Spoilers but mostly rants.
Lots of typical DW reviews on here. Meaning the review is "THIS ISN'T MY DOCTOR!" Tennant fans complained Smith was too young. Smith fans complained the older Capaldi was an attempt to recapture classic Who fans. Now many previous fans are complaining HOW CAN THIS ALIEN WHO HAS TWO HEARTS AND NORMALLY A BRITISH ACCENT BE A WOMAN?
The least rational argument I've heard. And to be fair if it we're just a casting point made just to fulfill some ideas of politically correct DW it might have some validity. But really, a character that becomes a completely different person every couple of season's every few years and your upset that for the first time in years it isn't a white guy? Go back to talking about how The Last Jedi ruined the SW franchise. True Whovians will be fine.
Having gotten through that let's get in a real review. The cinematography had improved greatly. The effects were a bit better but the CG with the alien craft/pod/giant purple garlic pod it managed to look like they spent all their money on the logistics of the later crane scene. The new alien threat was creepy as hell. Kind of gross to look at.
The storyline did something you haven't seen since classic Who Instead of the Doctor selecting companions, they got stuck with him (a la Teegan).
It also reintroduced an element of danger by making it dangerous to help the Doctor again by having a character actually die. I seriously thought they were going to Moffat it and have her resurrect the person with left over regeneration energy.
The characters aren't going to be with us for long. Not designed to. I think Ryan is designed to test out the idea of, "will people accept a black Doctor?"
Having said all that, I feel like it was a typical introduction episode. Thought I do feel like the writing is fresher. Chibnall obviously isn't suffering from the burn out Moffat did.
Lots of typical DW reviews on here. Meaning the review is "THIS ISN'T MY DOCTOR!" Tennant fans complained Smith was too young. Smith fans complained the older Capaldi was an attempt to recapture classic Who fans. Now many previous fans are complaining HOW CAN THIS ALIEN WHO HAS TWO HEARTS AND NORMALLY A BRITISH ACCENT BE A WOMAN?
The least rational argument I've heard. And to be fair if it we're just a casting point made just to fulfill some ideas of politically correct DW it might have some validity. But really, a character that becomes a completely different person every couple of season's every few years and your upset that for the first time in years it isn't a white guy? Go back to talking about how The Last Jedi ruined the SW franchise. True Whovians will be fine.
Having gotten through that let's get in a real review. The cinematography had improved greatly. The effects were a bit better but the CG with the alien craft/pod/giant purple garlic pod it managed to look like they spent all their money on the logistics of the later crane scene. The new alien threat was creepy as hell. Kind of gross to look at.
The storyline did something you haven't seen since classic Who Instead of the Doctor selecting companions, they got stuck with him (a la Teegan).
It also reintroduced an element of danger by making it dangerous to help the Doctor again by having a character actually die. I seriously thought they were going to Moffat it and have her resurrect the person with left over regeneration energy.
The characters aren't going to be with us for long. Not designed to. I think Ryan is designed to test out the idea of, "will people accept a black Doctor?"
Having said all that, I feel like it was a typical introduction episode. Thought I do feel like the writing is fresher. Chibnall obviously isn't suffering from the burn out Moffat did.
Tell Your Friends