Liam Gallagher: As It Was (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
family feud
ferguson-612 September 2019
Greetings again from the darkness. Co-directors Gavin Fitzgerald and Charlie Lightening could have ended this profile of singer Liam Gallagher by playing the theme song to "Family Feud" over the closing credits. While they do offer up an unflinching look at the talented singer of suspect character, we come away with the feeling that the entire project was designed to reunite Liam and his brother Noel. The two supposedly haven't spoken since they nearly brawled backstage at a scheduled Oasis concert: Paris 2009 Rock en Seine.

A blend of clips from that final Oasis show and Liam's 2017 comeback concert in support of his solo album "As You Were" kick off the film. However, before the opening credits roll, we hear Liam spewing enough f-words to make any teenager blush. The assumption is that we are to be reminded of what a prig Liam was, and the reputation he earned as being a bad boy of rock. The filmmakers, along with Liam and his mum, then spend the rest of the run time trying to convince us that he's a changed man and is actually devoted to his family and to his craft. We do believe the latter, but the former is quite a stretch. We do see his sons accompany him on a later tour, but Liam's numerous affairs and broken marriages are glossed over.

To his credit, Liam faces the camera with some candid self-assessment. It's unclear whether this is his own personal therapy or whether he's choosing to come clean for his fans. Others with featured input here include former Oasis guitarist Bonehead Arthurs, Liam's brother Paul, and Liam's mother Peggy (who is very proud of her boy). Also offering up praise is Debbie Gwyther, Liam's former assistant, who is now his lover and manager. He credits her with getting him back on track in life and back on stage in music.

Although the film features very little music, we do get enough concert clips to recognize Liam's stage presence; however, it's the camera time in the studio that is most fascinating - and leaves us feeling a bit short-changed. Seeing Liam work through songs at historic Abbey Road Studios could have made for an entire film. He is admittedly not a true songwriter, so being forced to collaborate due to the absence of Noel, probably displays the most personal growth for Liam (even if it's out of necessity).

Liam and Noel supposedly haven't spoken in the 10 years since that backstage fight killed off a superband and a brotherhood. The reconciliation evades the filmmakers, but they salvage the project as Liam's solo career takes off, and he travels with sons Gene (born to singer Nicole Appleton) and Lennon (born to actress Patsy Kensit). I chuckled when it's mentioned that Liam is 'the greatest rock front man' ... a line easily contradicted by mentioning Mick Jagger, Bono, or Bruce Springsteen. We are told "he is who he is", and can't help but wonder if that's a good thing. Having others say that he is grateful for a second chance is not the same as him stating it for himself.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Enjoyable and interesting
dtnmusic12 February 2020
If you're a fan of Oasis, Liam, music, or comeback stories you should find this worth your time. I've rented it twice. I've always been a fan of Oasis, but this made me realize I honestly didn't know much. I've been binging and learning their history the last 3 months since watching this. And congrats to Liam, his solo career is a great success.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Personal yes but also utterly controlled and sanitised
stevelomas-6940125 July 2021
No doubt Liam is all the things talked about however this an is incredibly controlled and sanitised one sided publicity vehicle. I need all the fingers on both hands to count the subjects they were told to steer clear of. Even with that he still comes across as unlikable.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An intimate documentary with swagger
sean-rae10 June 2019
This movie pretty much starts off at the end. oasis is done, new paths begin for Liam. it covers the highs and lows of post oasis life and then kicks into gear with the triumphant comeback.

I found this to be a great follow up to supersonic, where that film relied on animation and archive footage, this has more personal interviews. Liam. feels honest and vunrable at times with certian subjects.

fans will enjoy it. Noel will hate it.

as you were...
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
After Oasis - from the bottom back to the top
DeadMansTrousers13 June 2019
If you're a fan of Liam you're going to see this documentary regardless of what anyone says. I ignored any reviews before watching it and I honestly didn't expect it to be so candid and personal. I knew that Charlie Lightening had been filming Liam for a long time but I was unaware of the amount of footage there was. This film documents Liams journey from rock bottom at the end of Oasis to his journey with the under appreciated Beady Eye and straight back to the top where he rightly belongs with his solo career. The majority of this film is new footage and is worth watching for any fan.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Personal and insightful
richardbates715 July 2019
Liam bares his soul, shows some depth and insight. It was interesting and much better than expected. He is a legend like it or not
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not honest enough
michaelbrownlie-323882 January 2020
This film is purely made to make Liam look good and Noel look bad. They both have there faults but being an oasis fan from the start I remember all the incidents that would of made Noel feel like he wouldn't want to work with Liam any longer. Liams new fan base seem to be teenagers or early 20s and don't seem to know or care about the problems he caused in oasis that split the band up, they just dislike Noel for not wanting to work with Liam. He seems to have cleaned he's act up and is more professional now saying and doing all the right things as he's doing it for himself so can't behave the way he once did with the might of noels songs behind him.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Some class Liam propoganda.
Edeards21 May 2020
This sorry mess of a documentary throws everything but the kitchen sink at attempting to portray Liam Gallagher as a tortured artist who lost everything due to his evil brother Noel splitting up the band and ruining his life.

Admittedly it is not without a sense of self reflection and regret but this is a disingenuously one-sided propaganda flick for die hard Liam fans.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
In His Own Words
msalway-243-2791429 December 2019
This documentary is a telling of the tale of Liam Gallagher's personal journey after the breakup of Oasis. This is about the rebirth of a musician finding his place in the world again after the end of a major part of his life - Lazarus emerging from the flames even stronger. It's an honest and raw look into his world tour between 2017-18. A must-see for any Oasis/Liam fan
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Love it!!
lucyjohattel4 August 2023
I love Liam in general, and this documentary is one of the best I've ever seen, it shows the problems Liam has suffered and went through throughout his Rockstar lifestyle and you don't really think of it until someone says something because you just listen to the music and don't understand the problems in his life and this really shows how relatable he is as a person. It shows how far along he has came from his fall out with Noel. Words can't describe how good this documentary is, it's just actually the best thing ever and I recommend that everyone reading this watch it atleast once in your lifetime :)
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Mad fer it
stefimandic25 September 2021
This really made me fall in love with his and Oasis' music. Fantastic, biblical.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Self indulgent apology to Noel
maddie187814 June 2019
It started off well with the announcement at the Paris gig. Some really gritty insight that I was interested in as I hadn't seen it before.

But then it lost pace and was a pure attempt to prove that Liam wasn't the old idiot everyone loved/hated. I'm a diehard oasis fan but this felt like a feeble attempt to get Noel to talk to him again. Liam has great musical talent but he needs to stop trying to do oasis without Noel. I really wanted to see insight into the split and the aftermath. But this was just his manager/girlfriend chatting propaganda
16 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Trailer was all you need
summervanderhart3 October 2019
Sorry Liam, I love you but this movie wasn't needed and didn't work, a short interview would have been enough. I had to fast forward after a few minutes in to see if anything good was coming up but nothing, the 2 minute trailer is all you need and even that maybe too much. In contrast I loved Oasis Supersonic documentary, well made and highly recommended.
9 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Grow Up for Christ Sake
andrewfowler-3702819 June 2019
When Liam was younger I thought he was a bit of an idiot.Now I know he is.He's a grown up now....so you'd have thought he could stop swearing constantly and lift his perpetual angry aggressive gaze. An insult to people's intelligence and ears.
14 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A very uncharismatic movie about a very charismatic man
martinbjerrebygballe5 December 2020
Liam (& Noel) are some of the most entertaining people in the rock business - they have a lot of attitude and humor, and even if they're often unlikeable, they're still very funny. They're also of course famous for being hotel-room-trashing rock stars with a lot of conflict between them. In this movie we see Liam trying to get his act together and move on with his career after the split of Oasis, but it's just done in a very uinteresting and uninformative way. There's a lot of interviews with people calling the music "great" and Liam a "genius", but there's very little of the actual music in the film, let alone the process behind it. The interviews with Liam are filled with variations on "yeah, you just gotta keep on going, know what i mean?", and not a lot of reflections on himself, Noel, his life or his career. I'm not really sure what the audience for this movie is - I guess it's supposed to portray Liam's new music as something worthwhile and great, and while it is certainly quite nice (especially his latest album), it's just not on a level of "genius" that the film would like to have you believe (without ever really playing much of the music for you, or letting us see more than a 15-second continuous clip from a concert). Overall, very dull and uinteresting (unlike the Supersonic documentary, which really captures the madness and chaos of Oasis).
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Well i was right then
fewsternoble6 July 2019
All the time throughout this movie they are constantly saying he isn't a bad person, sorry but this just confirms it. Interesting movie but, my opinion of him is confirmed.
3 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
RIP off artist
rickiemjames19 June 2019
Completely ripping off Beatles! ALL ASPECTS!

Listen to all they did - Harmonys- builds- CHorus, All rip offs from the old guys, NO I am not a beatle fan. I jut hate rip off artist that roll on what has been done. Create new Like Sabith- RUsh _ NARAVA......
4 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed