The bulk of the story and the core of this film are carried by Jackie Gleason (MSgt. Maxwell Slaughter) and Steve McQueen (Sgt. Eustis Clay). About their acting talents there can be no doubt. But this film falls flat despite their efforts.
For me, the only other portrayal of note is Tuesday Weld as Bobby Jo Pepperdine. She adds a dose of excitement to this otherwise low key film, which centers on the relationship between Slaughter and Clay.
Clay is a schemer, similar to characters in other (mostly military) films and TV shows--like Sgt. Bilko. He idolizes Slaughter, who he thinks can do no wrong. Their relationship is unlikely but tender.
The story, however, is uneven and somewhat rambling. I am tempted to blame Blake Edwards (based upon other projects of his), but he is not the only person credited with the screenplay. In any event, this film could be better if the script was more coherent and it showed development in the primary characters.
Some viewers will find this film to be a quirky gem. Others will find it inconsequential. But I think it is safe to say that it falls short of what it could have been.
For me, the only other portrayal of note is Tuesday Weld as Bobby Jo Pepperdine. She adds a dose of excitement to this otherwise low key film, which centers on the relationship between Slaughter and Clay.
Clay is a schemer, similar to characters in other (mostly military) films and TV shows--like Sgt. Bilko. He idolizes Slaughter, who he thinks can do no wrong. Their relationship is unlikely but tender.
The story, however, is uneven and somewhat rambling. I am tempted to blame Blake Edwards (based upon other projects of his), but he is not the only person credited with the screenplay. In any event, this film could be better if the script was more coherent and it showed development in the primary characters.
Some viewers will find this film to be a quirky gem. Others will find it inconsequential. But I think it is safe to say that it falls short of what it could have been.