Calatorie la oras (2003) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Wit, Guts, Rhythm, Balance, Empathy
p_radulescu22 January 2011
This was the first movie of Romanian director Cristian Porumboiu, of nineteen minutes length. It was 2003. The guy made then in 2006 '12:08 East of Bucharest' which was great by all accounts. Then in 2009 'Police, Adjective' followed. I haven't seen it yet, it has very good reviews.

Coming back to 'A Trip to the City': it's a little gem. It is witty, it has guts, it has rhythm, it is perfectly balanced: it is making the case like a demonstration at the blackboard; nothing is missing, nothing is superfluous, the perfect demonstration. And above all, you feel the empathy the director has for these petty people with petty lives, the immense pleasure he has in discovering their humanity in anything they're saying or doing.

Two very good actors in the main roles: Ion Sapdaru (who has talent inside his skin as for a small regiment) and Constantin Dita (I saw him also in 'Portretul Luptatorului la Tinerete', where he managed a very difficult role).

I found 'A Trip to the City' on youTube, with English subtitles, only I can see how much it is lost in translation. But this was unavoidable. The same words have a very different emotional charge in the two languages. I noticed that when reading in English books by Pamuk or Pavić. I read them also in Romanian, to feel their flavor. I believe that the semantic correspondence operates perfectly only between languages spoken in neighboring countries (despite their different origins, like Romanian, Serbian, Turkish). Similar challenges throughout history led to similar mental constructions, to similar suggestions behind words.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Unspectacular and uninteresting Warning: Spoilers
"Calatorie la oras" or "A Trip to the City" is a Romanian 20-minute short film from almost 15 years ago and it came out when Romanian cinema had a bit of a resurgence that went on to a lesser extent until today. The writer and director here is Corneliu Porumboiu, but unfortunately I cannot agree with the awards bodies that honored him for his work here. I think the reason why I did not like this one as much is a combination of forgettable acting and a story that simply isn't good enough to have audiences glued to the screen, not even for 20 minute movie. Or maybe especially for a 20-minute movie as making a good short film is frequently at least as big a challenger as making a good feature film. You need focus right from the beginning to and flaws are even more difficult to excuse. I personally give it a thumbs down. Not recommended.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed