If you've ever wondered what shameless overacting looks like, look no further than Betty Hutton, who apparently lacks the ability to satisfy role nuances or maintain a specific dialect throughout a performance.
In every scene, Betty yells, mugs, unnecessarily contorts her face and delivers lines with the subtlety and consistency of a 10th grade drama student. The fact that she drifts in and out of a hillbilly dialect is just MST3K/HDTGM-level embarrassing.
Sure, this is considered a classic musical because of the compositions. I get that Hutton has her fans and I certainly don't begrudge them for liking this over-the-top embarrassment of a performance. Would Garland have been better? Not at that point in her life, no, so it's pointless to second guess the casting decision from that angle. Hutton was also a hit name at the time, making her an easy draw for big bucks.
But, let's face it: bad acting is bad acting and Hutton is no stranger to it. Energy is great (see Ann Miller). But Hutton doesn't just teeter on the precipice of overacting, she willingly leaps into the abyss with unrestrained aplomb.
Vastly overrated musical thanks to an embarrassing performance from Hutton.
In every scene, Betty yells, mugs, unnecessarily contorts her face and delivers lines with the subtlety and consistency of a 10th grade drama student. The fact that she drifts in and out of a hillbilly dialect is just MST3K/HDTGM-level embarrassing.
Sure, this is considered a classic musical because of the compositions. I get that Hutton has her fans and I certainly don't begrudge them for liking this over-the-top embarrassment of a performance. Would Garland have been better? Not at that point in her life, no, so it's pointless to second guess the casting decision from that angle. Hutton was also a hit name at the time, making her an easy draw for big bucks.
But, let's face it: bad acting is bad acting and Hutton is no stranger to it. Energy is great (see Ann Miller). But Hutton doesn't just teeter on the precipice of overacting, she willingly leaps into the abyss with unrestrained aplomb.
Vastly overrated musical thanks to an embarrassing performance from Hutton.
Tell Your Friends