"Marvel Rising: Initiation" Marvel Rising: Heart of Iron (TV Episode 2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Comes short story-wise on several occasions
Horst_In_Translation28 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The title "Marvel Rising: Heart of Iron" of course gives away already that this short film of 44 minutes here takes us into the Marvel universe. And the photo on imdb makes clear it is an animated movie. It is an American production in the English language, even if the names of directors Choi and Gimeno sound Asian/Hispanic. There were many writers in charge of the script here and looking at how udnerwhelming it turned out story-wise eventually, I'd say it is surely a case of too many cooks spoiling the broth. It was released at the end of March 2019, so it is pretty much 9 months old not, but it really is not the child Marvel fans have been longing to see. There are more "Marvel Rising" (short) films from pretty recently, but this is one of the most known. The cast is really female-centered, so in here you will get many double Y chromosome characters, some pretty well-known, others not at all. The famous one swould be Captain Marvel, even if she just appears early on and very late as an observing force basically who judges how capable another character is. She is the easiest to recognize, but Gwen Stacy / Ghost Spider is also not unknown at all. As for those I have never come across before there is that quirrel girl, who also brought in some comic relief and quite a few others. As for male superhero characters, there are some, but none are at the center of the film at all action-wise. Maybe it is a better watch for girls I am not sure. Iron Man is in it too, well sort of. Actually early on, it is a girl who designed her own Iron Man uniform that looks so similar that it takes the other characters a while to figure out it is not really him. Shoes always give girls away don't they? Anyway, so it is again another female character in this uniform, really the central character you could say, but where was the real Iron Man Tony Stark I wondered. There was a massive danger coming from a(n again female) antagonist named Hala, but he just like most of the other Avengers were nowhere to be found. Maybe they did not have the tights to use them? I don't know. It's not important either. The whole general idea here is struggling already because all the heroes are basically teenagers, which makes it difficult to believe they are capable of defending the planet from all those being a danger to it, not just Kree girl Hala.

As for Hala, she confused me too. I mean she managed to hold her own against all the kids early on, but when she managed to gain control over the Iron man uniform and have it (or her?) fight for her evil cause, she just leaves the planet and lets the uniform do the dirty job it seems. Of course at the end good prevailed as expected, but it was a long and strenuous road to victory. Then again, it is just kids. They cannot easily dominate the enemies I guess. They made this decision to make these characters more appealing and easier to identify for the teenage audiences this film was made for I suppose. In addition, they also added bevioral patterns and comic relief that made the characters seem normal like everybody else their age. I am talking about one character crushing on Iron Man for example. Or two other characters being romantically linked to each other in a slightly awkward fashion that involves tentacles. Or also one character not only being an orphan, but also being enough of a nerd that she focused on science and lost all her friends because of that. Or one character that the other people her age do not want to go to a concert with. There is more really. As for comic relief I already mentioned the chubby squirrel girl, but it is not just her (by the way come on if you lost your bracelet, then look at your arm and you know that is the reason), but also her little squirrel that is entertaining, especially when it interacts with this big dog that is able to teleport. Also something you would not find in a film, animated or not, that is mostly for grown-up audiences. So there are solid inclusions and ideas here that could have served as a nice background for a good little superhero movie, but what they eventually made of it in terms of the story at the film's core was just not enough for my liking. This one has its moments and maybe the rating is slightly too low here on imdb (surprises me it is this low actually), but I still think I have to give it a thumbs-down as well. Marvel of course also attracts solid actors and familiar names. These would be the Descendants' Dove Cameron and Teen Wolf Tyler Posey here. But also the others are more experienced in film (not just voice acting) than you'd expect given their ages. But yeah, it's all not enough to make this project really work, even if the animation kept growing on me the longer it went. I say watch something else instead.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Somehow, worse than other Marvel RIsing
bfeldz23 September 2021
The Marvel Rising series has been the epitome of everything wrong with comics and Marvel. Yet somehow, Heart of Iron found ways to be worse. Horribly written with awful and depthless characters.

Someone suggested "Super inclusive and progressive" and sure, if by "super inclusive and progressive" they mean turning characters into shallow and superficial stereotypes, with almost no individuality and all identitarian nonsense. If you want a political and ideological garbage disposal, this show is for you. If you want your kids looking up to stereotypes, seeing people as purely representative of broader ideological and political diatribe, generic teen shallowness and complete lack of character depth, this show is for you.

And the writing, even for a children's so, is sub par. To call this "fan fiction" would be a slight at all fan fiction. I am not sure where they find these "writers" but they don't really know how to write, or at least how to write well. This can't touch shows like Teen Titans Go! Or even older Marvel animation, which has always trailed behind DC animation. But this is a new low standard.

The characters are pointless, copycats of established characters. It's like a bad commercial for a product that makes your children dumber. If stereotypes and cliche characters and broad generalizations are "progressive" then what is "regressive"? In reality, the show is no more "inclusive" than regular Marvel or really most shows these days. It just shoves that "inclusiveness" down your throat until you choke and vomit up a rainbow of stereotypical shallowness.

They seem to think being a "minority" means your ethnicity or sexual expression is more important than your individuality and personality. In fact, they seem to think that your ethnicity and sexual expression are ALL people are. It's a giant step backwards and slap in the face to every "minority", every group of people and every stride towards a loving, empathetic and passionate world. Frankly, it's the modern equivalent of a minstrel show, except they run the full gambit of identities.

But the writing, oh the writing...... I've heard many suggest that "the written word is dead". Well, if it wasn't dead before this Marvel Rising series was created, it certainly is no longer breathing after. Let your kids watch this if you want them to grow up without a brain and with the ability to see the world purely in stereotypes and superficial nonsense.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Poorly made
louiethepitt16 August 2020
Love superheroes, but sadly this feels rush, never heard of this character but feels like a ripoff of Iron Man.... why didn't they create an original hero?... have zero idea... about the cartoon I feel is directed at toddlers but even that would be child abuse... I recommend a Strong pass guys...there are awesome DC cartoons and Anime heroes out there to waste your time on this one.
6 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I Really Like It!
alex-036016 March 2022
Marvel: Rising has a sort of energy that I really love. The art style is beautiful, we get a spotlight on lesser known characters like America Chavez and Ironheart, and I love the energy between Ms. Marvel/Kamala Khan and Squirrel Girl/Doreen Green. I only wish this was a TV Series like Marvel's Spider-Man or Avengers Assemble.

Also I find it odd that some characters that have secret identities in the show are public heroes in the comics, such as America Chavez and Quake, not to mention how confusing the timeline of events of the Marvel Animated Universe.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
So good!
AnnaPagrati31 August 2021
Yes, I adored it! Such an intriguing plot, it's so captivating!
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed