Actually, to refer to this film as a "documentary" is too generous. There are already dozens of user comments on here that do a great job of nailing all the points on which this film fails. I just wanted to throw my fuel on the fire.
Throughout the film, images of Hitler and Nazis from World War II are shown to symbolize those who disagree with the Intelligent Design theory. For someone who, I assume, is trying present a thought- provoking argument in favor of Intelligent Design, it is atrocious that Ben Stein would feel the need to stoop to outrageous sensationalism and inflammatory references.
The film is also peppered with short, single-phrase sound bites from a variety of talking heads. These sound bites seem geared to showing the small-mindedness of those against Intelligent Design. But there is no context around these sound bites, and often the viewer is given no indication as to the identity of the speaker. Anyone can take a word or phrase out of context to suit their needs.
Bottom line, between the references to Nazi Germany and the chop-shop editing, this film isn't a discussion about the debate over Intelligent Design; it isn't a rational presentation of an argument for Intelligent Design; it is an immature rant by someone I had expected a whole lot more from.
Throughout the film, images of Hitler and Nazis from World War II are shown to symbolize those who disagree with the Intelligent Design theory. For someone who, I assume, is trying present a thought- provoking argument in favor of Intelligent Design, it is atrocious that Ben Stein would feel the need to stoop to outrageous sensationalism and inflammatory references.
The film is also peppered with short, single-phrase sound bites from a variety of talking heads. These sound bites seem geared to showing the small-mindedness of those against Intelligent Design. But there is no context around these sound bites, and often the viewer is given no indication as to the identity of the speaker. Anyone can take a word or phrase out of context to suit their needs.
Bottom line, between the references to Nazi Germany and the chop-shop editing, this film isn't a discussion about the debate over Intelligent Design; it isn't a rational presentation of an argument for Intelligent Design; it is an immature rant by someone I had expected a whole lot more from.
Tell Your Friends