Sibling film makers Mark Duplass and Jay Duplass decided to executive produce Young Hearts four days after the production finished filming.
Young Hearts was filmed in Portland, Oregon in 15 days. Nearly all interiors were filmed in Sarah Sherman's neighbor's homes.
Young Hearts premiered at SLAMDANCE in Park City, Utah in 2020 under the name "Thunderbolt In Mine Eye."
Quinn Liebling, Anjini Taneja Azhar, Zachary Ray Sherman, Morgan Demetre and Carter Jon all acted in Netflix's "Everything Sucks!", which was filmed in Oregon in 2017.
Anjini Taneja Azhar lived with Sarah Sherman while filming.