As another endeavor from the Hollywood to create a movie out of an iconic, much loved and cherished Japanese animation / comic series with an enthusiastic, loyal fan base, Death note has bathed in skepticism and pessimism before it becomes available to the world. With the western setting and the emphasis from the production that the movie would be loosely based on the animation / comic series, it is bound to spark disapproval, especially among those who have enjoyed and loved the original. Fortunately, without having previously watched the original series, I consider myself a blank page that is good to go to enjoy the movie without the risk of bias. Unfortunately, Death Note turns out to be yet another proof of the skepticism surrounding Hollywood adaptations being absolutely correct.
The problem with these Hollywood adaptations is that, they cannot just simply pick up whichever pieces they find interesting and useful from the original, throwing away the rest of the complicated and difficult bundle, and call it a day. No. In order to produce a triumphant 'loosely based' adaptation, there must be some elements of originality added to create an exciting and refreshing take of the original story line. Death note is, however, anything but exciting and refreshing, leaving the audience frustrated by its lack of sincerity. The movie seems like a sloppy version which tries its hardest in avoiding any direction that requires originality or creativity.
But even if not judged as an adaptation but as a movie alone, Death Note has a fatal problem of not producing any, yes, ANY likable and colorful character. The movie never takes its time to introduce the characters, giving the audience only a few scarce pieces of information that make them struggle to feel any connection with them. The only character the audience can sympathize with, is perhaps Light Turner, the death-note-owning protagonist, as we learn his upsetting reasons for his strong desire for justice and his struggles between choosing the right and wrong as the story unfolds. However, the other characters in the movie are, if not unlikable, at least uninteresting and confusing. Even L, supposedly the mysterious, intriguing and extremely intelligent detective, falls as the victim of character underdevelopment and unconvincing dialogue, and loses his charm. Misa, as Light's girlfriend / partner in crime, is probably the number one unlikable character in the whole movie, as she swifts from the endearing sweetheart to the mindless and manipulative murderer caught in her obsession with maintaining the reputation and popularity of the Kira (the pseudo name Light uses to kill people using his death note).
After all, Death Note definitely fails to deliver an enjoyable and memorable adaptation of the acclaimed animation / comic series.
The problem with these Hollywood adaptations is that, they cannot just simply pick up whichever pieces they find interesting and useful from the original, throwing away the rest of the complicated and difficult bundle, and call it a day. No. In order to produce a triumphant 'loosely based' adaptation, there must be some elements of originality added to create an exciting and refreshing take of the original story line. Death note is, however, anything but exciting and refreshing, leaving the audience frustrated by its lack of sincerity. The movie seems like a sloppy version which tries its hardest in avoiding any direction that requires originality or creativity.
But even if not judged as an adaptation but as a movie alone, Death Note has a fatal problem of not producing any, yes, ANY likable and colorful character. The movie never takes its time to introduce the characters, giving the audience only a few scarce pieces of information that make them struggle to feel any connection with them. The only character the audience can sympathize with, is perhaps Light Turner, the death-note-owning protagonist, as we learn his upsetting reasons for his strong desire for justice and his struggles between choosing the right and wrong as the story unfolds. However, the other characters in the movie are, if not unlikable, at least uninteresting and confusing. Even L, supposedly the mysterious, intriguing and extremely intelligent detective, falls as the victim of character underdevelopment and unconvincing dialogue, and loses his charm. Misa, as Light's girlfriend / partner in crime, is probably the number one unlikable character in the whole movie, as she swifts from the endearing sweetheart to the mindless and manipulative murderer caught in her obsession with maintaining the reputation and popularity of the Kira (the pseudo name Light uses to kill people using his death note).
After all, Death Note definitely fails to deliver an enjoyable and memorable adaptation of the acclaimed animation / comic series.
Tell Your Friends