8/10
Powerful, interesting and thought provoking
9 February 2014
The movie is a critical evaluation of the media practices and journalism standards in many countries and the general trends, all over the world. Viewers are shown about some of the gripping facts of news making, including what goes behind the scenes. The end-to-end process of news making as explained in the movie including other elements like vested interests, controlling factors exposes the audience to several dark truths. After watching the movie, any viewer will be in a better position to judge news and news making, whether or not they are from the media background. Some of the topics are quite controversial, but it helps us in understanding the rigor that Prof.Chomsky uses to advocate freedom of expression. For instance in the section on 'Holocaust Denial,' Prof.Chomsky mentions that there is a difference between expressing your own views and protecting the views expressed. He makes this statement while arguing that he had supported the French intellectual who published a book to explain that the Holocaust, mass murders actually did not take place. He also emphasizes that he does not endorse the views of the French intellectual, but supports him, in the context of expressing his own views. Prof.Chomsky's statement "States are violent institutions," is a connotation, well expressed. There are chilling evidences to support his statement in the movie. For instance, while analyzing the news articles that appeared in the media in the United States, during the initial phases of Indonesia's aggression on East Timor, there were negative reports. He explains that this was on account of the fact that East Timor was a former Portuguese colony. However, after the invasion of East Timor, U.S supplied arms to Indonesia and there was no coverage of the genocide and atrocities committed by Indonesia in East Timor. Similarly, he also remarks that every Post-war American president should be hanged, if Nuremberg laws are to be applied. Some of the definitions and framework put forward by Prof.Chomsky helps in understanding theories like Manufacturing Consent and Agenda Setting, better. For instance he says that marginalizing the public is the intention of elite class. Similarly he also explains that elite and big media are agenda setters and that 80 percent of the population are followers in a democracy and the remaining 80 percent is composed of the elite and the political class. The movie is a very interesting eye-opener for all audiences, be it a novice or a historian or a media professional. However, some of the concepts like manufacturing consent and agenda setting are repeatedly explained. Further editing can improve the quality of the movie and especially remove the repeated explanations.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed