Change Your Image
gingersnapper
Reviews
Wuthering Heights (1967)
It was a decent production.
Pretty faithful to the book except the actors as children were much too old as well as when they're adolescents. McShane is too short at 5 9' and the actor playing Edgar is taller and has a bigger frame. It's hard to picture Heathcliff being stronger and more threatening in the key thrown in the fire scene- which they changed. Cathy doesn't throw the key in the hottest part of the fire she just tosses it across the room. Also cut is the scene where Cathy chases after Heathcliffthe the night he runs off and she ends up very sick. Her first near death experience isn't depicted. Also Heathcliff runs off before Hareton is even born therefore he never catches him when he falls from Hindley's grasp at the top of the stairs. Scoular is one of the best Cathys I've seen. She's pretty enough and delivers her dialogue in a natural way which is hard to do with the way they talk in the book. She delivered her lines fast., how ppl naturally talk, not slow and melodramatic. I liked Anna Calder Marshall as Cathy but they didn't make her powerful or bratty enough. Timothy Dalton was the best Heathcliff in my opinion. I would say this version is worth watching. Too bad it's not in color.
I Am All Girls (2021)
Pretty Good
I liked the "getting even" aspect and the young girl getting tough and strong. The subject of ht really gets my blood boiling. How these men make a business of using women and children for men's' sexual gratification and to get rich...making ppl just a hole to put their dick in. Anyway 1 thing I thought was humorous is Jodie - the lead character -is the worst cop ever! She fux every situation up! She can't do anything right! Watch it you'll see what I mean. The other lead that plays Ntombi is really good tho. I'd say the movie is a B. It's in English mostly with some African language that includes subtitles. The two lead actresses are good, they do a good job. But the one character of Jodi is kind of a mess, like I said.
Wuthering Heights (1978)
Best Version Yet as of 2022
I just saw it yesterday and while watching it thought "this is the best adaptation I've seen", and I've seen all of them except foreign language films. It was sort of presented as a play, the characters' conversations weren't cut to bits. They actually included most of the dialogue in the book with a delivery that seemed natural, which I think would be hard to do. People don't talk like that in real life "He is my soul" "he's like the eternal rocks beneath" "I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!" Most of those deep, poetical emotions aren't conveyed like that, imo. But the actors delivered all those types of lines very smoothly, very naturally, when to me they've always seemed awkward. Anna Calder- Marshal's Cathy was pretty good, but she only says a little snippet of the entire declaration like "I don't just love Heathcliff, I am Heathcliff" The whole speech was cut to a few lines. Fiennes and Olivier I didn't buy as Heathcliff. One was too scrawny and the other too dopey. Plus the story was very much changed in Oliver's movie. I liked Dalton, but his lines were cut up too, plus he's really hot, too good-looking. This Heathcliff wasn't ugly but he wasn't too handsome that you'd want him just by looking at him. Oh and I got to say this Cathy and Heathcliff have brown eyes! Anna and Timothy have beautiful blue eyes, I hated that. All the other main characters were cast appropriately as well - Hindley (Julian Glover was too old and looked nothing like the kid who played him younger), Edgar (Ian Ogilvy was better though), Isabella, Hareton, daughter Cathy, and the delicate brat Linton., Bravo to all!
As for Anna's Cathy I've always liked it, but it was tamed down a bit to maybe make her more likeable? But I found her believable. I really hated Juliette Binoche as Cathy. Too French, too refined- I don't know who she was playing but it wasn't Catherine Earnshaw. Merle Oberon was lovely, but that movie wasn't even Wuthering Heights, just some Hollywood regurgitation of the novel.
Anyway if you're a fan of the story and have been disappointed by other films, check this 5 episode series out! It's pretty good and better than the rest!