MINOR SPOILERS One of SUPERMAN RETURNS best attributes (treating it's audiences like an adult) may also hurt it's box office potential. In a country where some of the worst reviewed films at the theaters (Da Vinci Code, X3) are also it's biggest hits, SUPERMAN RETURNS may have found greater box office triumph had if it instead treated it's audience like short attention span children. Without sensational controversy and taboo curiosity fueled hype or constant whiz bang pyrotechnics and one liners, SUPERMAN RETURNS with it's balance of reality, consequences, emotion and adventure is a throw back to the late 70's-early 80's, which ironically is an era when most film snobs complain not enough of the current crop of blockbusters take their inspiration from anymore. Now that a film that takes it's emotional core seriously has arrived, the complaint seems to be that the mega-budgeted film would have just been better off with more action, faster, rapid pace editing and calculated funny quip placements, dangled in front of a restless American audience like so many keys on Mom's key chain distracting her toddler child.
Granted, SUPERMAN RETURNS could have indeed used a few of the lighter moments seen in the previews but not in the final product (Ben Hubbard is cut out almost completely), but it would be hard to imagine what should be cut in favor of those moments from the finished product. The film does have it's funny side, however, dominated mainly by scene steelers PARKER POSEY and SAM HUNTINGTON, not to mention bits by the superb Routh's Clark Kent and Sociopathic Lex Luthor played by Kevin Spacey. Spacey, while still very amusing and quick witted, is fairly removed from Gene Hackman's interpretation of the iconic baddie. Where Hackman was excellent as kind of a megalomaniac used car salesman, Spacey is charming, snide, but also downright sadistic. What's interesting is that Spacey's Lex also shows some genuine concern for his loyal side kick / girlfriend (although he is not above putting her life in danger if he arrogantly believes his planning is beyond any real "risk") and seems to know his henchmen so well, that volumes are spoken, or screamed by a distinct look or glance. His hatred for the Man of Steel also goes way beyond Saturday Matinée, mustache twirling revenge, but is a legitimate and calculated lust for vengeance; something he revels in with utter contempt when he gets his chance. When Lex and his crew finally get their hands on Krypton's Last Son, it is such a completely one-sided bit of brutalization that it hurts your heart a little to watch. This scene, more than almost any other in the nearly 2 and a half hour runtime stuck in my head days later. It is realistic and sad...for the moment.
Other stand outs include the much talked about Airplane rescue scene (it is essential to see this scene AT the theaters!) and to a more noble and more human degree JAMES MARSDEN's Richard White. Ricahrd isn't some typical jerk third wheel, but in many ways Superman..without the Superpowers. This makes the dramatic tension all that more compelling. Kate Bosworth is wonderful as Lois, recalling a young Michelle Pfieffer. The most potentially fatal kryptonite of the flick, however, could have been (but thankfully is not) Tristan Lake LeBeau as the 4 year old Jason White. Young actors have a very hard time striking a balance between cute and legitimate. Too knowing and the kid is no longer a kid, but a little person imitating an adult actor. Too cute and you wince in pain. The little guy in Superman Returns, to put it simply, is perfect.
Routh of course had the biggest hurdle in taking on the many faces of SUPERMAN/KAL-EL/CLARK KENT, but in recalling some of Christopher Reeves best qualities (distictive differences between the characters, a natural ability to take on a character who wants only to do good, and of course more than a passing resemblance to Reeve himself) along with some added depth to the part(s) emotional core(s) and humanity and you have a terrific addition to the legacy of actors who have tackled the part. I originally was very unhappy with the choice of Routh, now it's hard for me to imagine another actor today filling the red boots. Routh is the new Superman.
One can only hope that the film has legs, and that in the coming weeks it hold up reasonably well. Pirates of The Caribben 2: (Electric Boogaloo) has been pitted against it in the media, which is unfortunate as PIRATES also looks to be an enjoyable Summer blockbuster. It seems the over emphasis of box office prognosticators has created an atmosphere where only one can be successful. SUPERMAN RETURNS, if it holds up well at the box office has more story to be told, and many possibilities left to explore and it would be sad if we were denied those story lines in favor of a more traditional fast and furious summer actioner in sequels to come. Superfeats and heroics are essential to the Man of Steel's story, but hopefully we will continue to be enlightened to his motivations and humanity as well. And despite whatever misgivings have been blared across blog boards and water coolers across the nation as to the film's big "twist", after watching the very moving moment with Superman and another pivotal character towards the end of the film, I have to say it's unfortunate if you keep a closed mind as you will miss a truly memorable and touching moment not just for this film, but for the entire franchise.
Like the first X-MEN film, there is a lot of time spent on relationships, and while these moments are still very enjoyable, they lay an essential groundwork for future films in the franchise to come. And I for one look forward not only to seeing this movie again, but also the next chapters to be unveiled in the years ahead.
3 out of 5 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends