while i was watching this movie, in the start sequences i never realized that the movie was going to lead up to such an insensible and false stuff. cant believe it, Muslim's themselves r creating fun about them, and also delivering a false message about Islam.
i am not here for any arguments and neither do i give a damn about whatever people r gonna comment on my opinion but i would just like to make one thing very clear to other and non- Muslims that, in no way does Islam permits a Muslim girl to get married outside her religion. thought it differs for men (as they are allowed to marry Christians and Jews). their r many genuine hadith's on this issue and specially the one which Mr. Naseeruddin Shah presented in the movie (regarding Muslim girl marrying outside her religion) didn't make sense at all on this matter as it did only clear out that a girl should be asked and her permission should be seeked before deciding her marriage. and yeah, as about the music issue in which he said that music is allowed because "Daud, Alaihis salaam"(David) was gifted with a beautiful and sweetest voice by Allah and when he sang all the birds and mountain started to praise the Almighty along with him. well i agree with him, but the point here is that "David" was gifted with a sweet voice, not MUSIC! of course Islam doesn't prohibit singing for men, like nasheed etc. but the thing Islam prohibits is Music.
as i also did say earlier that i am not here to rate this movie on a commercial basis, but the message what this movie was trying to pass was intolerable . though up to a certain limit i also do agree what was shown in the first half regarding the hypocrite mullah's and tableeghi's but this doesn't prove that the opposite of this is right!
anyhow, i hope people don't take my opinion in any wrong way instead of thinking over it and preventing themselves in falling into evil.
and just for a matter of point, i don't think that Mr. Naseeruddin Shah deserves any religious appreciation or does he suits to talk on any thing related to Islam or specially marriage, as he himself has a non-Muslim(Hindu) wife, which is prohibited according to Islamic Shariah.
i am not here for any arguments and neither do i give a damn about whatever people r gonna comment on my opinion but i would just like to make one thing very clear to other and non- Muslims that, in no way does Islam permits a Muslim girl to get married outside her religion. thought it differs for men (as they are allowed to marry Christians and Jews). their r many genuine hadith's on this issue and specially the one which Mr. Naseeruddin Shah presented in the movie (regarding Muslim girl marrying outside her religion) didn't make sense at all on this matter as it did only clear out that a girl should be asked and her permission should be seeked before deciding her marriage. and yeah, as about the music issue in which he said that music is allowed because "Daud, Alaihis salaam"(David) was gifted with a beautiful and sweetest voice by Allah and when he sang all the birds and mountain started to praise the Almighty along with him. well i agree with him, but the point here is that "David" was gifted with a sweet voice, not MUSIC! of course Islam doesn't prohibit singing for men, like nasheed etc. but the thing Islam prohibits is Music.
as i also did say earlier that i am not here to rate this movie on a commercial basis, but the message what this movie was trying to pass was intolerable . though up to a certain limit i also do agree what was shown in the first half regarding the hypocrite mullah's and tableeghi's but this doesn't prove that the opposite of this is right!
anyhow, i hope people don't take my opinion in any wrong way instead of thinking over it and preventing themselves in falling into evil.
and just for a matter of point, i don't think that Mr. Naseeruddin Shah deserves any religious appreciation or does he suits to talk on any thing related to Islam or specially marriage, as he himself has a non-Muslim(Hindu) wife, which is prohibited according to Islamic Shariah.