This episode was a much better portrayal of everything that is going on in the show, and the pacing and scenes were overall competently executed.
I will note to the readers of this review, that I am typically the person who rates these episodes between 1-5, specifically from the last two seasons.
Of course being a mid season finale with 18 minutes longer than usual episodes, The focus of the episode was to advance the plot significantly. This episode showed every character and story that is currently occurring in the show, which probably has happened maybe afew times in the last 24 episodes (Season 6 and 7). Seeing that in itself was a much fuller viewer experience. I have grown used to watching an episode and feel as if nothing has happened. Tara's episode afew weeks ago is a perfect example of that. We learned almost nothing relevant to the main story, and we learned nothing about Tara, so there was really no material in it besides setting something up to happen in 4 months. Episodes that are going to advance the main plot AND touch base with many story lines are going to be needed in the next 8 episodes to really pull this show back together.
The character development of this episode felt like it was actually a forethought into making it. We had character development in some small and larger ways occurring, and the thing that stood out this episode is that it came from everyone. Some of the development stuff that happened seemed alittle crude. Michonne talking to herself about killing Negan with a Savior right beside her made me actually laugh. I don't care if she ending up killing the Savior, some thoughts are best kept to yourself depending on who is in the room. A small issue in all honesty, nothing compared to previous infractions that have happened in the show. I liked the advancements to the Kingdom story-line, especially since they complement what later occurred with the changing of Rick's thoughts. If that had occurred last episode somewhere in that giant garbage pile, it would have seemed off.
There were a lot of moments in the show that just made me hit my head and say "why do you keep doing this?" The scene with Aaron and Rick on the boat, going to the canoe to go the houseboat that isn't that much further... over complication of an easy task to fill airtime is something that has happened most frequently with this show. Then comes Aaron and the "surprise walkers". First comes the one in the canoe. That one made me note to myself how much time is wasted in this episode before Rick saves him, since we all know a Aaron isn't going to die from that encounter. Next Aaron gets pulled into the water, and the cycle continues as we just count down the clock before we can begin watching something worth watching. The show isn't called "Close Encounters With Zombies", so why does this happen every episode?? To make my point clearer, Rick and Aaron saw the zombies in the water and they continued on, to get past them. I'm going to assume they are logical people, and logical people don't do things that incur a good chance of them dying. So if they know that they very likely aren't going to die, why do we as the viewer have to suffer through this time and time again with pointless zombie encounters. Too often now are zombies the afterthought of the show. They probably make the script and with a wet paintbrush flick paint randomly onto the script and add a close encounter with a zombie at the paint splash. I was extremely excited when in season 6 the focus started out to be about combating the zombie problem, but that was the focus of maybe 4 episodes and completely gone in 8.
Another scene that made me hit my head was when we were picking who gets to die. And like most times in this show, its the 2nd class characters who got a disproportional amount of screen time in the last few episodes that die. When its time for a "main" character to die (Rosita), the mood changes to "I'm going to mess up your face". He killed Spencer for says Rick won't follow your rules, but when someone actually tries to kill Negan, he just wants to mess up your face alittle. And that point reminds me of the "au naturel" moment when Negan, picks up the shell casing... takes time to examine it... determines its hand made... And finally demands to know who made it. He got that entire plot stripped down to the bone in a matter of seconds. Its almost like he is Santa Claus knowing exactly who was implicated in being Naughty. Its too contrived to be believable or watchable. After that moment that scene went down the dumps. Spencer's death overall wasn't too bad. It made some tenseness, especially with Rick supporters watching him do what he was doing. A redeeming factor for that was Andrew Lincolns acting. He is definitely the best actor of all of them. (beets Carl by a long-shot!)
Honourable mentions go to Fat Joseph, who like many viewers of this show, are just trying to get by. (Another example of a 2nd class character with disproportional screen time die)
I hope my 6/10 is a good rating. I haven't seen an episode this good in a long long time, and even this episode had major flaws. I hope we have a solid plot driven focus in the second half of the season.
I will note to the readers of this review, that I am typically the person who rates these episodes between 1-5, specifically from the last two seasons.
Of course being a mid season finale with 18 minutes longer than usual episodes, The focus of the episode was to advance the plot significantly. This episode showed every character and story that is currently occurring in the show, which probably has happened maybe afew times in the last 24 episodes (Season 6 and 7). Seeing that in itself was a much fuller viewer experience. I have grown used to watching an episode and feel as if nothing has happened. Tara's episode afew weeks ago is a perfect example of that. We learned almost nothing relevant to the main story, and we learned nothing about Tara, so there was really no material in it besides setting something up to happen in 4 months. Episodes that are going to advance the main plot AND touch base with many story lines are going to be needed in the next 8 episodes to really pull this show back together.
The character development of this episode felt like it was actually a forethought into making it. We had character development in some small and larger ways occurring, and the thing that stood out this episode is that it came from everyone. Some of the development stuff that happened seemed alittle crude. Michonne talking to herself about killing Negan with a Savior right beside her made me actually laugh. I don't care if she ending up killing the Savior, some thoughts are best kept to yourself depending on who is in the room. A small issue in all honesty, nothing compared to previous infractions that have happened in the show. I liked the advancements to the Kingdom story-line, especially since they complement what later occurred with the changing of Rick's thoughts. If that had occurred last episode somewhere in that giant garbage pile, it would have seemed off.
There were a lot of moments in the show that just made me hit my head and say "why do you keep doing this?" The scene with Aaron and Rick on the boat, going to the canoe to go the houseboat that isn't that much further... over complication of an easy task to fill airtime is something that has happened most frequently with this show. Then comes Aaron and the "surprise walkers". First comes the one in the canoe. That one made me note to myself how much time is wasted in this episode before Rick saves him, since we all know a Aaron isn't going to die from that encounter. Next Aaron gets pulled into the water, and the cycle continues as we just count down the clock before we can begin watching something worth watching. The show isn't called "Close Encounters With Zombies", so why does this happen every episode?? To make my point clearer, Rick and Aaron saw the zombies in the water and they continued on, to get past them. I'm going to assume they are logical people, and logical people don't do things that incur a good chance of them dying. So if they know that they very likely aren't going to die, why do we as the viewer have to suffer through this time and time again with pointless zombie encounters. Too often now are zombies the afterthought of the show. They probably make the script and with a wet paintbrush flick paint randomly onto the script and add a close encounter with a zombie at the paint splash. I was extremely excited when in season 6 the focus started out to be about combating the zombie problem, but that was the focus of maybe 4 episodes and completely gone in 8.
Another scene that made me hit my head was when we were picking who gets to die. And like most times in this show, its the 2nd class characters who got a disproportional amount of screen time in the last few episodes that die. When its time for a "main" character to die (Rosita), the mood changes to "I'm going to mess up your face". He killed Spencer for says Rick won't follow your rules, but when someone actually tries to kill Negan, he just wants to mess up your face alittle. And that point reminds me of the "au naturel" moment when Negan, picks up the shell casing... takes time to examine it... determines its hand made... And finally demands to know who made it. He got that entire plot stripped down to the bone in a matter of seconds. Its almost like he is Santa Claus knowing exactly who was implicated in being Naughty. Its too contrived to be believable or watchable. After that moment that scene went down the dumps. Spencer's death overall wasn't too bad. It made some tenseness, especially with Rick supporters watching him do what he was doing. A redeeming factor for that was Andrew Lincolns acting. He is definitely the best actor of all of them. (beets Carl by a long-shot!)
Honourable mentions go to Fat Joseph, who like many viewers of this show, are just trying to get by. (Another example of a 2nd class character with disproportional screen time die)
I hope my 6/10 is a good rating. I haven't seen an episode this good in a long long time, and even this episode had major flaws. I hope we have a solid plot driven focus in the second half of the season.
Tell Your Friends