Ashad Ka Ek Din (1971) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Futility of Unrequited Love
had-1714620 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Mani Kaul had an astounding understanding of women, and men who love them. Aashad Ka Ek Din(1971), based on the play by Mohan Rakesh of the same name is the prime example of this dynamics. Although Mani Kaul's 'Dwividha' (1973) is his most celebrated film, and has been remade as 'Paheli 'by Amol Palekar in 2005 starring Shahrukh Khan, 'Ashad Ka Ek Din'(1971) remains his esoteric masterpiece. Mani Kaul's Kalidas is a misanthrope and emotionally distant character who has a profound love for Mallika. He takes refuge in the nature devoid of any human connection only to be found by a wounded fawn; whom he brings to Mallika because he knows that she understands him. His irony is he fails to understand her as a woman . We have all read about Kalidas as this literary genius who is God gifted , Mani Kaul has achieved to cement Kalidas beyond his works as a man of flesh and blood in our imagination. Ambika warns her daughter Mallika of the inevitable consequences of her unadulterated love for Kalidas. She could not fathom the notion of her own daughter making herself worn out for another man's capricious pursuit. What Ambika fails to understand that Mallika is the very force of nature who propels every stroke of creation of Kalidas. Mallika loves Kalidas with her whole heart; even though her spirit withers with his subsequent creation. When representatives from kingdom of Ujjain came to honour Kalidas , he refuses to go with them as he felt no honour is above his body of work, which is beautifully emphasized by Mallika to the foster Uncle of Kalidas , who was upset because of the denial of Kalidas. Mallika's persuasion of Kalidas going to Ujjain speaks volumes of her altruistic love for Kalidas . Kalidas returns to his roots some years later , but as Matrugupt . His capricious mind could not gather courage to face Mallika , hence sends his wife who is a princess of the Ujjain Kingdom to her . She promises Mallika riches, rehabilitation of the house and the prospect of marriage to one of her chaperone to which Ambika seems enthusiastic ; Mallika refuses all offers with grace . For her they are nothing but outlandish display of status, which can never compensate her longing for Kalidas. ' Aashad Ka Ek Din' is a textbook of Staging. Contemporary filmmakers of Small and Big Screen take numerous POV shots of the actors to create Mise en scene . One can create Mise en scene without focusing on the actors face every time he/she tells a dialogue. 'Aashad Ka Ek Din' is a testament to that. A scene among Kalidas , Mallika and Arya Bilom is a perfect example of how to stage actors to heighten dramatic need. The whole movie is shot in one room, but it never feels claustrophobic. That is the power of cinema. After several years, Kalidas meets Mallika, discerning the capacity of bureaucracy to rot creativity, only to realise Mallika has created her masterpiece with the torments of her longing for him. Although she never stopped longing for him; she has embraced life in different dimensions. Kalidas in the penultimate scene says to Mallika "Time is the most powerful, because it waits for none." Has Mallika moved on with her life while Kalidas was busy craving her in his creation?

A Review by Amattasiri Jena
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A forgotten masterpiece about the angst of unfulfilled affection between an artist and his muse
Ansango21 March 2023
AASHADH KA EK DIN is the ultimate expression of longing and unrequited love. With the help of the characters of Mallika and Kalidas, the film beautifully explores the various facets of emotion, passion, yearning and devotion associated with love. Mani Kaul also brings attention to the themes of loss, change, sacrifice, societal anxiety, and the complex relationship between an artist and his muse. The visuals are gorgeous and the lighting is impeccable. The acting suits the tone of the film perfectly and Rekha Sabnis is ethereal. The sound dubbing isn't always the best and some dialogues sound too stiffly delivered to leave their mark(primarily because it was written for the stage). The acting isn't always great either and the pace is slow. But despite all these minor issues, the emotional core of the film is never lost. The last scene where Kalidas leaves everything and returns to Mallika and tells her that she always was the inspiration behind all of his works and expresses his love for her was the standout scene for me(although the film is filled with such great scenes).

It's a deeply emotional film and a great one at that. The plot is not the primary focus here but isn't abandoned either. It's a forgotten masterpiece from the annals of Hindi Cinema that deserves more attention and praise.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
So very poetic.
anoopfrm14 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
A great film. Beautiful screenplay. A sample:

Arya Vilom (a jealous acquaintance, who himself is trying to be a poet, and a self proclaimed 'friend' of Kalidasa) in the presence of Mallika (Kalidasa's lover) to Kalidasa who is about to leave his village to become the royal poet: "You can definitely be proud of your knowledge today. Heard you have received an invitation from the capital"

Kalidas: "Yes. Are you sad to hear that?"

Vilom: "Sad? Of course. Sad that I am being separated from a good friend...it is good that both of us understand each other so well...What's Vilom? An unsuccessful Kalidasa. And Kalidasa? A successful Vilom. We are very close in that sense"

Kalidasa: "Undoubtedly"

Several years passed. Kalidasa couldn't enjoy the palace life. He renounced everything and returned to his village, only to see that Mallika has given birth to Vilom's child!

A drunk Vilom: "Do you think your rights are permanent? As if there is no life beyond you. It's only you and no one else. But time isn't heartless. It has given power to others as well. It has given rights..."

Later, Kalidasa in a sad tone (to Mallika who hinted at a fresh start after the drunk Vilom left the scene): "Possibly it was the conflict of desires with time. But I can see that time is more powerful. Because..."

Mallika: "Because?"

Kalidasa: : "Because it doesn't wait"

With Lishin Anoop.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed