Héctor Babenco is a great director, but I grew bored with Carandiru. It's overlong (2 hours 20 minutes; should have been 50 minutes shorter). And it's largely a parade of prison-movie clichés. You have the tough but fair prison director, Senhor Pires; prisoners divided into saints and scoundrels (the latter, naturally, meet all sorts of gory fates); the inevitable riot; the murderous response of the riot squad, etc. And it's told through the eyes of a doctor whose character lacks depth, and whose connection to the plot is tangential. Save it for free viewing on the Independent Film Channel. If you want to see better gritty, downbeat Brazilian films, I recommend Ônibus 174 (Bus 174) or Central do Brasil (Central Station) instead.
