MGM's "Hollywood Revue" often comes off like an elaborate amateur "Talent Show" from an otherwise uninvolved in show business group of people. It could be any school, or workplace. Everyone gets a role, and a few people stand out. The early appearance by Joan Crawford sets the tone. She is clearly not at her best, performing a song and dance; but, she is enthusiastic. So, the company's workforce goes through their assigned tasks, for better or worse. As a variety show, the movie is sometimes good; but, the brighter spots can't justify its length. It's also a chance to see some big name "stars" in a disappointing light.
Without a doubt, the three MGM stars shining brightest are the non-appearing Greta Garbo, Lon Chaney, and Ramon Novarro. Mr. Navarro would have appeared; but, he was abroad, with his family. Of those appearing, Conrad Nagel and Jack Benny (his debut) do well hosting. Mr. Nagel is especially good, singing "You Were Meant for Me" (to Anita Page) well enough to have pursued a singing career. Nagel and Bessie Love were already "sound" investments for MGM. The middle rendition of "Singin' in the Rain" (the black and white one) is nice looking; and, it's a terrific song.
Plans to make the "Hollywood Revue" an annual embarrassment were canceled.
***** The Hollywood Revue of 1929 (8/14/29) Charles Reisner ~ Jack Benny, Conrad Nagel, John Gilbert
Without a doubt, the three MGM stars shining brightest are the non-appearing Greta Garbo, Lon Chaney, and Ramon Novarro. Mr. Navarro would have appeared; but, he was abroad, with his family. Of those appearing, Conrad Nagel and Jack Benny (his debut) do well hosting. Mr. Nagel is especially good, singing "You Were Meant for Me" (to Anita Page) well enough to have pursued a singing career. Nagel and Bessie Love were already "sound" investments for MGM. The middle rendition of "Singin' in the Rain" (the black and white one) is nice looking; and, it's a terrific song.
Plans to make the "Hollywood Revue" an annual embarrassment were canceled.
***** The Hollywood Revue of 1929 (8/14/29) Charles Reisner ~ Jack Benny, Conrad Nagel, John Gilbert