This is one of five biopics that William Dieterle made for producer Hal B. Wallis at Warner Bros in as many years and the third to star Paul Muni in the title role. Excellent production values suffice it to say. Tony Gaudio is behind the camera and there is a symphonic score by Korngold arranged and orchestrated by Hugo Freidhofer with an effective use of 'La Paloma'.
Film historian David Thompson has dismissed these biopics as being Germanic and stagey. He is fully entitled to his opinion of course but I think his verdict to be harsh especially when one considers the first class actors, both leading and supporting, who appeared in these films.
The characters that linger longest in the memory from this are those of Brian Aherne as Maximilian and Bette Davis as his wife Carlotta. Aherne has never been better quite frankly while Davis is absolutely stupendous in the role. Their scenes together are beautifully understated and the scene where she confronts the ignominious Louis Napoleon, played with relish by Claude Rains, is magnificent. Her descent into madness is subtly handled.
Interesting also to see as future president Diaz that human dynamo John Garfield whose greatest roles were still to come.
Paul Muni I must confess has never really been my cup of tea but that is only my opinion.
The 'execution' of monarchs understandably has always caused more emotional outrage and controversy than that of dictators.
In this film at any rate Juarez feels remorse but his refusal to grant Maximilian a pardon is certainly a blot on his historical reputation.
Excellent film by a European director who adapted to and thrived under the Hollywood system.
As an historical document it is certainly off-centre in many respects but as a piece of entertainment it certainly hits the mark.
Review of Juarez
