Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Three Monkeys (2008)
Nuri Bilge Ceylan: always different, always the same.
5 January 2009
There is something about Nuri Bilge Ceylan's films that have always set itself apart from other films on the international stage: its ability to resonate with an audience. Although set in Turkey his films' story lines have the ability to connect with an audience from any region while also being able to utilize a major city's inner-turmoil via its transmitting landscapes, exhaustive loneliness and its sheer beauty. And "Three Monkeys" is no exception.

The story is the most complex and inter-connected of Ceylan's career and because of this he opts to use actors with previous experience for the first time (outside of his actress wife in "Climates"). A series of hidden secrets and unfolding lies keeps the family distant and increasingly torn apart from each other until a breaking point brings them back full circle. The "best-laid-plans" aspect of the film gives it a tinge of film-noir as it uses this device to present the family in its wondrous failures.

Having seen each of Ceylan's previous works my first expectation before seeing this film was breathtaking cinematography (and it did not disappoint in the least). Seeing Ceylan present the wondrous rain clouds that burst and crash above the dusty traffic-filled streets of Istanbul throughout this film as well as many of his others never gets old. "Three Monkeys" itself starts with a beautiful presentation of a car riding hidden paths that circle inside a forest's midnight darkness before it disappears from sight completely perhaps evoking questions as to why anyone would need to make their way through such landscapes at such an hour but at the risk of being cliché: "c'est la vie".

The use of established actors provided some consolation for the audience who could believe and connect with three characters who slowly went about their lives of self-destruction and self-deception until all secrets and lies were laid out on the table for the whole family to bear. The father who went through great hardship for his family finds only heartbreak following his efforts, the guilt-ridden son who is haunted by the memory of a younger brother whose tragic death he feels responsible for and must now deal with the knowledge of a mother who has found the love and affection of another man who is simply using her. The wide array of camera angles and mixture of shots of varying range and clarity enables Ceylan to convey the feelings and thoughts of his characters while still allowing the audience to follow the foreshadowing plot.

The usual Ceylan trademarks resonate within "Three Monkeys" both technically and spiritually while also showing his audience that with each time-out and with each film he can take his stories and characters into a completely new direction while taking his audience along for the ride. The slow, motionless shots give the audience a silence that swells with his characters' feelings and showcases a family's ability to communicate without words. This film has the ability to simultaneously show an audience a beautiful city and its inhabitants while also revealing real-life characters who let their emotions go to the extreme due to jealousy, rage and lust which can be found within anyone in the world.

Note: At Cannes, Ceylan picked up the Best Director prize and the film was subsequently chosen by Turkey to be its nominee for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film.
28 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Capote (2005)
Excellent Exploration of the Similarities Between Seemingly Different People
27 February 2006
Besides the fact that Perry's diary entry for "if called upon to make a speech" for an achievement is almost identical to Marlon Brando's Oscar acceptance speech (Perry's speech from his diary as found in Capote's notes: "I can't remember what I was going to say for the life of me. I don't think ever before have so many people been so directly responsible for my being so very, very glad. It's a wonderful moment and a rare one. Thank you!"), and the reasoning that Perry could be trying to identify with celebrities and people of stance in those times, I think it is intriguing that Capote's notes written right before Perry's "achievement" dialogue are as follows: "If Called Upon to Make a Speech – This is exactly what I was talking about – a speech just in case he's ever recognized for an achievement".

This is exactly what Capote just repeated to Harper Lee. I don't think he would have written it as "This is exactly what I was talking about" if they were simply notes to himself. He had written the notes just as he would have said them to Harper, and in a way he was preparing himself for this "speech" over the phone, much like Perry was preparing for his own "achievement speech". I noted a stark similarity between the psyche of both Perry and Truman and how they often feel the need to stand out as being flawless amongst people due to their own personal anxiety and loneliness.

Either that or it was simply a tool used by the crew to help Philip Seymour Hoffman remember his lines.

P.S. I found this out by freeze-framing – Bennett Miller sent me a personal copy, and if you believe that I tell you another. P.S.S. Capote should win as many Oscars as it was nominated for.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed