Yet another mining expedition. This time the Earth is running out of rare metals and a crew is sent to explore a planet to create strip mines and take what is there. While on patrol, the agents are attacked by some lizard men (again). The issue in this one is "Little House's" Melissa Gilbert, who feels that the indigenous people are not evil and are only responding in self defense. She is seen as weak by one of the soldiers and a mutiny occurs. She bonds with one of the creatures that has been seriously injured and tries to save him, all to no avail. The killing in cold blood goes on. Even when the creatures cower and beg for their lives, they are gunned down mercilessly. Colonization seems to be an issue and the earth is desperate for resources. Sound familiar. This is the road we seem to be traveling, so this may be a bit allegorical.
5 Reviews
It was OK anyway.
ObscureAuteur20 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Problems with the New Outer Limits. Many.
First was that at most half the scripts were really worth doing at all which is inexcusable given the vast resources of untapped stories in decades of science fiction and fantasy magazines and books.
Another was the dubious choice to remake a few of the best original series stories producing episodes that were manifestly inferior to the old black and white version in every way but looks. Exceptions might be "Feasibility Study" that was not far off the original as I recall, and "I,Robot" when we must choose between the good simple Adam Link of old, or the new dark, brooding, punky one. In the original the good people were the cynics, now the robot is a cynic too! At least both were good episodes. Definitely no exception for the "Inheritors" chopped down to a cold, sickly one hour.
The worst problem was that at least once each season the producers grossly compounded their deficiencies by turning out an episode made out of recycled scenes from earlier ones with the lamest script of all (no exceptions). A budget saver for sure but an insult to any serious and knowledgeable viewer. This was bad enough when it was one episode but the producers topped themselves with a two part regurgitation, "Final Appeal", that wasted an astounding battery of well known major actors and actresses headed by no less than Charleton Heston.
About as bad as that was, was the addition of superfluous text (was this a legal thing?) to the signature control voice speech that starts every show, and the pretentious and usually non sequitur comments of the control voice for the start and end of specific episodes. This was not a problem on the old show but an embarrassing excrescence on the new one.
Another problem, one that applies here, is that there seemed to be a definite mission to deconstruct the 50's sci-fi tradition, still well in evidence in the original series, that one way or another, no matter how out-brained, out tech-ed, or even out-numbered, humanity always emerged triumphant(1). It would not be a problem, in fact it is long overdue on TV, except that it usually resulted in rather facile, contrived episodes that were merely snarky, or dreary and obvious preaching rather than good sci-fi with a message. Thus the reviewer that complains of the baldly preachy episodes found in this series has a point.
(SPOILER) But I liked this one anyway if only for the pleasure of seeing the consternation of the swaggering corporate mercenaries (compare to the real life example of Blackwater contractors in the field today) among the crew when they finally realized that they had affirmed their manhood and species superiority by boldly wiping out a scout troop on a camp-out, the parents had arrived, and they were going to get their final lesson in survival of the fittest in short order after their files were uploaded, and resistance was indeed futile. It is a nice enough twist for a respectable short story in a magazine or a one hour TV show. One of most successful of these deconstruction episodes. (End of SPOILER)
Still I was glad someone was giving this a try and getting on the air. The best of these episodes are better than a typical "sci-fi channel original" movie and nearly all are better than the rest of the trash passed off as original sci-fi on cable. I would forgive them almost everything if it weren't for those awful and insulting recycle episodes.
====================================
(1) Is this merely pandering? Or is it a significant expression of the arrogant assumptions of the place of humanity in the cosmos that pervade most the world's cultures and religions?
First was that at most half the scripts were really worth doing at all which is inexcusable given the vast resources of untapped stories in decades of science fiction and fantasy magazines and books.
Another was the dubious choice to remake a few of the best original series stories producing episodes that were manifestly inferior to the old black and white version in every way but looks. Exceptions might be "Feasibility Study" that was not far off the original as I recall, and "I,Robot" when we must choose between the good simple Adam Link of old, or the new dark, brooding, punky one. In the original the good people were the cynics, now the robot is a cynic too! At least both were good episodes. Definitely no exception for the "Inheritors" chopped down to a cold, sickly one hour.
The worst problem was that at least once each season the producers grossly compounded their deficiencies by turning out an episode made out of recycled scenes from earlier ones with the lamest script of all (no exceptions). A budget saver for sure but an insult to any serious and knowledgeable viewer. This was bad enough when it was one episode but the producers topped themselves with a two part regurgitation, "Final Appeal", that wasted an astounding battery of well known major actors and actresses headed by no less than Charleton Heston.
About as bad as that was, was the addition of superfluous text (was this a legal thing?) to the signature control voice speech that starts every show, and the pretentious and usually non sequitur comments of the control voice for the start and end of specific episodes. This was not a problem on the old show but an embarrassing excrescence on the new one.
Another problem, one that applies here, is that there seemed to be a definite mission to deconstruct the 50's sci-fi tradition, still well in evidence in the original series, that one way or another, no matter how out-brained, out tech-ed, or even out-numbered, humanity always emerged triumphant(1). It would not be a problem, in fact it is long overdue on TV, except that it usually resulted in rather facile, contrived episodes that were merely snarky, or dreary and obvious preaching rather than good sci-fi with a message. Thus the reviewer that complains of the baldly preachy episodes found in this series has a point.
(SPOILER) But I liked this one anyway if only for the pleasure of seeing the consternation of the swaggering corporate mercenaries (compare to the real life example of Blackwater contractors in the field today) among the crew when they finally realized that they had affirmed their manhood and species superiority by boldly wiping out a scout troop on a camp-out, the parents had arrived, and they were going to get their final lesson in survival of the fittest in short order after their files were uploaded, and resistance was indeed futile. It is a nice enough twist for a respectable short story in a magazine or a one hour TV show. One of most successful of these deconstruction episodes. (End of SPOILER)
Still I was glad someone was giving this a try and getting on the air. The best of these episodes are better than a typical "sci-fi channel original" movie and nearly all are better than the rest of the trash passed off as original sci-fi on cable. I would forgive them almost everything if it weren't for those awful and insulting recycle episodes.
====================================
(1) Is this merely pandering? Or is it a significant expression of the arrogant assumptions of the place of humanity in the cosmos that pervade most the world's cultures and religions?
Brilliant Concept, Relevant Human exploration questions
thewhale-4913420 August 2019
Good Story, plenty of twist and turns.
Reminded me of a Twilight Zone episode.
Well worth watching until the end.
Really Excellent ending. Surprised there has not been a feature movie made of this story line and very cleaver ending.
I give it ten of the depth of the story.... Script and acting ok.
Special affects work fine for the story.
Great Story and Fantastic Ending
metrowestjp22 March 2023
This is probably my all-time favorite episode of The Outer Limits series from the '90s. It's such a great story, and I did not see that ending coming. I don't want to give anything away, but it's basically a cautionary tale about the value of life and the dangers of arrogance, jumping to conclusions and taking drastic action without knowing all the facts, all set on a supposedly uninhabited alien world that's being investigated for natural resources by a group of humans who have just arrived from Earth. I love the way it was written, and it has one of the best twist endings of the series. Melissa Gilbert's last lines of dialogue at the end finally bring the horrific reality of their situation into sharp focus and hit like a punch to the throat. I get chills every time I hear them.
Melissa Gilbert Delivered the Deathknell
richard.fuller110 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Think of Aliens with Sigourney Weaver.
That is pretty much what this looked like. Creepy, spiked, lizard like creatures found on a planet by an Earth expedition.
The planet they are found on is barren, with virtually no form of civilization whatsoever.
They are inferior to us, beneath us.
I caught this one on the Sci Fi channel, and watched to see the outcome.
Melissa Gilbert was the biologist who found herself in command, then had her command taken from her in a mutiny, because she was pitying the aliens too much.
She sought to get one to safety, but her three male cohorts overtook her and killed the alien lizard thing.
Two are found in a cave. Primitive. One is holding an object, apparently an idol.
Melissa is back in the lab with two of the alien bodies and observes the item. It isn't an idol. It is a probe. For communication.
She then realizes something and does a scan on the alien corpses. Their craniums aren't developed fully.
They are in fact, children. Teen agers.
What the Earth team just wiped out wasn't primitive aliens, it was an alien boy scout troop, Melissa says.
And the parents and alien authorities are seeking justice. Here they come.
Fade.
That is pretty much what this looked like. Creepy, spiked, lizard like creatures found on a planet by an Earth expedition.
The planet they are found on is barren, with virtually no form of civilization whatsoever.
They are inferior to us, beneath us.
I caught this one on the Sci Fi channel, and watched to see the outcome.
Melissa Gilbert was the biologist who found herself in command, then had her command taken from her in a mutiny, because she was pitying the aliens too much.
She sought to get one to safety, but her three male cohorts overtook her and killed the alien lizard thing.
Two are found in a cave. Primitive. One is holding an object, apparently an idol.
Melissa is back in the lab with two of the alien bodies and observes the item. It isn't an idol. It is a probe. For communication.
She then realizes something and does a scan on the alien corpses. Their craniums aren't developed fully.
They are in fact, children. Teen agers.
What the Earth team just wiped out wasn't primitive aliens, it was an alien boy scout troop, Melissa says.
And the parents and alien authorities are seeking justice. Here they come.
Fade.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
