"The film starts off about a women with a delusional dying neighbour but with over an hour ago we find out the past of this neighbour when she lived in Africa, this second half of the film is what takes down it's grade a bit"
This film seems to be inspired by many films of the past which I will mention later but this film is one of those that will have mixed reactions I believe. The film is split into two parts and part one called Paradise Lost where we met Pilar (Teresa Madruga) a retired women living in Lisbon. Her neighbour Aurora (Laura Soveral) seems to believe in many strange things believing that Pilar is her best friend and must help her before she eventually dies. Once Aurora dies at the funeral Pilar starts to talk to a strange man named Ventura (Henrique Espírito Santo) who knew Aurora when they lived next door to each other in Africa. The second part then starts and it is called Paradise telling the story of Aurora (Ana Moreira) and Ventura (Carloto Cotta) when they were younger including a forbidden love shared between the two but also how that messed up their lives.
The film is shot entirely in black and white but also all the dialogue is Portuguese. I believe that the first part of the film works better because of awkward some of the scenes feel but also of how Aurora, Pilar and Santa are involved in the story. The second part of the film does not work as well for me because of many scenes were there is no sound even if we do see the actors speaking, the only words in this part is a voice-over provided by Henrique Espírito Santo as he explains the story being told on screen. The choice to use black and white I thought was a good choice especially for the second part as it was a flashback we watched and looked like it was filmed on old style film. The story did get confusing for me at times but I couldn't take my eyes off some of the images especially in the second half of the film.
The performances are more needed in the first part of the film because they actually get to speak dialogue. Teresa Madruga playing Pilar is fine but her performance is more of reactionary one as she observes events that are happening around her. Laura Soveral playing the older Aurora in her limited screen time gives the best performance in the film. She just knew how to play this character's descent into madness very well which is why the film is all about her character in the past and in present time.
The film does have it's great moments but because of the failings of the second half to set up as much an interesting story as the first the film. The film does well at surprising me because most of what happens in the film I was not expecting to happen.
MOVIE GRADE: B (MVP: Laura Soveral)
This film seems to be inspired by many films of the past which I will mention later but this film is one of those that will have mixed reactions I believe. The film is split into two parts and part one called Paradise Lost where we met Pilar (Teresa Madruga) a retired women living in Lisbon. Her neighbour Aurora (Laura Soveral) seems to believe in many strange things believing that Pilar is her best friend and must help her before she eventually dies. Once Aurora dies at the funeral Pilar starts to talk to a strange man named Ventura (Henrique Espírito Santo) who knew Aurora when they lived next door to each other in Africa. The second part then starts and it is called Paradise telling the story of Aurora (Ana Moreira) and Ventura (Carloto Cotta) when they were younger including a forbidden love shared between the two but also how that messed up their lives.
The film is shot entirely in black and white but also all the dialogue is Portuguese. I believe that the first part of the film works better because of awkward some of the scenes feel but also of how Aurora, Pilar and Santa are involved in the story. The second part of the film does not work as well for me because of many scenes were there is no sound even if we do see the actors speaking, the only words in this part is a voice-over provided by Henrique Espírito Santo as he explains the story being told on screen. The choice to use black and white I thought was a good choice especially for the second part as it was a flashback we watched and looked like it was filmed on old style film. The story did get confusing for me at times but I couldn't take my eyes off some of the images especially in the second half of the film.
The performances are more needed in the first part of the film because they actually get to speak dialogue. Teresa Madruga playing Pilar is fine but her performance is more of reactionary one as she observes events that are happening around her. Laura Soveral playing the older Aurora in her limited screen time gives the best performance in the film. She just knew how to play this character's descent into madness very well which is why the film is all about her character in the past and in present time.
The film does have it's great moments but because of the failings of the second half to set up as much an interesting story as the first the film. The film does well at surprising me because most of what happens in the film I was not expecting to happen.
MOVIE GRADE: B (MVP: Laura Soveral)