I get that this is definitely higher quality than most fan films, and also has better acting and is pretty well-choreographed, but it's still not great. A lot of people are rating it 10s, and it has a rating of 7.7, which is the same rating of certain excellent movies, and higher than some of the actual Star Wars movies. So, even though it's an impressive short film to be made and funded purely by fans, it still is just "ok," and certainly doesn't meet the standards of actual Star Wars movies, except The Rise Of Skywalker, which I will gladly admit is definitely worse than this fan film.