Hundiseaduse aegu (1985) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Good idea spoiled by limited production capabilities
andres-15127 October 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is set in the 1330s and 1340s, and tells about an Estonian lad's movements on the Mediaeval social ladder. Its production was seriously hampered by the conflict between its ambitious original script and the limited production capabilities. The outcome is a rather typical 1980's Estonian movie (which should be understood as an euphemism). The screenplay was written by the same person who had written the original screenplay for "Viimne reliikvia" (1969), though the success of the 1969 movie may lay in the fact that its screenplay was heavily edited which did not happen with "Hundiseaduse aegu" (1984). For instance, it was scripted that the 1984 movie should have included a battle between the peasants and the knights which was simply deleted, as it was simply not possible to gather the necessary armoured cavalry and train the horses. Or the absurd killing-by-staring scene had originally to be a shot with a crossbow; the crossbow was also deleted as it might have been too difficult and dangerous to shoot an actor convincingly on the screen.

I remember from the original theatrical run also visible camera tracks in the swamp scene, but they disappeared from the version I saw in the late 1990's.

Finding a suitable castle was also a problem, so a late 19th-century Neogothic castle was used for both exterior and interior (with its central heating radiators), located in a forest which certainly was not the case for a Mediaeval castle. When the movie opened in 1984, the papers had articles about the movie's goofs, such as the power line poles and 18th-19th-century rural architecture or some 17th-century costumes in the 14th-century setting.

However, the ethereal electronic music adds much to the film. Paying attention to the message of their lyrics, the songs (like the opening and closing song, "Who are you, who am I?", or the one about death) reinforce the main character's sense of social solitude (he was not one of the peasants, nor of the monks, nor of the gentry). Also the generic, unsynchronised ritual music in the rural rite scene helps to create the abstract overall atmosphere, not that of a specific event.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
So that's why we are talking about a film that is wished to be forgotten forever
peter-kuus13 April 2008
In 1969 Estonian film company Tallinnfilm made a masterful adventure film "Viimne reliikvia" (The Last Relic). They have never made anything close to it again... Three years later an attempt to repeat the success with "Verekivi" (The Blood Rock) failed. They shouldn't try to film a medieval adventure story anymore. However, in 1984 they did it and gained the absolute bottom with "Hundiseaduste aegu" (When dogs ate dogs).

Set in the 14-th century there are used lots of costumes and armor of its time in the film. Even a medieval village is specially built into the forest. Doesn't sound like a cheap movie ? Well, everything not mentioned above was a real crap ! The director Olev Neuland - i'd say that i'm really afraid to watch any of his other films. The action was extremely unrealistic and jumping from one task to another. Did they do any film-composition (montage) at all ? The cinematographer did anything to make a feeling of some kind of experimental film. The actors we have used to see in good quality - what did happen to them ? Why is the acting so fake ? Who genius came to the idea that in the final scene Meleleiv will kill Hans Metten with his glance ?? The fighting scenes, especially on the river are nothing but pathetic ! To watch that, i'd got the feeling that all the crew just fleers over the public. And who wrote all that comic-weak text ? Radiator on the wall of the medieval castle or electric pole visible makes it even more hapless. The crown for it all is an unsuitable aggressive synthesizer music through the whole movie (a compositor Grünberg did Kraftwerk insead of Clannad).

Well, to get to the good points then there almost was none. Yes, the village girl was a beauty but her role was rather a small. Her Van Damme-type boyfriend was fine looking warrior too but still, they were more requisites than actors. So that's why we are talking about a film that is wished to be forgotten forever.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed