This film is *very* basic stuff; the dream/time-travel theme, the typical war-drama clichés, etc. The whole film is just so bland and and the way it handles the serious subject... I don't know, it's just like a... Schindler's List Light; you get the important subject and a few well-known actors, but without any shred of anything else worth watching a movie for. The plot is lame, just a rehash of the dream/time-travel formula, in which the main character travels through time because he/she must learn an important lesson(like, say, Christmas is important, caring is important, and in this one, the Holocaust was and is important; bear in mind, I'm not saying it's untrue... I'm merely saying that it's an overly tongue in cheek way of telling us that), and wanders about, constantly talking about things that don't exist in that time period, instead of wising up and keeping her mouth shut; how many of these movies have been made, anyway? They should have stopped making them back in whatever decade they started. It's too bad the important subject has to be dumbed down to a childish "adventure" just to make teens and kids aware of what went on during the Holocaust(which the film arguably does a somewhat half-bad job of, since it's made into a PG-movie). Come on, I'd have rather sat through an informational but dull retelling of the story, instead of sitting through this tripe. The plot is tame and cliché-ridden, badly paced and not very interesting. Once again, too bad for a film with such an important a subject. The acting is decent at best; not surprising for a TV-movie cast, but come on... Brittany Murphy and Kirsten Dunst can do better than this. They may not be the best teen actresses out there, but they're better than this. The characters are mostly clichés and stereotypes. The cinematography is unimaginative. One of the biggest problems apart from everything I've written up to this point was that it focused very much on the Jewish religion and their customs, which seem strange and ridiculous, at least to me. That made them all the more unappealing to me, along with their one-dimensional personalities and poorly written and even more poorly delivered dialog. But, maybe I'm just too anti-religious and atheistic. Meh. My point is; you don't really care about these people, since their personalities are paper-thin and you know from the very moment they are introduced exactly what is going to happen to them, at least if you have any experience with the genre. Basically, the movie has a good point, but it's poorly presented and too much of the film is just poorly executed and ends up making you smirk or even laugh at what you're supposed to start crying at. I recommend this movie only to kids and other easily impressible people. I suppose if you *must* see every movie about the Holocaust, this isn't the worst either. You could do a lot worse, but you certainly could do a hell of a lot better, too. 5/10
Review of The Devil's Arithmetic
The Devil's Arithmetic
(1999 TV Movie)
The Holocaust For Dummies or: How I Learned to Pay Attention and Care About the Prosecution of Jews
19 September 2004