I love space stories, not like the star wars or Star trek sagas but the ones which tell stories about astronauts from Earth in space travels missions. I love everything that involve other planets, stars and solar systems as well. I've seen a lot of documentary about Mars, Saturn, Jupiter, Pluto and the famous Titan (a Saturn moon) and also a lot of movies about space travels.
This premise is what brought me to watch this series on netflix.
From the very start I understand that this was not what I was looking for since the space things are not the main thing and, overall, it's full of scientific mistakes that even a child would have avoided in making a series or a movie set in deep space.
Let's talk about it first:
1) Communications. It doesn't matter how far they are from Earth, the astronauts can do normal phone calls to Earth whenever they want with absolutely no delay. The fastest thing that exists is light (300'000 km/s) and it's totally impossible that a phone call, even with the most powerful set of satellites, could be faster than light. (Only spaceball 1 in spaceball had a faster "ludicrous speed" but that movie was only a spoof). In real life the robots Nasa sent to Mars could send messages, photos and other documents but they need many whole minutes to reach Earth so it's impossible that a simple cellphones could reach Earth with no delay at all. (the same mistake is made in. "the space.between us" in which a Mars native boy can video chat with an Earth girl like they were in the same room with no delay)
2) How on Earth NASA could put together in such a difficult missions a bunch of astronauts who can't stand each other? The only really explanation is the abused "politically correct" issue which netflix really loves. Races, genders and religions always are the main thing to show in netflix opinion. Who cares about science and logic when we can see. It's no wrong that a space mission has astronauts from the whole Earth, we are all humans: americans, russians, chineses, africans, indians but the astronauts they chose are too much cliched just to remark their nationality and not focusing on the mission.
3) NASA always prepare a mission with months of tests and studies. There's no way that such a long mission can have so many technical issues even from the very beginning with the solar panels which don't unfold
I've talked only about the main mistakes the series have but there are many and many others but I don't want to be too long.
Let's talk about the story itself. I must admit they I liked it and that's the reason why I'm giving 4 stars out of 10 and not less. It it was not set in the space I could have given even 8 stars but unfortunately they chose the wrong set for an emotional family drama like this.
What I like more is the russian astronaut who's the only one who could really pass like an astronaut while all the other cast members, commander included, seem amateurs, expecially the african/british one who can't stand low gravity (how he became an astronaut in the first place?)
Hilary. Swank is anothe thing I liked of the series not because of their astronaut skills (which she lacks) but for her presence. I liked her from "Ps I Love you" and I think she is a really good actress.
That's all I wanted to write. I hope in the future netflix should ask the real NASA some advices before going at full speed in producing a space series.
This premise is what brought me to watch this series on netflix.
From the very start I understand that this was not what I was looking for since the space things are not the main thing and, overall, it's full of scientific mistakes that even a child would have avoided in making a series or a movie set in deep space.
Let's talk about it first:
1) Communications. It doesn't matter how far they are from Earth, the astronauts can do normal phone calls to Earth whenever they want with absolutely no delay. The fastest thing that exists is light (300'000 km/s) and it's totally impossible that a phone call, even with the most powerful set of satellites, could be faster than light. (Only spaceball 1 in spaceball had a faster "ludicrous speed" but that movie was only a spoof). In real life the robots Nasa sent to Mars could send messages, photos and other documents but they need many whole minutes to reach Earth so it's impossible that a simple cellphones could reach Earth with no delay at all. (the same mistake is made in. "the space.between us" in which a Mars native boy can video chat with an Earth girl like they were in the same room with no delay)
2) How on Earth NASA could put together in such a difficult missions a bunch of astronauts who can't stand each other? The only really explanation is the abused "politically correct" issue which netflix really loves. Races, genders and religions always are the main thing to show in netflix opinion. Who cares about science and logic when we can see. It's no wrong that a space mission has astronauts from the whole Earth, we are all humans: americans, russians, chineses, africans, indians but the astronauts they chose are too much cliched just to remark their nationality and not focusing on the mission.
3) NASA always prepare a mission with months of tests and studies. There's no way that such a long mission can have so many technical issues even from the very beginning with the solar panels which don't unfold
I've talked only about the main mistakes the series have but there are many and many others but I don't want to be too long.
Let's talk about the story itself. I must admit they I liked it and that's the reason why I'm giving 4 stars out of 10 and not less. It it was not set in the space I could have given even 8 stars but unfortunately they chose the wrong set for an emotional family drama like this.
What I like more is the russian astronaut who's the only one who could really pass like an astronaut while all the other cast members, commander included, seem amateurs, expecially the african/british one who can't stand low gravity (how he became an astronaut in the first place?)
Hilary. Swank is anothe thing I liked of the series not because of their astronaut skills (which she lacks) but for her presence. I liked her from "Ps I Love you" and I think she is a really good actress.
That's all I wanted to write. I hope in the future netflix should ask the real NASA some advices before going at full speed in producing a space series.
Tell Your Friends