You Don't Nomi (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
16 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
YOU DON'T NOMI: WHEN DOES TRASH BECOME ART?
kirbylee70-599-5261794 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It's amazing to watch as things that were at one time considered to be either terrible of high camp in film suddenly are rediscovered by a completely different set of people who then elevate it to art. Every time it happens I sit and wonder what could someone have seen in what was something so bad that they think it's wonderful? Don't get me wrong, there are movies that are terrible that I love but I've never gone so far as to call them art or tell others how stupid they were for not seeing how great they are.

This brings us to the new documentary YOU DON'T NOMI, a celebration of the movie SHOWGIRLS. Released in 1995 the film was written by Joe Eszterhas and directed by Paul Verhoeven fresh from their hit BASIC INSTINCT. Starring Elizabeth Berkley in her first adult role (she played Jessie on the kids TV series SAVED BY THE BELL) the film was made for a costly (at the time) $45 million dollars and bombed at the box office bringing in just $37 million. No doubt this was due to the films NC-17 rating and the drumming it took from critics at the time

But when it hit the video market all of that turned around. Whether it was people trying to see if the movie was as bad as they'd heard or boys now grown with dreams of seeing Berkley nude for the first time the movie took off on video raking in over $100 million. The movie was still considered a critical flop but something strange happened. The movie seemed to take on a life of its own.

For those who haven't seen the movie let's begin there. It tells the story of Nomi Malone, a rough and ready young woman on her way to Las Vegas to take the town by storm as their top dance. But with one reigning queen already in place, Cristal Connors (Gina Gershon), the odds of her taking over are slim. Working as a stripper to make ends me, Nomi gets into her job there. I mean REALLY gets into it. She catches the eye of Connors one night along with her boyfriend (Kyle McLachlan). Eventually Connors gets Nomi the chance to audition for the big show and eventually she tries out for the top spot. Will her dreams come true?

Directed by Jeffrey McHale, YOU DON'T NOMI takes a look at the movie all over again from his own perspective and discovers he enjoyed it more than he realized. Combining older interviews with cast and crew as well as talking to various people who have found the film their perfect feature, McHale attempts to convert the non-believers out there that the film deserves to be taken more seriously than it has in the past.

Among the various people he talks to are numerous pop culture critics who view the film as an icon of the times, finding more happening on screen than viewers and critics were willing to give it credit for in the past. They champion the films and its story line while at the same time noting the ridiculous dialogue and overblown acting. I know it's just me but I've always found people who find some deep hidden meaning in things like paint splatters to be pretentious folks looking to impress others with how smart they are and how stupid the rest of the world is. No amount of adjectives can make this movie an actual classic. That being said from a craftwork standpoint it is a great film to watch with some great cinematography, set designs and set up from director Verhoeven.

Another person interviewed is a drag queen who fell in love with the film and booked it at a late night screening in a theater where others would join in mimicking the film on stage as it ran. As word spread about what was taking place the cult following popped up much like it did around the film THE ROCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW, but a little racier.

Then there is an actress who went to New York to be discovered. Instead she was raped and secluded herself until her boyfriend convinced her to try out for the lead role in the stage production of a camp version of SAVED BY THE BELL being done off-Broadway. She got the past and noted how it helped her find the inner strength go on with her life. When the off-Broadway production of SHOWGIRLS came about she got the lead in that as well.

The question becomes can a movie made about what ranks on many lists as one of the worst movies made of all time be entertaining? The answer is yes, perhaps even more so than the original film itself. It was interesting to listen to these varying viewpoints of the film as well as seeing Berkley finally embrace the film for what it was in spite of it nearly killing her career. I finished still not convinced that the film was all that many here think it is but at least I came to appreciate how others could find it so.

One thing should be noted for viewers. The film uses extensive clips from the original movie and that means there are plenty of nude and simulated sex scenes on hand. If you found the original film offensive then this movie will fall into that category as well. If it doesn't bother you then you might want to watch this and come to your own conclusions about the original film. Who knows, you might even go looking for a copy to watch all over again.
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Note that this is not a single point-of-view documentary!
Bloomer8 April 2022
Reading the reviews for this documentary on IMDB, it seems clear to me most viewers didn't understand that the context for the various critical commentaries made in the documentary changes all the time as you watch. The fact almost nobody gets that this is happening is totally the documentary's fault. The editing is simply not clear enough with in its intentions.

What happens in this documentary is that its author, David Schmader, who sees a lot in Showgirls both in the positive and negative, and from both the genuine and camp angles, gets various critics - and/or actors standing in for critics, it's not clear - to read out their genuine and mostly negative critical reviews or thoughts of the film on the soundtrack. You never know if these thoughts were written today or back in 1995, or a mixture of both; the documentary never fully declares the sources.

Schmader then contrasts each of these critical attacks with his own additional commentary (or perhaps in some cases, other people's, but again, it's hard to tell) on the same themes or scenes from the film, pointing out value, directorial skill or just other ideas that people might have missed. He also shows clips from other Verhoeven films. These are illuminating when they're used to show recurring Verhoeven themes. Unfortunately, he also alters some of these shots as a sort of gag where the people in the other Verhoeven films are 'interacting' with elements of Showgirls, and these moments are usually downright confusing.

So people ranting on about 'wokeness' of this film and such - blame each critic David was quoting. Neither he nor the documentary is outright endorsing these views. They present them in order to either comment on them, refute them or expand on them. But because the doco is really bad at saying who's speaking from what time period, and when or why, it's understandable viewers miss this.

The crucial point is, this is NOT a single point of view film. It invites a pile of points of view, mostly bundling them into positive or negative camps (which you might expect - polarisation is the hallmark of Showgirls) and compares them, through unfortunately bad editing, usually giving the positive camp the last word. By stepping away from the critics' views late in the film, it ends with other kinds of positives. But make no mistake, you will hear a lot of negative commentary on Showgirls in this film.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good If A Little Dry
matildawoodworm29 April 2022
This exploration of what makes Showgirls such a great cult film is at times interesting, but with one main speaker on the subject, it can feel a bit like attending someone's lecture about this in a film school hall. No idea how prohibitive that would have been, but more input from some of the people who helped bring it to life would be interesting.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
But I do
kosmasp18 November 2020
Or don't I? Actually who knows ... Nomi? And of course there are other interpretations of that word. Maybe one of the most wicked things about the movie - the characters name. Know me - no me - no! Me! - as you can see you make it what you think it should be. And maybe some won't like how certain people view this movie. But then again, why are watching this? I personally thought the audio commentary was enjoyable enough and most topics that are being highlighted there, get repeated here.

But you also get to see how some just cherish the movie, by reanacting it. But also how different some view it! Is it a feminists worst nightmare or does it show and depict how powerful women are? I don't have to tell you how to feel about the movie, you are the one deciding. And no one can make you have fun watching the movie Showgirls, but maybe the documentary brings you closer to that point. Especially considering where Berkley came from and where she went after that movie ... all depicted here. I almost feel sorry for her. But she accepted that the movie will always be a part of her and she relishes in it. One of the things you will learn here ... for fans of Showgirls mostly, but can work for others too. Still it makes sense to have seen the movie to fully understand or have the complete context
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Entertaining look at the fans of a famous turkey
cherold25 January 2021
I've never seen Showgirls, and I probably never will. But this movie does a nice job of laying out its history and exploring its cult-movie status. It also gives you all the nudity without having to watch the movie itself.

I see about half the reviews here hate this movie for being "woke," i.e. exploring how the movie portrays women. Having not seen the movie I can't speak to how persuasive the analysis is, but it's pretty interesting and they do make a good case. And I have never heard the opinion of anyone using "woke" or "feminist" as a criticism who wasn't a complete idiot, so that's a point for the movie over its critics.

The talking heads are smart and often witty, there are some interesting personal stories, there are a range of perspectives, its fun to see how the makers tried to spin their disaster, and there are some attractive naked ladies, so all-in-all worth watching.
7 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quite funny to watch somebody review a horrible picture in a way you wanna see it again...
imseeg28 February 2022
A documentary about a terrible movie. A story about a movie so bad, that it got a cult following. An interpretation of kitsch, making it valuable again.

This is quite a fun watch, because listening to this huge fan of "Showgirls" explain to us viewers why this terrible flop has still got some worth to it, is quite interesting.

Should I watch it again? No, I dont think so. But terrible movies can become great cult movies and they sure can turn into fun documentaries!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An extended video essay about a Hollywood film that bombed
thadeusgreyson31 December 2022
This documentary puts forward the idea that perhaps Paul Verhoeven's Razzie winning film "Showgirls" needs reappraisal.

If you haven't already seen it I would suggest you watch "Showgirls" first and then wait at least a day, if not a week, before watching this documentary.

My overall impression of the original film was it was a mis-fire from an over the top, intelligent and creative director who likes to provoke and entertain at the same time. The performances throughout the film are so exaggerated that it is not enjoyable to watch, and while there is a lot of nudity this film is not sexy or titillating at all. As with all the Verhoeven films I've seen there is sex and graphic violence.

This documentary takes the viewer on the journey of how the film has been received over the years, and how it has gained cult status. Fans of the original film praise it, books have been written about it.

The use of excerpts from Verhoeven's other films with insert images of Showgirls on TVs and monitors was interesting, as well as cutting excerpts from other films to compliment the narration/interviews from various critics.

Showing how Paul Verhoeven's stance towards "Showgirls" has changed over the years is interesting, but In the end the film is still a bad film and not the masterpiece that some of the participants in this documentary put forward.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fun & enjoyable, except for one thing....
mcsinteriors29 July 2020
If you're a fan of Showgirls for what it is, an over-the-top disaster that you can't look away from, then you'll enjoy this documentary. I found it entertaining and witty. Whether people want to admit it or not, Showgirls has become a cult-classic. You can analyze to death just l how bad it is, or you can just sit back and enjoy it in all of its awfulness. I choose to do the latter. To me, Showgirls is so bad that's it's good. This documentary does a good job of playing to that angle for fans, with the exception of one thing....

There is one "feminist" female commentator who chooses to pick the movie apart for its depiction of women. She must use the word 'misogynist' 50 times!!! It's exhausting listening to her. Isn't true feminism being able to do whatever the hell you want with your own body??? If that's showing your boobs on the big screen for 90 minutes and getting paid to do it, well so be it. She seems to only be in favor of female-empowerment when it fits her mold of what that encompasses.

If you can just tune her out, this is a really enjoyable documentary for fans of Showgirls.
22 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Finally in 2021, on public TV in the Netherlands
tvamsterdam14 January 2021
The great thing about Showgirls (1995) is that it gives a semi-futuristic image of a wasteland while at the moment it was shot it is taking place in reality. It was history in the making. In fact Paul Verhoeven created a dramatized documentary by hiring actors and a scenario writer. It was not a bad movie but a bad dream about American society. That's against the American Dream. Showing Americans that they are in a Third World Country was in those years the biggest taboo. The documentary You Don't Nomi does not come to this conclusion, it describes the fuzz and confusion from a film press perspective, wondering why after so many years the movie regained respect. Ask Paul Verhoeven to do a movie about the recent Capitol attack and he will show the ugliness of the patriots, including woman. Showgirls is about that. Show the ugliness of the American way of setting up a sex industry and not able to handle it. A third world country, in 1995 nobody in the US was thinking of it this way... only an outsider could see it.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Heartfelt Love Letter to a Beloved Cult Classic
bizzywiththefizzy20 June 2020
I've always loved 'Showgirls' so was delighted to see that a documentary had been released exploring a film dragged through the ringer & accused of being sleazy garbage.

As a queer female, lots of things about Showgirls and Nomi's crazy journey spoke to me such as the concept of 'chosen families'.

'You Don't Nomi' is an absolute must see, putting 'Showgirls' in its rightful spot amongst high camp, delightfully & unashamedly OTT classics including 'Mommie Dearest', 'Valley of the Dolls', 'Cobra Woman', 'The Room', 'Plan 9 From Outer Space' & 'The Rocky Horror Picture Show'.

This thoughtful documentary deserves all the awards it will certainly win.
18 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
VIEWS ON FILM review of You Don't Nomi
burlesonjesse530 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Cut feverishly yet disjointed. Informative yet adrift. Scorching in its archived look yet distant. Revealing yet risible. Yeah I'm talking about You Don't Nomi, a documentary chronicling 1995's Showgirls. I'm not kidding, Showgirls people, a film that's almost a bad pun for the overall discussion about the art form.

So OK, I saw Showgirls in the theater during my college years. I mean I was curious mainly because of the NC-17 rating. Did I like it? Not really. The writing was bad, Elizabeth Berkley had spaz moments in her acting, and the mean-spirited nature of the flick was something that stuck with me. Now apparently and unbeknownst to me, Showgirls is a cult film. Wha?? I'm not saying that it's the worst movie ever made but even cult films eventually get good reviews. Showgirls still sits with a Rotten Tomatoes score of 27%. And um, the audience score ain't much better.

You Don't Nomi is basically 90 minutes of critics, writers, randoms, and the director himself analyzing Showgirls and making sure its turd is more polished than it needs to be. You see a lot of past footage from the movies of Paul Verhoeven (the director of Showgirls). What you don't see are the people being interviewed and you can still tell they are getting high on their own, probing supply. I almost chuckled. The over-analyzing here is endless and while it appears smart and intuitive, it almost feels like heightened hot air, rising and falling.

Now I'm not saying You Don't Nomi isn't a well-made docu because it is. Heck, most of them are. It's edited fairly well and has enough swag to avoid being boring. But here's the rub: if you've never seen Showgirls you'll find "Nomi" to be fascinating and then you'll probably end up renting the thing On Demand. If you have seen Showgirls (and I did on opening night), then it will come off more as an annals lesson or an education about the vehicle that can only be taken as laughably self-serious. "I do know that".
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Someone who missed the point of the film, decides to make a documentary about it.
danielaudrasilva15 July 2020
Remember Claire from Six Feet Under? She goes to Art School and she befriends teenagers who are always high and will bring politics into every single thing for no reason. Now imagine those art school teenagers making a documentary about Showgirls and distorting every single thing in the movie to fit their narrative, that's You Don't Nomi. Everything you don't want in a Showgirls doc is here. Personal stories of random people I couldn't care less about and political commentary all over the place. What could have been an interesting dissection of the film and how it impacted Pop Culture, became a bad drinking game and if you take a shot everytime someone says "straight white male" you'll be drunk in no time. Ironically enough, this mess, completely misses the point about black characters, reducing Molly to a sidekick who only exists to serve Nomi, while in truth, Molly has the best and most interesting and sinister storyline in the film. Anyway, don't bother with this, get your friends together, watch the movie and discuss it among yourselves, you'll have a much better time.
41 out of 59 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Waste of time.
CriticsVoiceVideo7 July 2020
This is not a documentary. It's a 90min movie review by a bunch of irrelevant "critics" spouting their irrelevant opinions no one cares about and no one asked for. They sit around pontificating the meaning behind every little thing and how the movie is full of "misogyny" and "racism". None of which is true. Most of the commentary is done by basement dweller Schmader the schmuck from back in 2004/05. Don't even get me started on that. There is also a section devoted to some strange woman, who is a nobody, running around town obsessed with Elizabeth Berkeley and apparently there are idiots who think she's funny when really she's just cringe. NO ONE involved in SHOWGIRLS has anything to do with this load of bile. Wait for the real documentary, "GODDESS".
35 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
If you love "social justice" and identity politics this is for you
stevenastark28 November 2020
But If you actually like Showgirls, appreciate the camp satire and spectacle and wanted to find out anything interesting about how it was made then it's probably not.
18 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Tedious, unconvincing, and frequently irrelevant
Norman_French15 April 2024
Given how much I agree with the 1-star ratings of this supposed "documentary", my rating may surprise. I think this film isn't actually terrible, it's just lame and somewhat misguided. Now, Showgirls itself IS terrible, but that's not what I'm reviewing here (mostly).

This film has flaws. Much time is spent on the notion that Showgirls is either a "misunderstood masterpiece" or an "over-the-top FUN movie". But as the film clearly shows, Paul Verhoeven intended Showgirls to be serious drama. The studio eventually began marketing the movie as so-bad-it's-good (which I personally disagree with), but for whatever reason it found a cult following, especially among segments of the gay community.

One of the stranger assertions is that Showgirls is simultaneously bad and good, as if quantum physics is somehow involved.

The various unseen narrators have conflicting perspectives. Some bend over backwards to provide arguments that Showgirls has hidden merit. A LOT of footage of other films (many by Verhoeven) is shown to illustrate points or entertain, but it's mostly distracting and annoying. What I found most interesting about the actual Showgirls footage was how much more star power and/or stage presence Gina Gershon had than Elizabeth Berkley. A documentary about Gina would have been FAR more interesting.

You Don't Nomi touches on an off-Broadway musical adaptation of Showgirls, which was interesting (at first). The exaggerated mannerisms that seem so dumb in the movie work just fine on the stage. However, FAR too much time is spent listening to the life story of the lead performer (gad).

I give this four (4) stars, which is probably generous, given how little I learned relative to the time spent watching.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Meh.
thejdrage27 October 2022
There are 18 minutes left in this documentary and I can't listen to the person being interviewed drone on any longer. All I am hearing is the Charlie Brown teacher "Blah blah blah blah blah blah."

I never saw the movie, never heard of it - which is odd because I've been a movie fan all my life (let's blame my mother!!) and one would think I'd know this one given how famous it is for being such a stinker.

Sadly, I don't think this documentary is much of an improvement on the movie. It's just 180 degrees in the other direction. I am seriously trying to stay awake and finally decided that if it's THAT boring, why am I still watching it since it's not really about a topic I actually care about?

So, will forego the last 18 minutes and go take a nap.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed