Some old movies are true classics. They seem to keep on living despite technical disadvantages of the time they were made. Some others, simply need to be remade. The Texan is one of the latter category. It screams to be remade. It suffers terribly from the painfully limited post-silent Hollywood technology.
What does not mask that disadvantages is the primitive sound, no theme music, and the awful direction. The director simply fails to get a better performance from the obviously inexperienced future star, Gary Cooper. Coop is too tall and lanky to be believable in his role as a Mexican-American bandit slowly turning good, and the director fails to minimize it with good camera angles. He is also too stiff (even by Coop's standards) and boring to be likable as the leading character. On the other hand, the director allows Emma Dunn to be annoyingly suffocating in her overacting as the doting mother. One would almost like to throw a brick at the screen every time she is in a scene.
So why am I asking for a remake of this movie? Because it does have a great premise, and a very smart ending. In the hands of a capable director, and with the advantage of good music and today's technology, this story could actually turn into at least a minor classic. As it is for now, the original is good for a one-time watching and no more.
What does not mask that disadvantages is the primitive sound, no theme music, and the awful direction. The director simply fails to get a better performance from the obviously inexperienced future star, Gary Cooper. Coop is too tall and lanky to be believable in his role as a Mexican-American bandit slowly turning good, and the director fails to minimize it with good camera angles. He is also too stiff (even by Coop's standards) and boring to be likable as the leading character. On the other hand, the director allows Emma Dunn to be annoyingly suffocating in her overacting as the doting mother. One would almost like to throw a brick at the screen every time she is in a scene.
So why am I asking for a remake of this movie? Because it does have a great premise, and a very smart ending. In the hands of a capable director, and with the advantage of good music and today's technology, this story could actually turn into at least a minor classic. As it is for now, the original is good for a one-time watching and no more.