Catching Hearts (2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
A film that makes you think
Ali_C_7721 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This movie explores journey of 3 people who question their place in the world.

One protagonist is a middle-aged man who has espoused atheism by writing best-selling books and giving lectures and has made a small fortune doing so. Something occurred in his life that made him rethink the existence of God; we are unfortunately not privy to this event, which is an unsatisfying gap in the story. He no longer feels he can promote atheism, and this causes a huge divide with his wife, as she loves the wealth, fame, and adoration he receives.

Another protagonist is a young man who lives with his widowed father and has had no luck finding a job after college. The loss of his mother and feeling stuck in life has fueled his alcoholism. He has a rocky relationship with his father, and lashes out at the father, especially when the father encourages reliance on faith in God's plan.

The last tritagonist is a young lady who is a nanny for an energetic and adorable young girl. She shares an apartment with her supportive and sassy best friend. She also has an abrasively rude and uncaring boyfriend. The film doesn't explore why or how the boyfriend became this way, which would have been helpful. One day while working as a nanny, she takes her young charge to an outing at a park. While the nanny takes a phone call to have a terse exchange with her boyfriend the little girl is kidnapped. The nanny is blindsided that such an event could happen to her.

As the story plays out, the characters reflect on their lives and choices. There is man who works as a park landscaper, and he seems like an angel who was placed in their paths to be a sounding board for their internal dialogue. The landscaper is interesting in that he encourages them to explore their struggles with faith and fate, even when the protagonists seek to learn about atheism. He seems to feel assured that they will find answers in time.

I don't think that atheists were portrayed in a negative light, even though one is an alcoholic and the wife of the middle-aged guy is a greedy shrew. This a movie, so some type of character flaw and life crisis is needed to move the story along; otherwise, we'd all be bored. The movie shows humans as humans, who are all on a path. I was pleasantly surprised that one of the characters remained an atheist at the end. It was good that there's realism in that aspect.

This movie is obviously low budget, and the acting and cinematography is on par with that. I wouldn't watch it again, but it was ok.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Not making any sense.
tsskenny22 July 2019
Never revealed what dr gavin saw. Dean being mean to his dad doesn't make sense. How exactly does the book helped the depressed? How it explains how not believing in God make bad things doesn't feel bad.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A Typical Christian View of Atheism...
obwon-241452 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This movie paints the typical Christian view of atheists as lost souls looking for something greater in their lives. The leading atheist, Mark Gavin, experienced some kind of "event" that has made him question his belief in truth and reason. The other atheists in the movie are all shown to have some kind of defect (ie. alcoholic, neglectful baby sitter, dick boyfriend, etc).

It is just so typical of religious people to cast atheists in this light while most atheists would not act like this at all. At least not anymore than everyone else in the world (both religious and non-religious people can make poor decisions). Atheists tend to be more reasonable than most. For example, during the scene when Mark Gavin proclaims his belief in God, a real atheist would not boo him, they would be fascinated to hear his reason why he had a change of heart!

To be fair, I've seen atheists portrayed much worse in other films but this is still an incorrect way to represent how atheists act and feel about their non-belief in a God.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Miraculously done & filmed on 0-budget for such a young writer/director, simply astonishing!
jessicaroszko27 November 2015
New all time favorite movie. Wow done at age 20 it is amazing such a young mind can have such a remarkable grasp on people and God. I am amazed by the quality and acting on a shoestring, or half of one, budget. Amazing work! Entertaining from beginning to end, with some turns and twists along the way. The actors were entertaining and believable. Storyline is timeless. I couldn't have asked for a more clearly stated and respectful story that moved me emotionally with the actors back and their though provoking discoveries and choices. With heartbreak, joy, loss, and healing.... This movie is the essence of the heart and carries meaning that will forever be in the core of each and every one of us.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed