"Arrow" Sins of the Father (TV Episode 2016) Poster

(TV Series)

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
League Civil War
ThomasDrufke10 February 2016
It's funny to think about how much sh*t has been caused by Malcom Merlyn and ultimately, he'll never stop until Oliver kills him. After watching this episode, it almost seems set in stone that Merlyn will be the season 5 villain, assuming the show gets renewed. The conversation between Oliver and Nyssa to open the episode said it all. Sure, a lot of the horrific events that have occurred on the show have been a result of Ras Al Ghul, but really it can all be traced back to Malcom, so I was thrilled that we got an episode that centered upon that.

'Sins of the Father' turned out to be pretty much what I expected, but it absolutely delivered on the Malcom/Oliver scenes we have been missing and the few twists the episode had promised. Beginning with the flashbacks, I'm still not entirely sure what the ultimatum will be with Reiter and his gang but I wasn't annoyed with those scenes like I usually am. It's just hard to watch them knowing the material going on in the present day is far more interesting and satisfying, so they always seem like an unfortunate necessity.

The episode dealt with the father issues on both Felicity and Thea's front quite well. I've enjoyed Noah Amandes' performance as the Calculator thus far and tonight was no different. His story served as a good parallel for Felicity and Oliver to feed off each other's ideas on how to take down their respected father figures. Every scene with John Barrowman and Stephen Amell delivered. I think we were all expecting Malcom to come back and be the big bad at some point, but with his role as Ras taken from him, along with his hand, I think season 5 is inevitably where he'll fit back in. That is, after Oliver finishes dealing with Darhk as he now looks to go after Oliver's son, William.

It would be rather dark for the show to kill off two significant adolescent boys in subsequent seasons, but I wouldn't put it past the show's writers. But I also think the idea of William being in the grave maybe too easy. I'm still willing to say that a member of Team Arrow may bite it by season's end. Now that Thea is back healthy I hardly believe they would put her through the dead/not dead story line and Felicity is off the table so that really leaves Diggle, Laurel, and maybe Lance. As much as I'd be fine with Laurel taking one for the team, I don't think they will remove both Canaries from the show. Lance is an interesting possibility as he was my guess all along, but again, he hasn't been in the show all that much so they would need to bring him back into the fold for the latter half of the season. It's honestly a complete toss up.

Not that she was ever a regular on the show, but Nyssa's presence has always been welcomed and for awhile I thought Malcom may put an end to her memorable run on the show, especially because of Stephen Amell's tweet earlier today, alas, I was wrong. It was funny watching Nyssa constantly bring up the fact that her and Oliver are still 'technically' married. But one of the best parts about this episode was the ideologies of both sides of the coin. I understand where Malcom and Nyssa were coming from, which made the trial by combat on a Star City roof top all the more intense. So in all, 'Sins of the Father' continued the great week the CW is having and sets the table for an intriguing final 10 episodes.

+Malcom takes center stage

+Malcom gets incentive for being the big bad once again

+Nyssa

+Trial by combat

+New fold in the "who's in the grave?" story line

9.3/10
28 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
John Barrowman Shines In A Gripping And Powerful Episode
veikkohoffman23 July 2016
While the fourth season of Arrow hasn't been on the same level as the previous seasons as a whole, there are absolutely amazing individual episodes in the mix. A good example is Sins Of The Father, quite possibly my favorite episode of this season so far. It does a good job combining the best characters, story lines and other elements of the series, resulting in a powerful and memorable episode.

Malcolm Merlyn has always been the most intriguing and well-written character on Arrow - or in the whole CW/DC television universe for that matter. The way the character is constantly flailing between good and bad, trustworthy and betraying, likable and frustrating, all of that just makes him into such a great character. And this episode highlights that, as John Barrowman gives his best acting performance so far and his character becomes even more fascinating. All of his scenes here are pure gold, and that alone makes the episode stand out.

In a bigger picture, the episode succeeds on more levels than just utilizing one amazing character. There's also the drama with Thea's life hanging in the balance, intertwined with the League Of Assassins descending to the brink of a civil war. I won't give away any specific plot details, but many of the story lines that have been building up for multiple seasons come down to a boiling point. The rivalry between Nyssa and Merlyn makes for a fresh break from the episodes focused on defeating Damien Darkh and his people. Towards the end of the episode, we are also treated to one of the best fight scenes in Arrow history, as two major characters duel one another. The directing, choreography, acting, soundtrack and everything else about that scene is just breathtaking.

In an even bigger picture, this episode deals with a large theme - fatherhood. This is accomplished in many ways from many directions: Merlyn doing anything in his power to save his daughter, Felicity's father trying to reconnect with her, and even references to Oliver's son William and their distant relationship. Also Nyssa going up against her father's legacy goes together with this theme. 'Sins Of The Father' as a title describes the episode quite well, as many of the father-characters do questionable things with more or less good intentions, giving a conflicting view on the subject.

The episode ends on a brutal twist that I won't spoil here. I partially saw it coming, but not in a bad and predictable way, rather a slow-burning "It all lead up to this moment" way. I am excited (and slightly terrified) to see what follows from here. All in all, this episode shows season 4's full potential, and hopefully we'll have more like this towards the end of the season. I can only keep guessing what Darkh is planning for next, and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing where Merlyn's character arc goes from here.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Such Stupid Reasoning!
rhagelberg6 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
It is so ridiculous that when Oliver is contemplating that Malcolm may have a change of heart, in order to save his relationship with his daughter, Thea, they never take into account all of the lives that are lost. They only think about their own family in the whole scheme of things. They are definitely not superheroes in any sense of the word. They are still considered vigilantes and put so many people in harms way.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The silliness continues
kjv-0622919 July 2019
The silly scream by The Canary is absolutely ridiculous. Not credible to think the league of Assassins would not be immune to this goofy tactic. Further I have become bored with the story line. Get on with it!!!!
1 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed