"MacGyver" Legend of the Holy Rose: Part 1 (TV Episode 1989) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
MacGyver at its Best. And worst.
aramis-112-8048805 October 2022
"MacGyver" has always been derivative. So derivative episodes took footage from "The Italian Job" with Michael Caine and "The Naked Jungle" with Charlton Heston (even reusing its plot to the last detail).

Now, on the wake of "Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade" he's even on the quest for the so-called "Holy Grail."

A few factoids, first. The Holy Grail is a fictional device invented (yes, invented) by monk and 12th century novelist Cretien de Troyes. The word Grail even derives from a local 12th century Troyes term. The story of the Grail was made up in the early 1190s at the behest of Philip of Flanders, whose biography we needn't trace here, nor his relationship with Henry, Count of Champagne and the so-called "courts of love" there.

Suffice it to say, no mention of a Grail could have existed before the 1190s. Zip, zero, nada. Got it? Good. Believe me, I know this stuff.

"Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade" is full of nonsense, but it's enjoyable. Catacombs in Venice, a city built on a marsh? Why not? But its history, particularly its Grail history, is rubbish.

This two-part "MacGyver" episode is not only rubbish; it's eggregious rubbish, invented by the writers out of sheer ignorance to cash in on something popular about which they knew nothing.

The word Grail did not exist before the 1190s so ipso facto it could not have been mentioned before then. Never. In any context. So what did Cretien de Troyes think it was? We'll never know. His manuscript is unfinished, either because he thought the subject too godawful silly (which it is) or because he died. We don't know that, either.

So if a genuine professor, bragging about her promotion, is allegedly an expert in 12th century history and myth (which I am, btw), you may assume she's lying or totally deluded and, btw, don't send your kids to that college because the history profs are whack jobs.

But once she stops spewing her eggregious baloney the actual adventure, silly though it is, is kind of infectious. Let's face it, the woman who starts MacGyver on this quest strikes one who really knows this stuff as about as dishonest as Jack Dalton. Getting MacGuyver stirred up by a pack of lies and threats so they may loot cultural artifacts.

Again, btw, the 12th century was not the big one for alchemists and their track record was not good. Her "Ambrose" (the name borrowed from the much earlier mentor of St. Augustin of Hippo) seems to be based more on the overrated Roger Bacon (of a later century). Nothing the professor says touches base with the truth at any point. She's a left-wing nut job and a raging bigot. She's the sort who, given her way, would hammer up concentration camps for the elimination of those who disagree with her. But she looks a lot like a woman I dated in the early 1990s so I like her. Too, like the Grail she's fictional.

I binge on MacGyver every so often. It's a good show, though MacGyver is a bit of a hypocrite. He won't carry a gun to shoot back at villains, endangering the lives of hostages, but he'll beat the bad guys (and even the innocent, if rhey stand in his way, unmercifully with his sledge-hammer fists or hell jerry-rig some Rube Goldberg device to fall on their heads and cause brain damage. Frankly, I'd rather be shot. And killed. The two do not necessarily go together.

So don't expect a history lesson or anything worthwhile from this episode. The Professor is after a McGuffin and by lies and tricks forces MacGyver to aid her silly quest that's more Monty Python than Indiana Jones. It's just disappointing that the writers, who never seem to stint on physics or chemistry (so far as I know) are so vapid on history or Grail literature they foist this stupidity on us. What a bunch of (as Bugs Bunny puts it) "maroons." Shame. The fools could have written better.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
MacGyver and the Next Crusade
justinboggan17 March 2014
SPOILERS

On the heels of the third Indiana Jones film about finding Holy Grail (indded, the film is briefly referenced by MacGyver), yet another TV series decided to cash in on the success. But where The Last Crusade succeeded, this failed.

Similarly to the major film, MacGyver finds himself on a hunt for the lost Holy Grail.

We are introduced to an "old friend" of his, Zoe Ryan, a short-haired liberal moron who's more than high on life, she's confused by it. Zoe serves as nothing more than a stand-in female version of Jack Dalton (since the actor sort is disappears this season and only shows up less than a handful more times before the end of the series' run), only sans the common sense and and humor. Indeed, after this two-parter, she's never seen again. What a shocker, I know.

Henry Jones, Jr. faced a real life situation of the National Socialist Party (the Nazi's) looking for artifacts such as the Holy Grail, with a real struggle for the right thing. In this half-bailed MacEpisode, we have some lib' professor who just has feel-good, uninformed, truly idiotic ideas of about real life and history (the last one surprising, since she's supposed to be an archaeologist) that drive her to find the Grail. And replacing the National Socialist Party we have some nondescript bad guys; maybe they're German, who knows (perhaps the second parter reveals this). And replacing Indy, we have MacGyver, in filing a role that just wasn't meant for his character.

Remember that annoying little boy in the second Indy film? Well, now imagine he's older. A woman. Has red hair. And is liberal moron. Okay, now you're got your annoying character for this romp! Compelte with the little boy haircut.

This idiot, we are lead to believe, not only finds a priceless artifact, but some how she alone finally deciphers the old clues. No, not the Nazi's; no, not the Vatican; no, not treasure hunters world wide; no, not archaeologist for centuries before her, she alone is some how smart enough.

At least Dalton, while easily mislead by easy money and short-cuts to wealth, had brains and good sense. Here, not so much.

Some acts later and we are left with the utterly predictable capture by the bad guys after finding a clue. MacGyver finds himself in torture device, slowly leading up to his death, ending this first parter. You expect to start hearing Nelson Riddle's "Batman" scoring, William Dozer's voice-over, and yellow text on screen, saying something along the lines of: "Oh no! Our hero in peril?! The bad guys are prevailing? That pendulum is getting lower and lower! Will our hero become MacHalfed? Will the bad guys get the Holy Grail? The worst is yet to come! Tune in next week -- same Mac-time, same Mac-channel!" And I'm sure after this set up, the worst IS yet to come. Ever since season three, some more in-your-face Leftist crap has been shoved into some MacGyver episodes. They sort of died out late season four and I was looking forward to never hearing them again, but it's back. The writer of this episode would later go on to write the blasphemous "Young MacGyver" failed pilot, about a relative who joins the Phoenix Foundation (one which in this series, MacGyver said he didn't have); do yourself a favor and don't watch that. If you thought the "Hunter" re-vival series was bad, oh boy! The plot is nothing special here, the writing is pretty standard fair, and the friendship between the sudden Zoe MacGuffin character, just isn't there. If you are a completest and want to see every episode, then have at it, but if you want to skip filler crap, this is filler crap. At least we get some good cues by composer Dennis McCarthy in here.
6 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed