Castle of Dreams (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Gritty and realistic
howard.schumann25 September 2019
"The real voyage of discovery lies in not seeing new landscapes but in having new eyes" - Marcel Proust

The innocence of children has been one of the main themes of Iranian cinema in recent years. Films such as Majid Majidi's "Children of Heaven," Abbas Kiarostami's "Where is the Friend's Home?" and Jafar Panahi's "The White Balloon" not only depict the children's innocence, but also their hardships and spiritual strengths. Reza Mirkarimi's ("Daughter") Castle of Dreams (Ghasr-e Shirin), aka "The Sweet Palace," continues in that tradition with the story of two children of considerable charm, Sara (Niousha Alipour) and Ali (Yuna Tadayyon), whose continuing devotion to their disillusioned father, Jalal Moradi (Hamed Behdad, "Sly"), begins to break down the barriers between them and to develop a new understanding of their relationship.

Written by Mohammad Davoudi and Mohsen Gharaie, like Kiarostami's "Taste of Cherry," Castle of Dreams is a road movie that features a depressed and isolated man seeking a way out, but Jalal is very much unlike the introspective and poetic Mr. Badii. Neither a paragon of virtue nor a poster boy for the joys of fatherhood, Jalal is a desperate man bent on avoiding any emotional or financial support for his children. Released from prison after serving time for involuntary manslaughter, the 42-year-old Jalal left his wife and children and moved to another city, but has now returned to his home town two years later to find his wife critically ill. Jalal wishes to profit from his wife's illness by selling her car and moving to Azerbaijan and to leave his children in the care of his sister-in-law, Nasrin (Azadeh Nobahari).

Nasrin's determined husband, however, wants no part of that and lobbies Jalal to take the children with him. He resists but, after what seems to be an interminable length of time pondering the alternatives, grudgingly agrees to take them. Unceremoniously depositing them in the back seat of the old car which does not sound as if it will make it to the next corner, the road trip begins almost 40-minutes into the film. Though Ali is older and more serious than his unbearably cute sister Sara, the impressionable boy believes the story his mother told him about his father living in a magic castle and wants to go there with him, still attached to his dad despite everything that has taken place.

Sara, not comprehending the chaos going on around her, is more concerned with the well-being of her pet turtle Water Color and pressures Jalal to turn the car around to rescue it and bring it with them. After learning that his wife has died, Jalal picks up his girlfriend Najmeh (Zhila Shahi, "Orange Days") whom he introduces to the children as his business partner, but soon begins to berate her for looking like a "floozy." In return, Najmeh calls Jalal a liar and a cheat which, given the character of the man depicted thus far, does not seem unreasonable. A crying Najmeh tells Jalal that she wants to have children with him, but he demurs which prompts her to abruptly get out of the car and find a way home with Jalal's sly assistance.

The journey eventually includes Jalal bribing a policeman who wants to impound his car for reckless driving and Jalal being violently assaulted by his ex-wife's two brothers, for which no reason is provided. The focus of the film, however, is not on the incidents that take place in the present or those in the past but on the evolution of Jalal's character. While the negative picture that is presented of fatherhood may be a hard sell in a nation that prides itself on the strength of the family, Behdad's brilliant performance draws us to him in spite of his lack of connection with others.

Gritty and realistic in the mode of minimalist French films of the past, Castle of Dreams contains no dramatic peaks and valleys, only a constant undercurrent of tension throughout. While Jalal's transformation is subtle and there are no blatant emotional appeals, the children's resilience more than compensates for the film's lack of dramatic urgency. Through Ali and Sara, we get a deeper insight into Jalal's character - his realization of his own loneliness and that of his children and a growing awareness that allows him to consider the notion of living simply and peacefully, turning the hardships of the past into a different vision of what a castle of dreams looks like.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Instead of being caged,I got breathless."
morrison-dylan-fan19 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Nearing the end of downloading titles to watch for the best films of 2019 poll on ICM,I decided to check what movies had come from Iran in 2019. Finding just one title as output from the county in that year,I set off for the castle.

View on the film:

Driving back to a relationship Jalal had left on the tracks 3 years ago, editor/ director Reza Mirkarimi & cinematographer Morteza Hodaei listen in on what Jalal is returning to with jagged wide-shots from the inside of Jalal's car, which obscures the viewer from getting the full vision of the dusty path he is being pushed back into, with splinters of audio nailing the angered frustrations from those Jalal had left behind.

Sitting in the car with Jalal and his children Ali and Sara for the majority of the title, Mirkarimi places the viewer in the middle seat with excellent Iran New Wave (INW) fluid panning shots darting between the pent-up emotions of Jalal landing on the rocks of Sara and Ali's grief and sadness.

Turning the key on Jalal's life after the one-two-punch of being freed from jail and the wife who he had drifted apart from has suddenly died, the screenplay by Mohammad Davoudi and Mohsen Gharaie bring Neo-Noir grit to the INW, in Jalal (a excellent, hard-bitten Hamed Behdad ) being a loner figure who hits back at anyone who mutters questions over where he has been for the last 3 years, going as far as making excuses in order to avoid telling the kids in the back seat that his girlfriend is not just a "friend" sitting next to him.

Reuniting with his own young children after leaving them behind years ago, the writers give Jalal and his kids Ali and Sara (played by the pitch-perfect Niousha Alipour and Yuna Tadayyon) fantastic Neo- Realist stylised INW dialogue, where the passage of time and disconnection they share weighs heavy in the brittle exchanges of Ali and Sara missing their deceased mum, and Jalal finding himself in relationships which he can't merely drive away from.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterpiece,Touching ...
saharfar6 November 2019
The first thing we said when the movie was over: I want to watch this again, right now. This film and the acting is one of the best that i have seen in many years. Hamed Behdad is carrying the scenes in a realistic way thats it's hard to think about anything else during the movie. The shocking truth comes in casual conversations and it nails you in the seat. the young actor and actress are so real, i forgot that this is not a real scenario. I will never forget this film. Congrats to all whom participated for making this movie.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Passionate
RosaGreen558 January 2020
It was a heartbreaking film and the role of Hamed Behdad as Jalal was awesome
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed