"American Experience" The Amish (TV Episode 2012) Poster

(TV Series)

(2012)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Sunday worship, Amish-style
take2docs9 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
What puritan religious community is comprised of members who don't vote or pledge allegiance, who shun excommunicates, and who consider themselves no part of the world? If you guessed Jehovah's Witnesses, you wouldn't be far off. Albeit, the correct answer in this particular context is the Amish (not to be confused with the Mennonites).

For anyone who has been living beneath a rock, the Amish are a highly conservative and relatively agrarian religious society, predominantly located in the Pennsylvania area within the U.S. They are known to worldlings for their being rather technophobic, apolitical, and horse-and-buggy.

I did not watch THE AMISH to be amused by cornfed ways. To the contrary. Although nonreligious myself, I took delight in viewing this documentary and in fact considered it a refreshing viewing experience. Most impressive to me is the way in which the Amish do not try and fit in with the mainstream and certainly not pop culture. Aside from their unworldliness, I also like the Amish for their familial nature, strong work ethic, modesty, and love of the land. So what if they're not into automobiles and are camera-shy. Commendable is their wholesome nonconformity. In this overall faithless age of ours, it's also pleasing to see a close-knit community that still believes in godly values and virtues. Call them old-fashioned, but these pastoral folks possess a number of admirable qualities which many moderns and secularists are sadly lacking in.

There are some things I learned from this doc which I'd either forgotten or hadn't known before: the Amish practice adult baptism; they don't have churches, but instead congregate for worship inside of homes; their communities attract numerous curiosity-seekers and sightseers; more and more young Amish men are finding work in factories as there is less opportunity for the Amish to support themselves by way of farming.

Although I personally enjoyed THE AMISH, I suspect it is a film for acquired tastes, that would likely not appeal to, say, jet-setters, culture-vultures, status seekers, fast-trackers, club-hoppers, aspirants, and the worldly wise. Those people with yet a sense of agrarian purity would likely appreciate this picture more than anyone else. THE AMISH requires patience and above-average attention spans on the part of its audience. It moves at a leisurely pace. If you've ever taken a relaxing drive through the country for no other reason than to experience a simple pleasure and to take in the rustic scenery, THE AMISH just might be your cup of tea.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Shot at Eden
Goingbegging21 December 2014
Whatever you may think of the Amish, they certainly make a good spectator sport - ironically, since they disapprove of photography because it breaks the second commandment (graven images).

But millions of American tourists flock to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, for a few hours of escapism, watching a frozen moment of German village life in 1520, to the sound of the pony-and-trap, overlaid with religious chants that have (presumably) remained unchanged all that time.

Those tourists are watching American individualism rejected in favour of family solidarity, community service and a distinctly arrogant belief that they alone shall be saved. Either the Amish themselves or the producers of this film have shied away from specifying what exactly is off the menu. At one point, we're told that it includes all 'man-made devices', yet those carriages and harnesses didn't manufacture themselves. And if they're really talking about an Eden of pure, unsullied nature, I would suggest that when man first tamed the horse, most people would have called it profoundly unnatural.

It is easy to sneer at the inconsistencies, and there is no doubt that many of the faithful do derive spiritual sustenance from these unchanging values. A big test was their reaction to an Amish school shooting that cost the lives of five small girls. Their immediate reaction was to forgive the killer (posthumously) in the presence of his family. One of them said "I was so grateful that I did not have to make a judgment on his soul. That was God's territory." He described the sensation as a 'wash of peace'.

Actually the Amish schools have earned a good deal of respect from outside, and public sentiment has discouraged the authorities from jailing parents for not sending their children to the local public schools. But it is at the school-leaving age that the awkward questions start to emerge, yet remain unanswered. The clip of a very innocent-looking teenage party on the lawn, with the genders apparently segregated, does not broach what we might discreetly call the glandular issue. And in any case, I can't help suspecting that cynical things may be going on behind the gleaming white raiment of holiness, as they have in so many other priesthoods.

An hour and fifty minutes gives us plenty of time to hear stories from long-term believers and a few dropouts, as well as neutral commentators from academia. One girl quit the Amish to marry and work outside, to the fury of her family, but the spell of the faith drew her back. The young men, predictably, sound unsure of their beliefs and work prospects. The film is interspersed with useful title-frames that deliver key facts about the Amish. Less effectively, it is divided-up into the four seasons, in a way that does not seem to be reflected in the subject-matter.

Perhaps after all, those tourists feel that they may be watching the last chapter of a noble history, as we now see young Amish men working in factories that are unmistakeably hi-tech, and families needing to look for cheaper land, on which to continue their traditional farming life, Colorado being apparently a firm favourite. Maybe the famous Pennsylvania Dutch dialect may soon be heard ringing across the thirsty prairies of the West - a long way from well-watered Lancaster County.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed