Hill-Tillies (1936) User Reviews

Poor

[boblipton · 4/10 · 3 March 2021]

To get fame through publicity, and thereafter a job, Patsy Kelly and Lyda Roberti decide to pretend to g into the woods to live rough for a while. The place turns out to be as busy as Grand Central Station.

Hal Roach was getting ready to shut down production of shorts, but he still owed some GIRL FRIENDS on his contract. With Thelma Todd dea,d he cast Lyda Roberti as a dumb blonde. Unhappily, there's no sense of character beyond that.

With Toby Wing and Jim Thorpe -- yes, that Jim Thorpe.

About what I expected...it was completely awful!

[planktonrules · 1/10 · 3 February 2011]

Among the worst shorts that the Hal Roach Studio produced were the Thelma Todd/Zasu Pitts films. They made quite a few but they just weren't particularly funny. Zasu's shtick was sounding like Olive Oyl with adenoids and eventually they decided to replace her with the loud and abrasive Patsy Kelly. This really wasn't much of an improvement and the series limped along. However, oddly, after the suspicious death of Thelma Todd, the brilliant minds at Roach decided to keep the series going by substituting the Polish actress Lyda Roberti in Todd's place--a very bizarre decision in hindsight. Why pick Roberti other than the fact that she, too, was a blonde?! With her heavy accent and lack of screen presence or talent, the series limped along...barely...until Roberti's very premature death.

Lyda and Patsy (and their friend--who just disappeared from the film after the initial scene and returns at the very end) are looking for a job without any success. So, as a publicity stunt, they move into the forest to live off the land 'Tarzan style'. There the ladies encounter American-Indians and a crazy man--none of which is the least bit funny. In fact, I have seen films of dental extractions that are funnier! Dreadful and incredibly bad chemistry--with Patsy playing a loud-mouth no-talent and Lyda playing a dumb lady who had 8 minutes of English lessons!

Wanna see a sample of how bad this film is? How about this wonderful dialog:

Indian #1: "How"

Indian #2: "How"

Lyda: "I'm fine, thanks!"

By the way, the big American Indian was played by the world-famous athlete, Jim Thorpe. It's sad to see the man reduced to playing stereotypical parts in crap films like this after his amazing performance in the Olympics a couple decades earlier.

A Real Hillbilly Could Have Done Better

[Michael_Elliott · 19 January 2011]

Hill-Tillies (1936)

* (out of 4)

The second of two films Patsy Kelly made with Lyda Roberti after the death of her original partner Thelma Todd. In the film the girls are having a rough time finding a job so they decide to come up with a publicity stunt where they go into the woods for ten days without any supplies. Is HILL-TILLIES worth seeing? Only if you want to see if it's worse than the duo's previous film AT SEA ASHORE. It's rather amazing to see how incredibly bad both movies were but if someone held a gun to my head and I was forced to watch one of them again I guess this here was the better of the two. This is mainly do to a skit towards the end of the film where the girl's run into a wild man who has apparently been living in the woods for years and has several imaginary horses. This brief scene gives us a quick laugh and it's pretty much the only reason to see this thing, although hero Jim Thorpe appears briefly here. The rest of the film is one bad joke after another and it's easy to see why this was the final short for Kelly and Roberti. They simply don't have a bit of chemistry but I don't blame them or the studio too much considering they were simply testing the waters trying to come up with a new team. The film is beyond bad as it doesn't contain a single thing that works for it.