Review of Simon

Simon (2004)
7/10
Is this film Dutch incarnation of Les Invasions Barbares?
6 May 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This film reminded me strongly of Les Invasions Barbares by Denys Arcand (Canada, 2003), & it makes feel a bit suspicious: is it coincidence or did Terstall borrow thoroughly from Arcand? The similarities are plenty, down to the details.The two films basically tell the same story: the main character, with his outspoken & sympathetic personality, is suffering from a terrible decease & is preparing to say sayonara to the world. His friends, (ex-)lovers & family are gathered around his sick bed, living up to the day & hour of his final departure. For people who liked the film Simon, Les Invasions Barbares may be interesting, if only for comparison. It shows a different way, rather more subtle, of dealing with this material. I do believe Arcand provides better & funnier dialogues & the film leads up to a climax in a more balanced way. If emotional impact of a film is the most important criteria, Simon deserves high ratings: we see how a wonderful person has the courage to step out & we sympathise with him. In terms of the film as a whole & originality, it is currently overrated at 8.4.
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed