Don't get me wrong here, this is a good episode that I thoroughly enjoyed. I love Lost and am a huge fan of the series. But if I have to be critical I need to call out a couple things timed too perfectly that make some scenes a tad unbelievable - Jin running out of the jungle as soon as Michael and Sawyer get to the beach for example.
I also loved episode 1 of season 2 but the ending raised a question for me. Then after seeing the scene again in this episode I wondered: how was Jack reminded of who Desmond was just because he said "brother"? Perhaps the accent? Maybe that moment in his life was very memorable and clearly it was especially given his emotions at that time. But who knows how long ago the Tour de Stade took place, however that is much more believable than the aforementioned Jin sequence.
Overall, a good episode and I think these couple things can be overlooked.
Adrift gets a 8/10.
I also loved episode 1 of season 2 but the ending raised a question for me. Then after seeing the scene again in this episode I wondered: how was Jack reminded of who Desmond was just because he said "brother"? Perhaps the accent? Maybe that moment in his life was very memorable and clearly it was especially given his emotions at that time. But who knows how long ago the Tour de Stade took place, however that is much more believable than the aforementioned Jin sequence.
Overall, a good episode and I think these couple things can be overlooked.
Adrift gets a 8/10.