I struggle and fail to understand why the BBC basically justified the existence of this thing by allowing it to continue on air for close to 4 years because fundamentally, this show is just a big batch of nothing-burger: There is just literally nothing new or creative or fun or exciting or engaging or even remotely entertaining about this show to begin with. It is just a televisual black hole of pure nothing.
When you have such a format as this that is as absurdly bland as it sounds (probably even worse actually than that of Impossible), where you just have to answer a series of questions (the large majority of which go way in over your head rather quickly anyway) whilst at the same time you faff about trying to catch some random-sized balls from midair and yet it simultaneously commits the cardinal gameshow sin of immediately losing your audience's interest and/or boring them half to sleep, that's when you know there's a huge problem and that something clearly got lost in translation here. Honestly, the only perfect analogy I can use to describe this format is that it is like you're being served a cheeseburger without the cheese or a pepperoni pizza without the pepperonis or an ice cream without any of the sauces or even a chocolate cake without the icing.
Now don't get me wrong here, I have genuine huge respect for Paddy McGuinness (especially when it comes to his personal life) and I don't think he is entirely a bad presenter per se (e.g. I am of the opinion that Take Me Out was his best presenting job by far and Take Me Out was in itself a legitimately great show when it aired in my book; still a tragic shame though that ITV cancelled it after 11 seasons) but I'm sadly not gonna lie, he is just not the right choice to present a show like this and it further cements the fact that the BBC have completely wasted his presenting talent in recent years with an extremely unfortunate line of generic dreck such as this, I Can See Your Voice (which I legit have little to zero interest in checking out anyway), latter-day Top Gear and even latter-day A Question of Sport that lead to nowhere, consistently tank in the ratings and then immediately get taken off air after two or more seasons because the BBC are so pathetically desperate these days to force us peasants to pay the licence fee.
In conclusion, if you're in the mood for a gameshow that is fun, engaging, exciting and most importantly entertaining, prepare yourself to be immensely disappointed because this show frankly lacks any of that and my advice instead is just stick to watching either Tenable, Tipping Point or even The Chase.
My overall rating for Catchpoint: 0.5/10.
