OK, lets look at this as a movie, not as something that morons are debating because they dislike Moore's politics. I seriously doubt half the negative reviewers even saw the film, but lets see what we have here.
First of all, its a joke that it won the golden palm as the best film at Cannes, unless of course "Kangaroo jack II" was the only film running against it. The movie is about 20 minutes too long, with certain sequences just playing themselves well beyond their usefulness. Also, so much of the film involves clips from shows like "Larry King" and others that you feel that you're watching something hastily edited.
I felt it could have gone two ways - either as a super-serious indictment of the War in Iraq, or as a document of the Bush administrations actions regarding the events of 9/11. Its tough to be both and doesn't succeed there. When Moore is TOO populist, he comes across as preachy. However, when he pulls brilliant stunts like reading the patriot act over an ice cream truck PA system, trying to get members of Congress to get their own children to sign up for the draft and the like, while cleverly editing together soundbites of Bush sounding cavalier, self-righteous and absurd at the same time - well, thats when the film truly hits the mark. I wish he would have gone after the media for their complacency after 9/11 - there's plenty of good stuff on that - but he only scratched the surface on it.
Overall, an important document and sign of the times. But not a perfect movie by any means.
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends