I read this movie was not a big hit when released but I am glad it has endured! It took awhile to actually see it. I knew I would love it! It was recently seen on Ok.ru. Delightful site for many old films even TCM doesn't show! I recently found the DVD as well and enjoy it! For a long time it was not available and still not easy to find.
This is strictly a fantasy film so don't overthink it! What makes it so good is the FUN cast. Margaret O'Brien trying to soften up three old bachelor croons who are very cute in their respective roles. Lionel Barrymore, Lewis Stone, and Edward Arnold. I especially enjoy the interaction between Margaret and Lionel Barrymore. The two were apparently very close in real life from what I've read.. She was his favorite child actress. You can tell his fondness for her. In real life he lost two daughters in infancy and never had any other children and no chance for grandchildren. In several films he showed his soft spot for little girls. It is so touching. And Margaret referred to him as the Grandpa she never had. She also did an episode with him on the Dr. Gillespie series. She was so adorable!
Also great supporting cast of Thomas Mitchell, Harry Davenport, and Jane Darwell gives an impressive appearance as a nun. Fun stuff!
This is strictly a fantasy film so don't overthink it! What makes it so good is the FUN cast. Margaret O'Brien trying to soften up three old bachelor croons who are very cute in their respective roles. Lionel Barrymore, Lewis Stone, and Edward Arnold. I especially enjoy the interaction between Margaret and Lionel Barrymore. The two were apparently very close in real life from what I've read.. She was his favorite child actress. You can tell his fondness for her. In real life he lost two daughters in infancy and never had any other children and no chance for grandchildren. In several films he showed his soft spot for little girls. It is so touching. And Margaret referred to him as the Grandpa she never had. She also did an episode with him on the Dr. Gillespie series. She was so adorable!
Also great supporting cast of Thomas Mitchell, Harry Davenport, and Jane Darwell gives an impressive appearance as a nun. Fun stuff!