A Christmas Wish (TV Movie 2011) Poster

(2011 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
30 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An original plot with believable performances
SimonJack7 December 2018
Most modern Christmas movies are either fantasies about romance found unexpectedly or about troubled families whose members discover the true meaning of Christmas. Very few have different or original plots. I can't think of another film that has focused so completely upon the plight of a single mother struggling to raise three children after her husband deserts them.

"A Christmas Wish" is a true drama that doesn't have to be set at Christmas or in any particular season. But the seasonal theme adds something to the film. That's significant in providing hope for a happy ending, where this film digs deeply into the intensity and stress of the woman giving her all so that her family can survive.

The film has some light and amusing scenes, with some witty dialog and funny moments. But it also has intense drama. There are sad scenes, depressing situations and incidents that seem almost hopeless for Martha Evans. Some people may not appreciate this as a Christmas movie to cherish and watch in succeeding years. But others may find it especially appropriate.

Evans is a very believable single parent under extreme duress. Kristy Swanson gives a superb performance in that role. It was deserving of an Emmy nomination but the Emmy's seem almost to have a bias against Christmas themed films. Perhaps it's because each year brings out one to a few movies that appear to be just slight moderations of well-worn themes. And Kirstin Dorn is tremendous as the very intelligent and wise young Mel Evans. The rest of the cast all give good performances.

This is a very good drama about a life that far too many women have experienced, and that has too seldom been shown in film. For that reason alone, this is a movie some may want to keep and replay in years to come. It's also a film about hope and perseverance and good rising from dedication, sacrifice and love for family and children. That's what makes it an especially different and memorable Christmas film.

Here are some favorite lines from the film.

Mel Evans, "Why do you call the car Jack?" Martha Evans, "Because it rhymes with Cadillac."

Joe Hopkins, "Gotta help heathens once in a while, or he wouldn't have a congregation."

Lola Metcalf, "Do you know why most women would rather have beauty than brains?" Martha Evans, "Why?" Lola, "Because most men can see better than they can think."

Martha Evans, "Okay, how do you want your eggs?" Les McCallum, "From a chicken." Martha, writing on her order pad, "Right! No fish eggs. Uh, how do you want 'em?" Les, "On a plate." Martha, "Raw?" Les, "Over, easy."

Martha Evans, "Well, being single's not so bad." Joe Hopkins: I'm not single. I'm romantically challenged."

Lola Metcalf, "Here you go (mumbling in a low tone) tall, dark and available."

Lola Metcalf, "In fact, you're the first woman I've seen him take an interest in." Martha Evans, "The destitute mother of three?" Lola, "Yeah, go figure."

Lola Metcalf, "Side of gravy's comin' up." Frank, "I need more butter." Lola, "You want some heart medicine to go with that cholesterol?"
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nice film
raymondrogers-6354129 September 2017
This television film shows that all of us need help at one time in our lives. It also shows that "It Does Take a Village".

In this film Martha's no good husband, Cal (Bart Johnson), has left her for the last time, emptying her bank account and disappearing without a word. Hopeless, Martha takes to the road and winds up in a motel broke & homeless with 3 kids.

This film sounds like it is a downer but in reality it is a great film to watch. This is a film about how all of us can help anyone at anytime. Small things you think you did can make a huge impact on people.

This film is not far fetched. It is not just people in small towns in the United States that are like this. However in small towns word does get around fast when someone needs any type of help!
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very good Christmas movie
janmanuel26 December 2018
I dislike many Hallmark movies especially the cookie cutter Christmas movies. There are some stands outs however, even in the Christmas genre, and this is one of them. The acting is superb. I love anything centered around a diner in a small town. I won't rehash the plot. The kids are darling, not brats. Kristie Swanson is not too old for this role as some reviewer said. Women have children through their 30s and even 40s now. I watch this movie every year. It's very moving and sweet.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
With the help of new friends things might turn out OK after all.
TxMike29 December 2020
Here 40-something Kristy Swanson plays 30-something Martha Evans whose husband of 4 years runs off with a woman in the weeks leading up to Christmas, wipes out the bank account, and leaves her with three children aged 3 to about 11. Not sure why but she puts them all in the old family car and heads north, ending up in a small community in Utah.

Once there she has to find a place to stay and a job and ultimately has to rely on the kindness of her new friends to make a go of it. And the kids have to start at a new school with the boy dealing with the school bully.

This is a nice small movie, some of the dialog doesn't seem to fit but overall nicely acted and with a good message. It was nice to see Edward Hermann in a different role for him, he died in 2014.

My wife and I watched it on Amazon streaming movies.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Good Family Friendly, Family Values Movie
dickklip23 November 2011
This is a very watchable movie, very typical of the Hallmark Channel Christmas movies, which my wife and I love to watch to get us in the holiday spirit. As is typical, we find a woman whose rodeo cowboy husband has abandoned her; leaving her broke and with three kids to care for. Things go from bad to worse as she battles a series of mishaps trying to find a new home for herself and her children. If you ever think that you've had a bad day or week, you've never gone through anything like this woman faces! The acting is, however, very good, from a variety of veterans, like Edward Hermann, Tess Harper, and others. Ultimately, as with all Hallmark movies, things are resolved in the final six minutes.

This is a very enjoyable movie, and I was especially surprised and impressed with the plot theme of showing the true meaning of Christmas, and the power of prayer, something which most modern movies avoid. It definitely is a "feel good" movie, and one which teaches strong family values. Despite the predicable, and somewhat thin plot, and several loose ends being hastily tied up at the end, it is worth the watch.
33 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Fond Memory
VintageSoul5630 November 2017
I have watched this movie every Christmas since it was first on in 2011. In fact, I'm watching it now.

I have a fond memory of this movie because I watched it the first year that it was on with my mom. That was 6 years ago. My mom passed away in December 2015. So, it reminds me of us sitting in her living room watching it. Mom thought that it was a good old fashioned sentimental movie that did make our eyes a little misty. I remember her saying that Kristy Swenson was a pretty girl. Mom was 91 at the time, so Kristy was a girl to her. Mom had some tough times too and she related to her character.

I like it because of the same reasons. It is about kindness to people struggling, but trying to improve their situation and hope that things will get better. I thought that the acting was realistic. Kristy was great, Edward Hermann gave a good performance, as usual. Page Petrucka who plays Lola is a hoot and a half. The only thing, and it's minor, the time line of the story is a bit rushed. But, they had to fit a lot of story in less than 2 hours.

If you like old fashioned, sentimental Christmas fare, this is for you.
19 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Worth Watching
Christmas-Reviewer27 August 2016
BEWARE OF BOGUS REVIEWS. SOME REVIEWERS HAVE ONLY ONE REVIEW. WHEN ITS A POSITIVE REVIEW THAT TELLS ME THEY WERE INVOLVED WITH THE PRODUCTION. IF ITS A NEGATIVE REVIEW THEN THEY MIGHT HAVE A GRUDGE AGAINST THAT PRODUCTION. NOW I HAVE REVIEWED OVER 200 Christmas MOVIES. I HAVE NO AGENDA. I AM FARE ABOUT THESE FILMS.

This film is not a ripoff of "It's a Wonderful Life". That is a topic that someone started on IMDb message board. I can assure that it may of drawn inspiration from that film but it has more in common with "Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore".

In this film a woman finds herself suddenly single after she wakes up one day and finds out her husband has just ran off with another woman.

She takes off to in a car and end ups in a small town where she ends up living a motel and becomes an overnight waitress at a local restaurant.

You can check off all the boxes on the Christmas movie check off list with this film but that doesn't mean this isn't a good film it really is a nice film to see. The on camera talent is above average. It is enjoyable. Most of all it shows that it is better to give than to receive.

To many people the plot may seem "Unbelievable" but trust me in small towns people really do help each other. They know how to be good neighbors. I am a liberal but trust me "The South" has many good decent hard working and caring people.
23 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Sweet movie, but it isn't 1925
deetdee1214 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
I'll give it a 4, because I DID cry and the little boy was an excellent actor (his stammering just broke my heart). That said, it's A) completely derivative and B) ignores a whole bunch of options open to the destitute mom.

First the unoriginal part: Hallmark Hall of Fame themselves already basically did the same movie 12 years ago starring Carla Guigino called "A Season of Miracles". Single, impoverished caretaker of sweet, scraggly moppets? Check. Wonderful small town full of warm hearted people who only want to help? Check. Car problems she can't afford/have her stranded? Check. Perfect hawt lawman love interest? Check. Minimum wage job that she's grateful for and somehow provides for them all? Check. Christmas/Jesus last minute miracle? Check.

Except at least in "A Season", Carla's on the run from DHS with her niece and nephew, so you understand why she's hiding in a tiny town and not looking for any assistance. In Martha's case, it just makes zero sense.

As an abandoned mom, she has an entire litany of services available to her. She is precisely WHY there are programs like TANF, WIC and Food Stamps. While I admire her independence, I'd have swallowed my pride really fast to keep my kids fed and housed. It's always meant to be a hand up, not a hand out--and clearly she was in dire straights.

Instead of wasting precious gas and subjecting my kids to such uncertainty, I would've sucked it up and visited my local DHS office. Where they also would've been able to offer me job training or placement assistance. And provided Early Head Start Care for the youngest (who acted like she was about 18 months, NOT 3). With three kids, she would've been placed at the top of the list for housing, as well.

My next visit would've been to the courts (which any DHS social worker, also could've helped me with). Sorry, but fathers don't get to just run out on their kids and then get divorces within a week---totally free of responsibilities. She should've been receiving child support from her first husband for her older daughter, as well.

Even if this hadn't been the case, once her kids were enrolled at school again, they would've automatically qualified for free breakfast and lunch---and school officials would've directed her to social services, as well.

Instead we saw this silly, Republican fantasy in which the government is evil ("sorry, I had to take out taxes" says Tess Harper. Except with three dependents, earning minimum wage and taxes being so low now, anyway that wouldn't have been much at ALL), but the church and others will provide for you. Except in real life, she'd just work at the local Walmart and watch her life slip away.

Also, Kristy Swanson, at 42, was waaaaay too old to portray someone who should've been 30 or younger.

And lastly, since everyone so wanted to help her, when she was gonna be tossed out, why didn't someone just say, "hey you can stay with me for awhile"???
23 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A beautiful tearjerker!
neenerlily859 December 2014
I saw this movie for the first time a few years back. I love watching all those made for TV Christmas movies but this one just made my heart swell. It has such a wonderful story of one Woman's struggle to make ends meet and when all seems truly lost, when she is truly broken and realizes she cannot do it on her own, she does the only thing she can do.... Gives it to God... It is also about Angels... Not the ones with wings and a halo, real life Angels who come together and surround you with love and Friendship. Sometimes, the support of those around you can make all the difference in you life.... If you need a good (and happy) cry, this is the movie for you... This movie will truly lift your spirits!!
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A wish for Christmas
TheLittleSongbird4 January 2022
My Christmas film viewings over-time have been a very mixed bag. With some surprisingly good hits, where regardless of how predictable they are succeed in being full of charm, warmth and heart so succeeding in being light-hearted and undemanding fun. But also some quite big misses, where the characters are not likeable, everything is forced and shallow with implausibility too in some of the worst cases, the acting and writing being weak and basically with just nothing to them.

Despite being a long way from perfect or being a complete hit, 'A Christmas Wish' is thankfully closer to the former category. It is the second Kristy Swanson Christmas film seen back to back (the other being 'Angels in the Snow') and is the infinitely superior one, with it actually being a good film and Swanson is also much better here. Although the story execution is not perfect, 'A Christmas Wish' is still sincere and moving and is worth seeing for primarily the cast.

'A Christmas Wish' isn't perfect. It takes a bit of time to find its footing pace-wise with it being a bit thin and draggy story-wise at times. Not all the script is there, with moments of awkwardness and sugar heaviness.

The messaging is well-intentioned but features too much and is on the heavy-handed side.

However, there is a lot to like about 'A Christmas Wish'. It looks attractive enough. The scenery is both rustic and festive and the photography doesn't look rushed or drab, quite beautiful actually. The music doesn't come over as too melodramatic while still having some presence. The direction is suitably sympathetic on the most part while taking a little time to find its feet. The dialogue is not perfect either but the cheese and sentiment don't go overboard and it generally doesn't come over as stilted.

Furthermore, the story, despite its imperfections, is warm hearted and has a lot of well meaning heart, without taking itself too seriously. The film did leave me feeling very moved. The characters interest and are worth investing in, not being too perfect or having flaws too exaggerated, which was refreshing after seeing a few films with distastefully over the top unpleasant characters that you are meant to root for. Swanson's performance is deeply felt and doesn't get melodramatic. Kirstin Dorn is a charmer and similarly moving and Edward Hermann once again plays the type of role he played so well beautifully.

Overall, not great but well done in a lot of areas. 7/10.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Decent movie but...
kessannlgrant25 December 2020
The movie was an okay movie. The storyline could have been developed a little more to be compelling but it's a Christmas movie so my expectations were low to begin with. However, there was a line in the movie that goes, "He's normal and she's a South American looney tune" or something to that effect. Very disappointing to see a movie released in 2011 using that type of reference. Seems like the writers needed some sensitivity training. Considering that 99% of the cast is white, why make the South American woman the crazy one??? These are the subtle messages that continuously feed stereotypes and foster discrimination. Shameful.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Love this movie
christine_aliotta12 December 2019
I love this time of year for the hallmark and lifetime christmas movies . I record and watch where Sunday with my Hallmark watching mug, and this ones not playing this year . I'm so upset. Also a single mom and have been where she is in this movie , about to be again so please forget all the new movies you keep making, dont forget the old faves.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
This deserved nothing more than the incinerator, which it could have ended up in had the director actually gone to a film school.
theperfectmarysuekiller26 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
When first seeing the DVD case, I assumed it was going to be boring, preachy and needlessly heavy handed in being so. I was correct, unfortunately, yet I was still unprepared for the horrible acting, scripting and execution.

The movie can be summarized as follows: women loses husband, moves, settles in new town, goes through a bunch of contrived and boring crap, only to finally get help after praying. The problem is that there is no sign any of it had anything to do with god. The villagers were already helping her almost as much as the government support programs she should have swallowed her pride and gotten for the sake of her children. There was no surprise when she got the financial support and room, which is why it makes no sense as to why she believed it was from god. Clearly, whoever made this had a religious agenda. Maybe her husband would have stayed with her if she had an actual personality.

I personally felt this movie lacked a few things, such as a decent script, decent actors and an engaging story. Kick-Ass, by virtue of a capable director and decent acting would be a better choice for the family. Sure, it may not be appropriate, but at least they will be entertained. As a plus, the humor there is intentional, and it works.

For this reason, I cannot recommend that you buy this movie. The only thing they got right was holding the camera still, and given that most movies are shot on a mounted camera, even that may be giving it too much credit. Maybe not, considering that if they are making back 100 times their budget each time they sell one DVD, maybe they couldn't afford a mounted camera.

All in all, lacking even unintentional humor or talent on the part of anyone involved, this travesty fails even as "so bad its horrible material". It isn't something I willingly watched, actively though unsuccessfully trying to avoid it. If you like boring, contrived, sappy, pointless and irritating movies so bad they fail to even provoke the bile fascination caused by Birdemic, this movie is for you. But if you are a normal person, watching this should be akin to an arachnophobe seeing a spider the size of a dog. That you would avoid it at all costs and never look at it again.
14 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Pretty good TV Christmas movie
rob-sibley21 November 2011
Our family likes to watch Christmas movies on the Hallmark Channel. While most of the shows are similar it is a safe network to view family style programs. Some of the shows are so bad we just laugh at poor writing, cheap production values and just plain bad acting. Watch "The National Tree" and you'll know what I mean. "A Christmas Wish" was on par with some of the better programs. While the story was familiar to many Hallmark movies the dialog was a cut above. The show was actually filmed during the winter instead of summer with fake snow scattered around. There were some cute moments which caused us to laugh out loud (in a good way), but perhaps what this Christmas movie had that the others did not was the true meaning of the season. Although not over bearing it did mention the birth of Christ and the importance faith plays in our lives. Overall a good effort.
35 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wanted: A better screenplay (but keep the actors!)
gee-1521 November 2011
A woman has just been left by her husband and takes her two children and stepson away to find a better life. They end up in a small town where a friendly cafe owner gives the woman a job. The movie then explores how this woman tries to make a new life for herself with the help of the kind townspeople including a handsome deputy whose interest in her hints at the possibility of romance.

I wouldn't say this film is awful...just mediocre. And the frustrating thing is that it didn't have to be. It creates some interesting characters that are portrayed well by the actors involved. It has a heartwarming theme about faith and love but ultimately the writer(s) fails to make the story compelling.
22 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A little heavy handed with religion
kz917-111 December 2017
Kristy Swanson stars in this Christmas film about a woman with three kids in search of a new job and place to call home after her toad of a husband skips town with all the family's cash. To make matters even more complicated one of the kids is a stepson, who isn't happy about being separated from his father (even though he is much better off for it!). They eventually land in a town where the residents are mostly helpful, but a few are out to scam her out of every dime she has. In the end Christmas spirit is out in full force!
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A feel good film with not surprising plot holes -
sheldonlinda3 December 2021
"A Christmas Wish"

I love this film. There are granted several of plot holes but it is one of those film that as it is about service is just makes you feel good.

Kristy Swanson is fun to watch, KC Clyde is fun to watch, but the fact that Kristy is eleven years older than KC is distracting. Fortunately, the film is not really about their relationship and there is no ending big kiss or romantic resolution. I didn't think that Kristy was necessarily too old for her role, but she just didn't match with KC.

The film instead is about "Martha's" circumstances and the kids. Why did Martha leave where she was living? She at least had a roof over her head. Did I miss her being evicted? Surprising that even with kids that considering her circumstances that she hasn't been working. Bart Johnson is too nice of a guy to be playing the abusive husband. The parts of the kids were well acted. It was disappointed that they didn't do much with acting elsewhere. The girl in particular was well acted. As someone else commented, it was interesting seeing Ed Herrman with his as usual amazing acting and in a different sort of role.

Dani Cuchran in the teen part of her career was fun to see.

Things as usual in Christmas films did "wrap up" a little too nicely.

I originally saw the film under the working title "A Rootbeer Christmas." I was disappointed when I saw that the title had been changed to "A Christmas Wish" which is far from a unique name for a Christmas film. I think that I heard that it is because people in Europe don't care for the taste of rootbeer that that is the reason that it was changed.

I understand the films made by the LDS/ Mormon market that clearly take place in that market using terms such as "pastor" to make the film more accessible to other groups, but it still bothers me. Hello just say that the nice heavy set man is the bishop and not the pastor!

The film made me wish to live in a small town like Mapleton, Utah where the film takes place and to work in a diner such as "The Rootbeer." Evidently, at one time it was an actual diner, but is now an insurance office or something. I was disappointed to learn that it is no longer a real diner. I keep meaning to drive passed it, but I haven't.

"A Christmas Wish" I love this film. There are granted several of plot holes but it is one of those film that as it is about service is just makes you feel good.

Kristy Swanson is fun to watch, KC Clyde is fun to watch, but the fact that Kristy is eleven years older than KC is distracting. Fortunately, the film is not really about their relationship and there is no ending big kiss or romantic resolution. I didn't think that Kristy was necessarily too old for her role, but she just didn't match with KC.

The film instead is about "Martha's" circumstances and the kids. Why did Martha leave where she was living? She at least had a roof over her head. Did I miss her being evicted? Surprising that even with kids that considering her circumstances that she hasn't been working. Bart Johnson is too nice of a guy to be playing the abusive husband. The parts of the kids were well acted. It was disappointed that they didn't do much with acting elsewhere. The girl in particular was well acted. As someone else commented, it was interesting seeing Ed Herrman with his as usual amazing acting and in a different sort of role.

Dani Cuchran in the teen part of her career was fun to see.

Things as usual in Christmas films did "wrap up" a little too nicely.

I originally saw the film under the working title "A Rootbeer Christmas." I was disappointed when I saw that the title had been changed to "A Christmas Wish" which is far from a unique name for a Christmas film. I think that I heard that it is because people in Europe don't care for the taste of rootbeer that that is the reason that it was changed.

I understand the films made by the LDS/ Mormon market that clearly take place in that market using terms such as "pastor" to make the film more accessible to other groups, but it still bothers me. Hello just say that the nice heavy set man is the bishop and not the pastor!

The film made me wish to live in a small town like Mapleton, Utah where the film takes place and to work in a diner such as "The Rootbeer." Evidently, at one time it was an actual diner, but is now an insurance office or something. I was disappointed to learn that it is no longer a real diner. I keep meaning to drive passed it, but I haven't.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Just Pray, and Everything's Okay.
emortland24 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
When the kids in a Christmas movie say something like "God will look after us" you know it's not a light & lively Hallmark holiday film, but another deep and meaningful message that no matter how low you go, God pops up and everything will be all right. If you believe. In this case, it's a place to live, new job, valuable car, etc.

I don't know, sometimes I'm in the mood for this stuff, but most times "inspirational" themes are pretty predictable & formulaic, and this one just seemed to take a long time before God comes through. I assume He's busier during Christmas. Ms Swanson is cool, I was surprised Mr Herrmann & Ms Harper were in this, and all the adults have beautiful teeth. God Bless everyone in this.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Touching performance by Kristy Swanson
emaureen25 December 2011
The drama rose above the clichés because of excellent performances all around, especially by Kristy Swanson. There was enough material, and enough characters (mostly endearing), for a regular TV series spanning a year. This single mom had a TERRIBLE two weeks. My only regret was the inevitability of everything winding up in a hurry.

I got a laugh from the review saying that at 42, Swanson was too old to play the part of someone who should be around 30. For this role, you need someone who might be thirty but who shows the prematurely ageing effects of too much worry and too many sleepless nights. I thought she was perfect. Lots of good characters, so this Hallmark Christmas movie is recommended. However, I'd steer clear of the menu at the diner, far too much gravy.
19 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Very very very belief oriented
tashinaknight25 December 2014
This might be a positive or negative review, depending on beliefs.

Overall, the movie was pretty mediocre TV-movie fare, with a couple better then normal actors. I'll watch almost any Hallmark Channel style Christmas movie while I surf the internet. I'm not terribly picky - some turn out to be surprisingly good, some are just terrible. I rarely have to just give up on one.

This one I did. If I were religious, I think I would have given it a 6 out of 10 by the end. I am generally tolerant of a certain amount of religion in a movie, but this one was just over the top and preachy (and not just religious, but go-to-church religious). I started to fast forward those bits, but finally turned it off. If you are not solidly a religious church going person, I'd recommend giving it a pass.

If you are, I think you'll like it. It's nothing special, but not a bad example of the genre.

TL;DR: every 5-10 minutes there was another religious segment.
11 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Well done movie.
zazoots26 December 2020
Enjoyed this movie a lot. It was well done. Plot moved along. Good acting. An honest scenario.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Nice idea but....
sunisfun-9937222 November 2022
The story never changed. OMG it was the longest movie I think I have ever seen. So poorly done!! It says comedy/drama but it's only drama. Don't get me wrong, the idea of the movie was heartwarming but the entire movie was about a single mom looking for a house, like the ENTIRE movie was about that house. Also, the dad/ex husband in the show looks like some gangster, member of Mafia, danger to society... You get the point. Not someone you would see married to a down to earth, religious lady. That part didn't make an ounce of sense, way overdone. Anyways, movie had potential but it was lazy writing.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Christmas Wish should be added to Christmas Wish list!
markzanotti18 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
A Christmas Wish is a great Hallmark presentation. It is about a young mother and her two little daughters and step-son, who are deserted by his dad just before Christmas. The mother, Martha Evans, played by Kristy Swanson, decides to get into her old car and take the children to a new location. She doesn't know where, as she begins this new life, and she has very little money.

The struggling family end up in a small western town, where she begs for a restaurant job and gets it! The rest of the story shows how the townspeople help her in different ways, and how she develops a special friendship with a caring policeman, Joe Hopkins, played by K.C. Clyde.

Martha's stepson, Miles, played by Kevin Herring,III, has the toughest time adjusting because he misses his unfit dad. Little Miles is beaten by mean boys, because he stutters, and he is shy and wears eyeglasses.

The story is, also, about Christmas and what this special season is really about...Jesus! The older girl, Mel, about 9, is very sweet, as she tells her little sister, Lilee, played by Lilee Clyde, and Miles the story of the first Christmas.

Mel, played by Kirstin Dorn, is really an encourager to her mother and she tells her mom to pray to God for help.

As the family gets acquainted with others, Miles is befriended by a big man, Les McCallum, played by the late Ed Herrmann. The character, Les, pretends to be a tough old man, but he really softens towards Miles and Martha.

Les teaches Miles on how to get rid of the school bullies!

Craig Clyde. the movie director, earned recognition and awards for this wonderful Christmas movie.

I am, thankful, also, for the writers for making this a moral, uplifting, non-rated film for all ages! I thank everyone, who helped make this movie, and I hope more decent films will be made like this one. I just want to add this note to them: Please don't be afraid to make stronger witnessing movies, that help others come to Christ and to receive Him as Lord and Savior! Jesus is truly the reason to celebrate, not just at Christmas, but all year-round! God Bless You!
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Christmas Wish is a heartwarming, cute Christmas movie!
mraymond-9102318 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
A Christmas Wish is an above average Hallmark movie, because a little girl, Mel Evans, (Kirstin Dorn), tells the story of the first Christmas to her little sister and step brother. The movie centers around their mom and them after the unfaithful, mean father abandons them just a short time before Christmas. He runs off with most of their money and leaves the mother in a very poor financial and emotional state.

The mom, Martha Evans, (Kristy Swanson), packs their old car and takes the children on the road to find a new place to live, while she also looks for employment to keep them fed.

Martha begs a restaurant owner for work. The lady owner, Trudy Willis, (Tess Harper), has a struggling business, but she has compassion for the hurting family and gives Martha employment. The mom and three children have to stay in a budget motel, until money can be earned for a permanent place to live. (All kinds of crazy things happen after this!) This is a sweet movie and the other two children, little Lilee Evans, (Lilee Clyde) and Miles Evans, (Kevin Herring III), a stuttering boy, play their roles very well. A handsome policeman, Joe Hopkins, (KC Wilson Clyde), rescues them, more then once! I won't tell you all of this story....There are some very scary, tearful moments, but Martha prays to God, and the Lord blesses them beyond her expectations! God uses the loving, generous townspeople and sweet Joe Hopkins! This is definitely a wonderful Christmas movie for all ages and I hope that you buy this DVD.

The reason that I did not give it a "10" rating is because I like to see someone pray to receive and know Jesus, as his, or her Lord and Savior in a movie! In closing, I want to ask Craig Clyde to make future Christian themed movies that show this. Also, please make more movies that can are non-rated or G ones. "G" means "general audience", not for just children! I am 65 years old and my sons are 36 and 39 year old men. We value and only watch movies that are wholesome and moral. Merry Christmas, and may God bless us, everyone!
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Didnt notice before this year
knrdodson-78-60294413 December 2018
With all of the criticism of racial slurs this jumped out at me. I hadn't noticed it before. A waitress says, "He's normal and she's a south american LOONIE TUNE."
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed