The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Gift: Part One (2009)
Season 3, Episode 11
6/10
Some Nice Symbolism and a Big Plot Hole
21 January 2011
Warning: Spoilers
THE SARAH JANE ADVENTURES is a good spin-off from the BBC Wales version of DOCTOR WHO, in which Sarah Jane Smith, an old traveling companion of the Doctor, battles various alien threats to Earth with her adopted son Luke, two of his friends, an alien super-computer and K-9, a robot dog from the 6th Millennium. It is pitched for younger children, and typically contains a goodly amount of thrills, moral lessons, and aliens.

In this one, aliens from the planet Raxacoricofallapatorius, who have previously appeared in the 2005 season of DOCTOR WHO, trick Sarah Jane into accepting Raxweed, which they say can feed the planet. However, it soon becomes clear that this is a virulently invasive species which will, like kudzu in the American Southeast, take over the planet, unless Sarah and her teenage assistants can stop it. The story is told with the series' usual good humor, action and production values. Happily for fans of the serial form like me, all the stories of Season Three are written as two-parters, which permits cliffhangers. In addition, some important issues are handled symbolically -- something which fantasy and science fiction do very nicely: the question of whom to trust, the dangers of introducing new species into a a local ecology -- just like kudzu, as mentioned above -- and the dangerous allure of fame.

Unfortunately, there is a big plot hole: since the Raxweed spreads itself rapidly via spores -- fast enough to cover all of greater London in three days and the entire planet, presumably, in a few weeks, why did the aliens need to involve Sarah Jane at all? Why not just drop it in an out-of-the-way spot and let it conquer the Earth before anyone noticed? Well, I suppose the production team figured that its target audience would not notice.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed