Expectations were not massively high. 2018 did see some good Hallmark films, but your expectations are dampened a bit if you are not a fan of some of the actors. Jessica Lowndes usually does not do much for me and Jen Lilley is wildly inconsistent dependent on her character. Have generally found Marc Rosner quite amiable though, so expectations were not completely low. Hallmark have done quite a number of decent and more films before and since, so there was hope.
'Yes I Do' didn't deliver sadly. Am not a fan of too many of the June Weddings films from Hallmark (with a small group of exceptions, as generally they tend to be more of the same plot wise and with very similar strengths and flaws), and 'Yes I Do' does nothing to change my mind. Hallmark did do a lot worse certainly, before and since, there have certainly been worse June Weddings films (in all the years that that that block has been occurring) but they also did a lot better on both counts.
The best thing about 'Yes I Do' is the easy going and charming performance of Rosner.
Also thought that the production values were good, with the scenery being particularly beautiful.
Having said all of that, 'Yes I Do' had a lot wrong in my view. Lilley is ill at ease and tries too hard, and also found her character too self absorbed and manipulative. Have seen a few good performances from Lowndes but also a lot of bad ones, and this is one of the one note wooden ones that is for me seen a lot from her. Didn't care for any of the characters, other than Rosner's to begin with but later on he began to dull and frustrate.
For me, the romantic chemistry was very underdeveloped and bland, nothing looking natural or genuine. The script is very stilted, especially Lilley's with so many incomplete sounding sentences that come over as gobbledegook. The story is very predictable, has very little charm, heart or lightness, is very forced in conflict and dragged out. Did find it too easily resolved and there is nothing distinctive about the direction. The music is also far too loud and constant.
In conclusion, weak. 3/10.