Having recently re-visited the original seventies Bionic Woman it was only logical to move on and have another look at the 2007 attempted re-boot. At the time this got absolutely slaughtered by the critics and fans of the original show alike. But it's not actually as bad as people would have you believe.
On a technical level it was far superior to the seventies show and clearly showed just how far technology and special effects had come on in the thirty years between the two shows.
Where it failed badly was that it completely failed to capture the humour or the warmth of the original show. None of this was Michelle Ryans fault. Michelle Ryans Jaime Sommers - a woman whose life was already difficult then thrown into a new set of circumstances beyond her comprehension in a world where she no longer knows who, if anybody, she can actually trust - is, in some ways, more believable than Lindsay Wagners Jaime Sommers was.
The problem was that the show was just too bloody dark. Completely joyless and humourless. Everyone was just too hard-bitten and dour and cynical. If you can't get your audience to feel any connection to feel any connection or empathy with the people in the show it's doomed. None of the characters are remotely sympathetic or likeable. Whether that would have changed if the show had been allowed to develop, I don't know. The difference for me was that everybody fell in love with Lindsay Wagners Jaime Sommers almost instantly, whereas Michelle Ryans Jaime Sommers was, at least at first, much harder to like as a character. More realistic maybe in some ways (there must have been some sort of post-bionic my whole world has just been changed and I don't know who or what I am anymore trauma with Lindsay Wagners character. We just rarely saw it) but harder to like. Maybe it's just where TV was in 2007 reflecting a post 9/11, post Iraq war, dark and dangerous world.
Technically good, but a hard show to like. In some ways, the seventies was too silly and corny at times. But this went too far the other way to try and overcompensate. Maybe one day, they could have another go at The Bionic Woman but I fear this probably killed it off for good.
And, I say again. None of this was Michelle Ryans fault. She did the best she could with the part she was given and was the only likeable thing in the entire show for me. Worth a watch for the curious and fans of twenty first century dark TV. Just don't expect to smile much.
On a technical level it was far superior to the seventies show and clearly showed just how far technology and special effects had come on in the thirty years between the two shows.
Where it failed badly was that it completely failed to capture the humour or the warmth of the original show. None of this was Michelle Ryans fault. Michelle Ryans Jaime Sommers - a woman whose life was already difficult then thrown into a new set of circumstances beyond her comprehension in a world where she no longer knows who, if anybody, she can actually trust - is, in some ways, more believable than Lindsay Wagners Jaime Sommers was.
The problem was that the show was just too bloody dark. Completely joyless and humourless. Everyone was just too hard-bitten and dour and cynical. If you can't get your audience to feel any connection to feel any connection or empathy with the people in the show it's doomed. None of the characters are remotely sympathetic or likeable. Whether that would have changed if the show had been allowed to develop, I don't know. The difference for me was that everybody fell in love with Lindsay Wagners Jaime Sommers almost instantly, whereas Michelle Ryans Jaime Sommers was, at least at first, much harder to like as a character. More realistic maybe in some ways (there must have been some sort of post-bionic my whole world has just been changed and I don't know who or what I am anymore trauma with Lindsay Wagners character. We just rarely saw it) but harder to like. Maybe it's just where TV was in 2007 reflecting a post 9/11, post Iraq war, dark and dangerous world.
Technically good, but a hard show to like. In some ways, the seventies was too silly and corny at times. But this went too far the other way to try and overcompensate. Maybe one day, they could have another go at The Bionic Woman but I fear this probably killed it off for good.
And, I say again. None of this was Michelle Ryans fault. She did the best she could with the part she was given and was the only likeable thing in the entire show for me. Worth a watch for the curious and fans of twenty first century dark TV. Just don't expect to smile much.
Tell Your Friends