economy and Labour Economics with green slime.
33 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
New Commons!
amindboggling20 April 2018
'Glossary of Broken Dreams' is a colorful and imaginative film about the problems of the 21st century, but addressing them through the lens of old ideas (aka ideologies). An alternative tag line could be: "We can only shape the future if we understand the past."

The film openly promotes the idea of New Commons. This relates to network-based cooperation and localized bottom-up initiatives that often work outside of dominant markets and traditional state programs. Another world can be born out of the understanding and fostering of these notions.

The reality of a globalized world where migration, climate change, technology, capital have long surpassed any national borders is already here. We need to start getting realistic about this and seriously explore new answers. This film gives an in-depths analysis of the status quo and possible blueprint for solutions. Plus puppets. Win win.
40 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
You love it or you hate it
misterprezz20 May 2018
From communism to capitalism, media manipulations to general public opinion, technological and software advancements, right to freedom and privacy, Grenzfurthner doesn't leave any stone unturned. It doesn't take long for one to understand that he would rather provoke, insinuate or challenge his audience than mollycoddle them. I dare to say: It doesn't matter if you are a conservative or a liberal, but if you share a common sense of humor, you will get something out of this film. You love it or you hate it.
33 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
an entertaining trip through leftist politics
youngsterphat19 May 2018
An interesting and funny film. you can learn a lot, but it's also self-aware and ironic. it's a given that conservatives hate on it - but it's really important for left-leaning people because it offers a lot of valid criticism about the left itself - e.g. haven't heard such a good dissection of identity politics in a long time.
32 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Well worth a watch
Gunner-Ahlberg23 May 2018
This is actually a really unique and thought provoking documentary, it's kind of like what you might get if you had the south park or monty python boys trying to explain social and political theory. It's very off kilter in its approach, but entertainingly so, and it probably tries to fit too much into its running time, but if you have the interest and the attention span, and an open enough mind willing to hear other opinions that may or may not match your own views, this is well worth a watch.
21 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Flaws in the current political systems
beat_priest18 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I wrote this short paper for class, so why not post it here as well...

Glossary of Broken Dreams is an essayistic documentary film produced by art group monochrom. The movie that is directed by Johannes Grenzfurthner features prominent thespians, such as Amber Benson and Max Grodenchik. It explores political concepts and ideologies, such as freedom and privacy, that are important to a society but seem to be incomprehensible. At the beginning of the film, the director stated that the problem he experienced when directing it is that he had to be real and logical, whereas the real-life situations he was trying to mimic were the exact opposite. The film which is ninety-eight minutes long starts with the director, Johannes Grenzfurthners, narrating the story to the audience. This film utilizes short clips and chapters that feature fictional and exaggerated characters with a great sense of humor. The movie did not feature any interviews as most documentaries do, neither did the director site any source. With the development of the storyline, the basic rules and norms of a capitalist society are introduced. This is a community where the political system and operations are under the control of private owners. It went further to highlight how these societies function. The episode featuring capitalism was played by actors Stuart Freeman and Conny Lee, and it successfully explores the norms and rules of a capitalist society. The principles of fairness and justice where highlighted, as well. The film goes further and explores competition as another political concept. It highlights the advantages such as the improved quality of services that are associated with a competitive system. In the episode that featured this concept, the film explores other concepts such as biological evolution, which was a deviation from the political nature of the film. The movie continues to express the media and data privacy as very sensitive aspects of life in the current society. Fake news has become common in the media industry. The film ridicules unethical habits of the media, and the opinion that the society is entitled to the truth is clearly communicated to the audience. The freedom of speech should be upheld and utilized to inform the society. The film also takes its audience through the evolution of privacy as a value over the years and demonstrates how important it is to individuals. Not much is being done to protect the privacy of individuals in the postmodern era. The film also criticizes the influence of governmental power on the privacy of its citizens. Currently, governments can retrieve and use personal data from the citizens without their approval, which is considered wrong. Through most of its scenes, the film criticizes the status quo in the society. For instance, in the part that features 'the left', which is a political affiliation, its inability to think is vividly expressed. The movie suggests that this political group has never abandoned its outdated ways of handling political issues such as blame games. Overall, the director successfully highlights the flaws in the current political systems and suggests the way forward. Despite the fact that there are no interviews used in the film, the director successfully highlights the flows of the political systems in a current society, proving that he commands a high level of political information and knowledge.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good intentions
thatiguanodon10 June 2018
I love JG's take on making movies. Learned about him through his film 'Traceroute' -- and I'm glad he is at it again. I enjoyed this one even more, simply because it's uncompromising AF. A quote by Nietzsche comes to mind: "The man of knowledge must be able not only to love his enemies but also to hate his friends." The film's tag line says it all. It is a film about (good) intentions, about how to make the world a better place. Will we succeed? Maybe not. Trying is all that counts.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Definitely debatable - in this very sense
redfox-635959 August 2018
Interesting documentary on (anti-)capitalism, activism and the - in the eyes of the creator - possibly disenchanted state of the political left itself. While obviously a labour of love and while a lot was created with very little, the content itself is definitely debatable, as already stated in the title. Many statements and conclusions seem very idealistic and simplistic, which is not necessarily a bad thing, but will probably divide the audience of the film heavily. The light tone carries the film and might help to at the very least not scare off people like myself, who might heavily disagree with certain points. While not all of the jokes - light tone overall, as already stated - work, the film generally is definitely worth a watch - and especially the unavoidable debate afterwards.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed