Return to Halloweentown (2006 TV Movie)
1/10
Whoever made the decision to recast Marnie should be
19 October 2022
Made to wear a paper bag over their head for the rest of their life. No parole. Ever. What a bonehead decision. Whoever this person was, they killed the Halloweentown franchise. You CANNOT replace Kimberly J. Brown, it just CANNOT be done. It felt like I was watching a completely different movie. No spark, no warmth no familiarity... zero connection. Nothing against Sarah Paxton but she simply was not Marnie, it just didn't work. The plot of this movie is actually not bad, but it's the recast of Marnie that doomed it. I sometimes imagine what it would of been like if Kimberly J. Brown did return and I think we can all agree that would of been a great successful movie. And let's not forget that Kimberly J. Brown was very interested and ready to reprise her role but again this paper bag headed num skull passed on bringing her back which adds insult to our injury.

So to the person who made this mind blowing movie making disastrous call, whoever you are... thanks for ruining a great franchise. I really dislike you.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed