My empathy for Nadeem starts with him truly struggling to face his parents, but it ends there as well.
All we see in this documentary is Nadeem's superficial understanding of religion and lack of ability to dwelve into it. He is rightly kicked out of the monastery, for it was not his place. He did not ask the right questions nor could comprehend them, as all he knew was through the negative lens of what not to do.
Nadeem himself says he was made to read the Quran and didn't understand it. All he understood was to eat with his right hand and to pray. In the monastery, all he sees is the monks teaching how to properly eat. With Ryushin (the rebel monk), he sees him drink and asks whether he isn't actually prohibited from doing so.
This makes the Japan trip useless other than meeting Ryushin. I'd rather have seen Rushin's story fully, as his is more of a struggle in understanding and following proper scripture; Nadeem's is one of a hollow man wanting only for religion to stop messing with his life. Through this lens it makes him look rather narcissistic, but I only see him as an ignoramus.
All we see in this documentary is Nadeem's superficial understanding of religion and lack of ability to dwelve into it. He is rightly kicked out of the monastery, for it was not his place. He did not ask the right questions nor could comprehend them, as all he knew was through the negative lens of what not to do.
Nadeem himself says he was made to read the Quran and didn't understand it. All he understood was to eat with his right hand and to pray. In the monastery, all he sees is the monks teaching how to properly eat. With Ryushin (the rebel monk), he sees him drink and asks whether he isn't actually prohibited from doing so.
This makes the Japan trip useless other than meeting Ryushin. I'd rather have seen Rushin's story fully, as his is more of a struggle in understanding and following proper scripture; Nadeem's is one of a hollow man wanting only for religion to stop messing with his life. Through this lens it makes him look rather narcissistic, but I only see him as an ignoramus.
Tell Your Friends