Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Oceans (2008– )
Imperfect & flawed, with few moments of true magic.
13 April 2011
I have to concur with roguegrafix's review of this series completely. Well intentioned as it may have been, this series is severely flawed by the way it was presented.

The opening of each of the episodes points out that the Oceans cover two-thirds of the surface of the earth...unfortunately the series itself spends about four-fifth of its running time talking about the personnel involved in producing the series, not the oceans.

You are told about two dozen times about how meticulously experienced and intrepid a diver Paul Rose is; Mr. Cousteau Jr. is genuinely enthusiastic but the timing and number of his many mini-lectures gets tiresome very quickly. The countless shots of the perpetually worried diving safety director becomes an unintended on-going gag.

Do we really need to see Paul Rose jogging around in Messina or Lucie and Philippe baking bread in the sand? Surely Toony getting an emergency filling on board or throwing up on deck could have been consigned to the extras DVD.

All that being said the series is still worth watching for the handful of memorable scenes and some potentially meaningful scientific contributions the expedition may or may not have made. It's just too bad the production decisions took away so much from the magic of the oceans itself.

Interested viewers should seek out the 4-part series ONE OCEAN from CBC's Nature of Things, for a more compelling and moving depiction of the state of our modern Oceans. I believe it is still viewable on-line through CBC.ca.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Touching, Funny Film with a Nice Message
11 December 2004
Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen is about nothing, and yes, it is about everything. The familiar dilemma of juggling one's dreams with the realities of school, family and self-esteem is there - but it is first & foremost about friendship, portrayed in a wonderful, natural way by Alison Pill (Ella) and Lindsay Lohan (Lola/Marie). The friendship portrayed by these two lead actors are as real as any I've seen on screen. I especially look forward to seeing Alison Pill (Pieces of April) in more first-run movies.

The movie has a fine cast, and first-rate performances in the supporting roles - Glenne Headley as the single mother, is understated but a steady, anchoring presence in the entire movie. Megan Fox is the stylish school queen-bee whose role is much more complex than on first impression. Carol Kane is hilarious as the overwrought drama teacher.

Because the script is based on a popular novel, the movie rewards the viewer who listens carefully as it has densely humorous script. There are subtle lines and touches which can be missed. One example of the original nature of this movie is the way the budding 'romantic interest' of Lola is treated as a true subplot. This movie is about friendship, not romance.

The director, Sara Sugarman, deserves a lot of the credit for adapting the book to the screen with imagination and playful flourishes which reflect the mindset of the lead character and don't get in the way of the movie. The characters come across as real people, with real lives. There is an overall loving attention to detail in editing, production design and the several subplots all have meaning and contribute to each other without contrivance.

This is an accomplished movie with a nice message which succeeds at many different levels. While under-appreciated during its original theatrical run, I predict it will stand the test of time.
13 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed