net_orders Review of Sisters of the Gion

Sisters of the Gion (1936)

Primitive Even By Past Contemporary Standards. However ... .

[2/10 · 29 July 2016]

Viewed on DVD. Far from a classic. Inferior script and direction--it seems to have confused gold diggers with Geishas. Muddy sight and sound (although the print seems to have been restored significantly). Sound is so bad that dialogue is about 95% unintelligible (even for those who can understand a bit of Japanese)--but subtitles are clear and concise. Shot like a stage play with predominance of medium and long shots (there are, maybe, 2-3 close-ups showing what the actors really look like!). "Exterior" shots look phony and likely to have been shot on a sound stage. Film ends abruptly--money problems or saving the rest for a sequel? This film is more a historical curiosity than entertainment. However, restoration enthusiasts should consider adding it to their "things to do" list. The film is historic and could greatly benefit from further restoration efforts. I encourage the film restoration community to give this film further consideration. WILLIAM FLANIGAN, PhD.