Review of Green Chair

Green Chair (2005)
4/10
Poor Context; Takes Away from Plot
26 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I feel from even the raunchiest versions of this type of film (or characters it portrays) to the most solemn, context is important. There are, of course biases, whether in real life and/or fantasy, such as this film. I feel the 'fantasy' for fiction is fine as long as the context is well-defined; good or bad, it always seems to lay on context. As an example: two 'adults' are fine given by the laws of one nation (or state) to the other as long as both parties are mature enough (not only physically but mentally as well) but that's a bit troubling for this film because the age of consent in South Korea (where this film was made around 2005 when released) is 13 years old (their laws are based on the Western Calendar). So, either they have laws that are different based on gender or this film is considerably fictional since the 'underage' male in this is well over the age of 13 (he's actually 19 in the film). I know this sounds, perhaps ridiculous on my part, but it doesn't seem as a reason for her arrest to begin with. So, if the main character of the 'boy' is supposed to be 12 or younger in this, this film is ridiculous on that alone but he obviously is more to the age of 15- 17 (even though, as stated: he's 19); and most other things that require an age requirement in South Korea is 19 years old (drinking, smoking etc.,) and that's the problem for me and this film: no law has been broken. So, why did she get arrested? Why the 100 hrs of Community Service? I don't get it. I read once about a South Korean 45 year old man who apparently had consensual sex with a 15 year old girl in an elevator. At first he was charged and sentenced but since the 15 year old girl sent him love letters, the guy was let go because it was 'consensual'. That's why I mention the development of the person (physically/mentally) because that actually plays a big role in determining whether something is actually consensual or not.

If you separate that part from the film then it's an average erotica film about one person older having an affair with someone younger. The sex scenes are mildly entertaining, especially since they have conversations during them; and also the realization of one character noticing perhaps it's not love but lust, and perhaps it was just a risqué thing to begin with but takes home a life lesson for the better or not.

My biggest problem is the fact no law has been broken (except, at the time, adultery but I only remember that once and the police/reporter dialogue was about the 'young boy' not adultery); and since that's a major plot point: this movie is below average.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed