Acting and camera work was good. Story however is full of holes.
6 Reviews
Good acting bad story
gobie292029 December 2018
Failed to Stay Focus
starlight7023 October 2018
This movie has so many loopholes that I shook my head in pity for the director's work. Below par. It did not make sense for residents to continue staying in a haunted house, without the question of the ghosts/spirits unsolved.
And it tried to pull a last minute trick to be a tear-jerker. Seriously? What did the movie tried to be? A ghost film or a sad movie?
And it tried to pull a last minute trick to be a tear-jerker. Seriously? What did the movie tried to be? A ghost film or a sad movie?
An incoherent scramble of a movie...
paul_haakonsen20 January 2019
With my fondness for the Asian cinema and Hong Kong cinema in particular, of course I jumped at the chance to get to sit down and watch "The Lingering". As if there ever was any doubt.
What directors Ho Pong Mak and Derrick Tao thought made an effective horror movie, was apparently using loud and sudden noises constantly. But 90% of the times there was nothing following these loud sudden scare sounds, which meant that it became a nuisance to bear witness to, and it didn't work in favor of the movie.
I don't know what kind of stale tea writers Edmond Wong and Dong Zheng were drinking while writing the storyline, because the storyline and plot was just ludicrous. Towards the end of the movie, when it was revealed what was actually going on, nothing up to that point made any sense - the strange happenings, the apparitions, and so forth. It was all just a random mess of nonsense.
They had an adequate cast ensemble to perform in the movie, just a shame that they had next to nothing to work with in terms of script, storyline and plot.
There was nothing scary about "The Lingering", aside from the fact that it all felt like it was just made up as directors Ho Pong Mak and Derrick Tao went along.
If you enjoy Hong Kong horror movies, then there are far, far better choices readily available, and I can't really think of a single reason of recommending this movie.
What directors Ho Pong Mak and Derrick Tao thought made an effective horror movie, was apparently using loud and sudden noises constantly. But 90% of the times there was nothing following these loud sudden scare sounds, which meant that it became a nuisance to bear witness to, and it didn't work in favor of the movie.
I don't know what kind of stale tea writers Edmond Wong and Dong Zheng were drinking while writing the storyline, because the storyline and plot was just ludicrous. Towards the end of the movie, when it was revealed what was actually going on, nothing up to that point made any sense - the strange happenings, the apparitions, and so forth. It was all just a random mess of nonsense.
They had an adequate cast ensemble to perform in the movie, just a shame that they had next to nothing to work with in terms of script, storyline and plot.
There was nothing scary about "The Lingering", aside from the fact that it all felt like it was just made up as directors Ho Pong Mak and Derrick Tao went along.
If you enjoy Hong Kong horror movies, then there are far, far better choices readily available, and I can't really think of a single reason of recommending this movie.
Family drama with some mild social criticism and a few horror elements
kluseba7 December 2020
The Lingering is a drama with mild horror influences and a very positive message. The story in three parts revolves around Dawa, a young boy who lives in an old family mansion with his caring mother Qingyi. One year, the family father doesn't come home for the New Year celebrations and the mansion gets haunted by a mysterious spirit instead. As a young adult, Dawa leaves his devastated mother and the creepy mansion behind to move to a bigger city and get rich and famous. As an adult in his thirties, Dawa returns home with his girlfriend when he must verify whether the body of a drowned woman is his mother's or not.
The first twenty-five minutes taking place in the eighties and the final fifty-five minutes taking place in present-day are connected through some flashbacks that show character development and the negative progression of a complicated mother-son relationship. These connections offer some great ideas but are often lacking fluidity as they pop up randomly and are sometimes unnecessarily repetitive.
The movie's greatest strength is its message about spending time with your loved ones that is much more precious than any career that might provide money and fame. The film quietly criticizes the alienation, greed and selfishness of the contemporary Chinese society. This becomes most obvious when observing characters such as Dawa's self-centered business partner who likes to insert random English vocabulary in his sentences or the obnoxious real estate agent who goes as far as manipulating Dawa in order to force him into selling his family mansion.
The movie has a few mild horror scenes but is overall rather a family drama. The opening twenty-five minutes are quite atmospheric and have an authentic vintage spirit. Another highlight is the present-day scene at a hotel when Dawa and his girlfriend seem to get attacked by an evil spirit. The creepy scene in the hospital restroom also manages to grab attention.
The film's weakest element however is the story that has quite a few holes. It's never explained for instance whose spirit is haunting the couple in the hotel room. The movie ends with a twist that is supposed to be tearjerking but feels completely exaggerated.
In the end, you should watch The Lingering if you are in the mood of watching a family drama with some mild social criticism and a few horror elements. If you were simply expecting a creepy Asian horror movie, you might get disappointed however and should rather explore the Taiwanese The Tag-Along franchise.
The first twenty-five minutes taking place in the eighties and the final fifty-five minutes taking place in present-day are connected through some flashbacks that show character development and the negative progression of a complicated mother-son relationship. These connections offer some great ideas but are often lacking fluidity as they pop up randomly and are sometimes unnecessarily repetitive.
The movie's greatest strength is its message about spending time with your loved ones that is much more precious than any career that might provide money and fame. The film quietly criticizes the alienation, greed and selfishness of the contemporary Chinese society. This becomes most obvious when observing characters such as Dawa's self-centered business partner who likes to insert random English vocabulary in his sentences or the obnoxious real estate agent who goes as far as manipulating Dawa in order to force him into selling his family mansion.
The movie has a few mild horror scenes but is overall rather a family drama. The opening twenty-five minutes are quite atmospheric and have an authentic vintage spirit. Another highlight is the present-day scene at a hotel when Dawa and his girlfriend seem to get attacked by an evil spirit. The creepy scene in the hospital restroom also manages to grab attention.
The film's weakest element however is the story that has quite a few holes. It's never explained for instance whose spirit is haunting the couple in the hotel room. The movie ends with a twist that is supposed to be tearjerking but feels completely exaggerated.
In the end, you should watch The Lingering if you are in the mood of watching a family drama with some mild social criticism and a few horror elements. If you were simply expecting a creepy Asian horror movie, you might get disappointed however and should rather explore the Taiwanese The Tag-Along franchise.
Combining a haunted house with a mother son tear jerking story, and it works
WisdomsHammer20 January 2021
Okay, first a word of warning and a confession - the warning: If you're rather literal minded and analytical, you might not like this movie. I would say this movie focuses more on emotional aspects than rational ones. The confession: I read some of the other reviews here before posting mine, and I saw points in both the good and bad reviews.
The people who didn't like this seemed to have problems with questions left unanswered, things that didn't seem to make sense, and the mixture of an emotional drama with a ghost story, wanting it to be one or the other.
For those trying to figure out how the ghost can be this or that person, let's just say it was a demon impersonating all of them. Or something. The scares were still effective enough for me to be satisfying, and I can make up my own reasons for the apparitions with a little creativity. I can see why people had a problem with this, though. It is a little confusing if you linger on it.
Thankfully, for me at least, the story moved along and kept me engaged. The pacing was good. The scary parts were scary, and the emotional parts were emotional, and this movie did both better than a lot of movies I've seen lately. And yeah, it made me cry. I don't think I've ever seen a movie that's this effective at horror AND drama, so I definitely recommend giving it a try.
The people who didn't like this seemed to have problems with questions left unanswered, things that didn't seem to make sense, and the mixture of an emotional drama with a ghost story, wanting it to be one or the other.
For those trying to figure out how the ghost can be this or that person, let's just say it was a demon impersonating all of them. Or something. The scares were still effective enough for me to be satisfying, and I can make up my own reasons for the apparitions with a little creativity. I can see why people had a problem with this, though. It is a little confusing if you linger on it.
Thankfully, for me at least, the story moved along and kept me engaged. The pacing was good. The scary parts were scary, and the emotional parts were emotional, and this movie did both better than a lot of movies I've seen lately. And yeah, it made me cry. I don't think I've ever seen a movie that's this effective at horror AND drama, so I definitely recommend giving it a try.
This Film Will Made You Cry
ymyuseda17 October 2018
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
